11 ms·
Can’t say that’s a surprise. I wasn’t following the Gem but I sure wonder what the appeal of a skinny phone was supposed to be. It’s like trying to make a two
by dangus 7y ago
Can’t say that’s a surprise.
I wasn’t following the Gem but I sure wonder what the appeal of a skinny phone was supposed to be.
It’s like trying to make a two door minivan. All phones look the same just like how all cars look the same for a reason - we have converged on the most useful design that works for everyone.
- dsr_ 7y agoThere's a 2-door minivan design which might work: conventional driver's door, and a full folding or retractable passenger's side door that opens the full length of the vehicle, with an overhang to keep the rain off. I don't know if the novelty would be worth the other trade-offs, though.
- speedgoose 7y agoThe Peugeot 1007 or the Renault Avantime did explore the two doors minivans concept, without much success. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peugeot_1007 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peugeot_1007 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renault_Avantime https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renault_Avantime
- dsr_ 7y agoI count three doors on each of those.
- speedgoose 7y agoYou can probably ask the dealer to weld the trunk if you insist.
- Causality1 7y agoI hate the skinny phone trend. Rather than read a page of text then scroll to the next page, I tend to read the content of the middle third of the vertical space on my screen and then drag the next section up. I'd much prefer a 16:9 or even 16:10 screen.
- andrepd 7y agoSpeak for yourself. It drives me absolutely insane that I simply cannot buy a recent phone today which is smaller than the largest phablets sold in 2014. This is bonkers.
- aeyes 7y agohttps://www.unihertz.com/jelly-pro https://www.unihertz.com/jelly-pro edited for better link
- coldpie 7y agoAndroid 7? Uh, no.
- Arnt 7y agoThey updated to 8.1 and I got a security update not many months ago. It's a fine phone for some people. It runs the apps I need to run and is tiny, and timewaste apps are unattractive. BUT the battery lifetime. https://rant.gulbrandsen.priv.no/jelly https://rant.gulbrandsen.priv.no/jelly is verbiage about.
- gruez 7y ago>They updated to 8.1 and I got a security update not many months ago. That's still pretty bad considering phones from as far back as 2014 are getting Android 9 through LineageOS (nightly builds, up to date Android security patch level).
- Arnt 7y agoHow? Take the Moto G4 Play, for example. One of my daughters has one, so I care, and it's listed on the LineageOS site. How do I get an up to date Android security patch level for that? Or the Redmi Note 3 or Sony Z5C, both also in the device list at lineageos.org. I don't care, those aren't in use, but how would I get new security patches?
- _fs 7y agoMaybe thats why I have not purchased a phone since the Iphone SE came out. Can't stand large phones. I must be alone in this thinking, because so far, no manufactures are going back to small form factors. I want my phone for music, driving directions, calls, a pocket camera, and occasional texts. I do not need or want my phone to be my primary media device. I have an ipad for that.
- jolmg 7y ago> I do not need or want my phone to be my primary media device. I have an ipad for that. It might be partly that I have big hands, so despite smaller phones being more comfortable to hold, big phones aren't that bothersome for me. Maybe because of that, I would never buy a tablet. My phone can do more than a tablet can, so getting a tablet would just be paying twice for no reason. If my phone doesn't suffice for something, that's where my laptop comes in. With a phone and a laptop in hand, a tablet is very much useless to me.
- wlesieutre 7y agoI can take handwritten notes and sketches on my tablet while in splitscreen with a second app (slack, browser, mindmap, video lecture, whatever), and can't imagine trying to do that on a phone. Switching to a laptop wouldn't do well for me either, typing notes has never helped me learn or remember anything, and I can't draw on it. With a Surface/Yoga/similar you get the option to draw on it, but I used to have a Surface Pro and it's frankly not a very good tablet. Even if you have a stylus with a big phone, it's more of an equivalent to a moleskine style notebook. Certainly has its uses, but it's not a replacement for a full size pad of paper. I have a tablet, so I would never buy a big phone. If I want a device so big that it requires two hands to operate effectively, I might as well get my iPad out.
- jolmg 7y ago> I can take handwritten notes and sketches on my tablet Touché. I don't need to do that, but I can agree that it's a good use-case for a tablet. > typing notes has never helped me learn or remember anything, and I can't draw on it. For me, the main benefit of typed notes is that you can search them better. I don't imagine you can search for hand-written text among all sketches on your tablet. Also, if I ever needed to take notes on a classroom setting, typing also brings the benefit of being able to do it without having to look down. Or at least, it's easier and faster to type blindfolded than to hand-write blindfolded. You can keep your attention to the front of the room that way. > With a Surface/Yoga/similar you get the option to draw on it, but I used to have a Surface Pro and it's frankly not a very good tablet. Probably not as ergonomic, I suppose. If I ever needed to draw sketches electronically, I would prefer to do it on my convertible laptop simply because the ergonomics of a tablet are not enough to outweigh all other benefits that a laptop bring. Realistically speaking though, when I (rarely) need to sketch or hand-write, I use a paper notebook. Different people have different needs.
- notyourday 7y agoAs my wife said "They are about to find out that no one wants a cable remote".
- microtherion 7y agoI had the opposite reaction: Seeing the pictures, I found the form factor quite appealing in theory. Wasn't the Gem supposed to be a statement against the trend of making phones media consumption devices?
- anigbrowl 7y agoi saw someone talking about a blackberry-style Android phone the other day with a square screen and people were going nuts for it, even as they were making fun of its huge size. I sort of want one myself, the ruggedness and battery life are an OK trade-off with size and weight. https://www.unihertz.com/ https://www.unihertz.com/ We have not 'converged on the most useful design'. Equilibrium points are often just the lowest common denominator as a technology matures enough to become commodified. Then you start to see a variety of alternatives optimised for different use cases and market entry becomes more affordable to smaller players.
- p1necone 7y agoThe other big problem would be app support, how many devs are going to patch their app to look right on the wacky aspect ratio that a tiny fraction of a percent of the market uses.
- megablast 7y ago> I wasn’t following the Gem but I sure wonder what the appeal of a skinny phone was supposed to be. Do people really think there is no variance in the world? That if they don't want it, no one will?
- hbosch 7y agoIf there was a demand for this product, it would exist and this company wouldn't be shutting down.
- afandian 7y agoNo, we have hit on a demand curve that maximises profits. McDonalds and similar fast food businesses shift a lot of units, so it probably makes good business sense to keep doing that. Doesn't mean it's universally appealing. Of course diversity is by definition the opposite of mass market. I was saddened by the recent BlackBerry news too. There aren't many phones out there for those who find physical keyboards more accessible.
- chewz 7y agoThere is a large population of consumers that live within their phones 24/7 and they appreciate large screens for consuming content. But there is also small population of users (me, anybody else?) who don't. I use a phone to make rare calls, read text messages, play music on the train and occasionally for location. It is perhaps because I have my laptop at hand for most of the time. Recently I have lost large smartphone and had been using iPhone 5S and it is so small, sturdy and lightweight. I can put it in my pocket and I can replace it for $75. Perfect. So now I am in a market for a smallish smartphone.
- ken 7y agoThat's an interesting case, because there's actually a lot of variety in cars. In my circle of friends, everyone has a very different vehicle. We've got an SUV, a hatchback, a sedan, a pickup truck, a supermini, a sport wagon, a motorcycle, a cargo van, a minivan, etc. The powertrains aren't even similar: there's electric and internal combustion, gasoline and diesel, 2/3/4/5/6 cylinders, inline and flat and V, longitudinal and transverse mounting, turbocharged and naturally aspirated, automatic and manual transmissions, front/rear/all wheel drive, etc. (I know someone who even had a rotary engine, but he sold it a few years ago.) (And that's just the last <10 vehicles I've been in!) I'm not seeing a lot of "convergence" yet. Vehicles are diverse because our needs are diverse. It's a shame our phones aren't. Where is the truck smartphone, for people who need something tough to carry their digital 4x8 plywood sheets, or the motorcycle smartphone, for people who want something sleek and fast? All I see is the "crossover SUV" smartphone: tries to do everything, and ends up not being the best at any of them. Everyone I know seems to complain that phones aren't good at the one area they care about, so they keep buying the next new phone that's marginally better at everything, and inevitably worse at a few of the things they care about. We're not post-convergence, we're pre-divergence.