4 ms·
"dealing with bad actors", as the author puts it, is censorship by another name. Anything truly a public space is going to be filled with things you don't like
by sneak 7y ago
"dealing with bad actors", as the author puts it, is censorship by another name.
Anything truly a public space is going to be filled with things you don't like seeing. That's the messy part of real freedom for a whole crowd of people.
I recently wrote about 2k words on this exact topic:
From https://sneak.berlin/20200211/instagram/ https://sneak.berlin/20200211/instagram/ :
> For a moment, put aside the fact that you may or may not want to read any of that, or spend time thinking about any of that. Any time that doesn’t happen, considering how many people are on the internet and the theoretical ideal of any-to-any communication, then some communications are being censored (or you’re posting about the weather/your kids). The why and the how of that censorship should interest you, even if you like or benefit from it most of the time, such as not seeing constant spam in your DMs.
> Who is permitted to create accounts to speak? What money, rights, privacy, or information must they give up to do so? Who doesn’t have access to the prerequisites for an account and is excluded from the public square? How many different accounts are people permitted? Can people create new accounts anonymously? How much or how often are they permitted to post? On which topics? How many people are they permitted to message? You can’t follow every single account on Twitter, for example. You can’t DM a million people in one day.
- netsharc 7y agoTo anyone who read through those 2k words: Is it worth reading (after clicking away a "subscribe to my newsletter!" dialog), or is it just some guy's mental masturbation? (Hah, on the topic of things one doesn't like seeing...). I scrolled to the end and I think sneak concluded with "delete social media, send emails to each other". Then again, people who think they're highly philosophical enough to be offering newsletter subscriptions are probably not worth reading.
- bovermyer 7y agoSounds like you're OK with trolls and death threats. Should I assume you originate that kind of content?
- Mediterraneo10 7y ago> Should I assume you originate that kind of content? No, you shouldn’t. Slashdot (in its golden age, which was also a golden age of inventive trolling) and 4Chan has shown that there are a subset of internet users who, while not creators of that kind of content themselves, actually enjoy the trolling, it brings them merriment.
- morceauxdebois 7y agoThen why are you here on the dictatorship of HN instead of Gab or 8chan?
- sneak 7y agoTo answer your question directly, because websites aren't citizenship. I read a lot of different webpages, with varying levels of quality content. HN, Gab, and 8chan are among the list of websites I have loaded in my browser before. I imagine you've visited them at least once too - or do you rely entirely on conjecture and gossip to tell you what they contain? Forget about that, though. This isn't about any specific website. Indulge me with a hypothetical. Imagine for a moment a future in which a web browser exists on par with something like a Gopher or Usenet client: a historical curiosity, used only by a tiny fraction of weird people, a few thousand worldwide, tops. The majority of content is posted and consumed via native apps, communicating with centralized services from cryptographically secured devices that do not allow any sort of inspection, debugging, tampering, ad blocking, memory dumping, hot patching, or other runtime-modification fuckery. It's an end-to-end chain, determined entirely by a small group of people at TSMC, Apple, Comcast/Cox/et c, Facebook, and Google. The apps all still use HTTP (with TLS) to talk to their APIs, of course. But you can't go to webpages, even ones you don't like, because there aren't any. You can't start a new website, because nobody uses browsers any longer. This is the trajectory we're on. It has nothing to do with whether you like whether or not specific sites like Gab or 8chan exist or not, or where you fall on the freezepeach spectrum of opinion. Now, out of the hypothetical. Let's talk today. These censored platforms are engaging in an all-out assault on the web. Instagram has banned hyperlinks. Browsers on mobile cannot be extended via plugins or extensions. Gmail is censoring inbound emails not sent from a small whitelist of providers. Google Chrome is about to defang effective adblocking via a plugin API change. Apple, in their iOS, has hidden the Taiwanese flag in mainland China, and has replaced the gun emoji with a picture of a squirt gun worldwide. There's no hack or workaround for this. Entire swaths of potential businesses have been prevented as a result of this type of overarching design: bake censorship into everything. If the world continues on the path it's on, soon the web will be gone and mass publishing will be centrally controlled, as mass publishing has been for almost the entirety of the history of mass publishing. The free and open web where virtually anyone can start building an audience was an anomaly, a first of its kind in history, and several extremely large and well-funded organizations, Facebook and Apple primarily among them, are working to bring an end to this historical deviation. I really, really don't want that to happen. And it has positively nothing at all to do with the sites you listed.
- krapp 7y ago>"dealing with bad actors", as the author puts it, is censorship by another name. First, one must accept that bad actors exist, and that all forms of moderation are not merely attempts at political or cultural oppression. Second, one must accept that all public spaces, both online and offline, enforce some degree of restriction on how one can legitimately interact with that space. I cannot, for example, walk nude in any public place, or shout obscenities at people with a megaphone without suffering both social and legal repercussions. Those repercussions are the result of society, even in the context of a "public" space, attempting to deal with a bad actor. Online, one has the further restrictions imposed by the architecture of the software itself, beyond whatever rules are enforced by the nature and moderation of the platform. Hacker News won't let me make death threats or dox people, and the software won't let me upload pornographic images. So, yes, dealing with bad actors is censorship. By your definition, merely requiring participants to obey the law is censorship. But "censorship" at that point becomes so abstract and general a concept that it ceases to become a threat to anyone but anarchists and bad actors, and becomes self-evidently necessary to have any kind of a civil society or constructive dialogue to everyone else. Also, it seems weird to see an attempt at a full-throated defense of maximalist freedom of speech from someone who claims to require an NDA with a non disparagement clause for basic social interaction[0]. [0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22282579 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22282579
- sneak 7y ago> I cannot, for example, walk nude in any public place To use your example: do you think this is reasonable or just? Do you think it’s a sane thing to use force to enforce such a thing? > Also, it seems weird to see an attempt at a full-throated defense of maximalist freedom of speech from someone who claims to require an NDA with a non disparagement clause for basic social interaction If that’s what you read from that post or that comment, I have done a terrible job of communicating. You seem to have misread a discussion of social media’s corporate censorship into “full-throated defense of maximalist freedom of speech”, which it is absolutely not. If you re-read it carefully you will not find that conclusion supporter anywhere in the text—I specifically avoided it because I do not hold those views. Then, again, when you parsed the circumstances under which I formally ask people to keep my private information private: it is drastically far removed from “basic social interaction”. You seem pretty bent on fiercely mischaracterizing the things I have said or do. If you’re not actively trolling and really have sincerely read these beliefs into the words that I wrote, perhaps a third bit of my recent writing may be relevant to you: https://sneak.berlin/20191201/american-communication/ https://sneak.berlin/20191201/american-communication/ I can only tell you that your beliefs of my views, articles, and life are inaccurate and not supported by the data available. In the event you are actively trolling, well done. I slept on your comment before replying, because few things in the world make me type more fiercely than people making demonstrably false statements of fact about things I do or believe.
- dredmorbius 7y agoCensorship, as with policing, is occasionally necessary. It should be kept to the minimum level sufficient. But time and again has proved that lack of effective moderation is far more fatal. The people who bring quality discourse go elsewhere.
- sneak 7y agoDepends on the forum, I think. When all social communication happens via app on one or two platforms, and a dozen people have full access to every private communication for billions of people and the ability to decide what communications you can and cannot transmit via the primary and sometimes exclusive methods you use to speak to your friends and family, an extremely dangerous situation results. It is within the power of Facebook, for example to selectively allow or disallow discussion of COVID/nCoV based on user, region, geolocation, location history, et c - even in DMs, even on Instagram or WhatsApp. Imagine if a regime insisted that they censor a specific term or set of terms within their country, or be blocked GFW-style. I doubt it’d even require that much new code. They already have DM censorship mechanisms in place to combat spam and other forms of automated messaging. When you have no other contact info for those with whom you communicate, it gives them a point and click information blackout ability, even for “private”, person-to-person communications. Everything from protests to genocide can be made impossible to discuss, and thus invisible. They have full location history for a lot of users, too. Imagine them temporarily shutting off DMs for every user who has ever visited a specific location for the duration of some national security emergency specified by a government. Only temporary, of course - but suddenly the protesters of the concentration camps can’t send or receive any messages from anyone. Nobody else notices or is affected, so it doesn’t even make the news. It’s an extremely dangerous state of affairs. I don’t even think Facebook realizes what a huge menace they have inadvertently produced, if for no other reason that I don’t think the national military in the country where most of Facebook’s SREs reside has pushed the issue with machine guns yet. Those guys don’t mess around.
- dredmorbius 7y agoThat problem isn't moderation, but monopolisation. Power corrupts.