3 ms·
> Also of course the Navy doesn't repair all of it's own ships :) I can think of two systems with obvious benefits: 1. The Navy repairs its own ships. The big
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> Also of course the Navy doesn't repair all of it's own ships :)
I can think of two systems with obvious benefits:
1. The Navy repairs its own ships. The big benefits here are that you don't have to let anyone else access -- or see -- the ships, and you can perform repairs in the field to the extent that's possible. (For replacing nuts, it's certainly possible.) This requires two types of training: knowledge of the ship's specifications, and skill in performing repairs.
2. The manufacturer repairs the ships. This makes it a lot more difficult to receive repair, but it has similar secrecy benefits, and the manufacturer is well positioned to know how to repair the ship and what is or isn't important. You don't need to train anybody in anything as long as you have perfect, total confidence in the manufacturer.
The Navy here picked the option of having the ship repaired in random foreign shipyards where nobody knew the specs. That's a compromise that advantages ease of getting repairs -- but you lose out on the idea that the person performing repairs knows what constitutes good working order and what doesn't. I struggle to see the advantages; you get more ease of repair and more reliability by doing it yourself.
- rwmurrayVT 7y agoThe Navy does do minor repairs at sea and pier-side at Naval Stations. The majority of the work pier side is a continuation of an availability that overran time. It's very common these days unfortunately.. When the ship comes into a commercial yard for availability it is stripped down of confidential equipment. All of the radar/sonar/fire control/damage control equipment comes off. The work done in the yard is primarily mechanical. Deck inserts, foundation repair, lube oil system, oily waste, etc. I will install the foundation for a SPQ-9b antenna, but I will never see the antenna. At the end of the availability the combat systems engineers from MARMC/SWRMC will come out, install the equipment, record all "installed" alignment information, and program the systems. The major new shipbuilders are rarely in the business of ship repair. They're too busy building new ships. General Dynamics is probably one of the few in the new build and repair business. When the ships come into a commercial shipyard the work items are all specced out by the planning yard. That's typically Huntington Ingalls in Mississippi or Bath Ironworks. The days of foreign shipyards is all but over as far as I know. They brought the USS Cole all the way back to the USA on the Blue Marlin. In fact, she went to Pascagoula, but I don't know if it was to Huntington Ingalls or VT Halter. I'd imagine HI.