5 ms·
I'm confused by the portrayal of these as mental models. These are aphorisms[1]. A mental model is a reduced-complexity representation of something that allows
by jvanderbot 7y ago
I'm confused by the portrayal of these as mental models. These are aphorisms[1]. A mental model is a reduced-complexity representation of something that allows prediction or estimation of something that is otherwise incomprehensible[2].
This "Map is not the territory" one in particular is more of a word of wisdom or admonition against oversimplification than a process simplification that allows quick decision making.
Second-order-thinking is not a mental model. It is a way of constructing mental models about things. You can add second-order-thinking to your mental model of how stones roll down hills or how people will react to your speech. They must be interrogated as you contemplate actions to determine the best outcome, and therefore the best action[3].
TFA is clickbait.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aphorism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aphorism
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mental_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mental_model
3. http://www.modeltheory.org/papers/2005HistoryMentalModels.pdf http://www.modeltheory.org/papers/2005HistoryMentalModels.pd...
- andrewflnr 7y agoNot all of them are aphorisms. "Circle of competence" is closer to what you could call a "model", even if it is pretty trivial. I'm pretty convinced now that part of the problem with the Mental Models meme is that they aren't all the same kind of thing.
- jvanderbot 7y agoCircle of competence is a guiding principle of where to trust your models. It is not a model. How can I "query" the model to "predict" an outcome about my competence at a highly general level? I can't, but I can query a model of (e.g.,) an interviewer to see how he might respond to a joke, get a response, and then apply a high value of uncertainty to that response because it is outside my circle of competence (telling jokes is not something I'm good at). "Don't trust your unvetted models" is a better way of saying this.