5 ms·
> said an estimated £906m would be spent I wonder how exactly it costs this much? What is the money spent on? Lets imagine the 'MVP' census. A printed 10 p
by londons_explore 7y ago
> said an estimated £906m would be spent
I wonder how exactly it costs this much? What is the money spent on?
Lets imagine the 'MVP' census. A printed 10 page document (£0.45), mailed to each household (£0.61), in an envelope (£0.02), times 27.6 million houses. Return mailing costs another £0.61+0.02. Scan every sheet. OCR it (free). Hand-enter 1% of responses where OCR errors are excessive. 276,000 documents hand entered at 5 minutes per document, £10/hr. £0.0083/household. Total costs: £47M
Cost of running a few trial runs of one 10,000 house town or city to perfect the process: £100k
Pay for a year 1 statistician to make graphs, one social scientist to design questions, one manager for the team of printing/scanning/hand-entering people, one IT person to keep/archive the data and get it on the web, and a head of department. Also a little office. Total fixed costs £800k.
The whole thing can seemingly be done for 5% of the quoted cost. And that excludes any potential efficiencies gained by having an app to collect responses, or bulk discounts from postage companies. Also, while a redacted version of the full dataset is published, I would expect the government department to also offer commercial statistics services on the non-redacted dataset where such analysis doesn't impact customer privacy. That should earn them tens of millions at least.
- ben_w 7y ago61p is second class standard letter weighing up to 100g without any extra guarantees of delivery. As it’s a legal requirement to do the census, I’d use the price estimate for the signed deliveries; as it’s meant to cover a household and is quite long, I’d estimate the 100-250g/large letter price band; together, that’s £2.52 each way.
- Tenoke 7y agoThese are more or less the absolute minimum cost for doing it - and when has anything beyond an MVP cost the absolute minimum? Any real-world project, especially at that scale has much more external costs. There is also enforcement, publicising, security handling, approvals, way more than 1 person to come up with the questions (1 random employee designing the census would be such a waste if you get an average social scientist, that it's ridiculous to propose), compliance, double-checking, etc. etc. Going from 47m to 906m - when you account for the costs that exist in the real world for something as big and comprehensive like this - is actually fairly reasonable.
- crispyporkbites 7y agoIf you can beat the quoted costs, put a bid in for the contract.
- pjc50 7y ago> OCR it (free) Nothing at this scale is ever free, and handwriting OCR is terrible. The current census process includes a quantity of in-person question-asking; I don't know how much of the cost that makes up but it can only be considerable. Data protection and information security issues are probably considerable too.
- estel 7y agoThey employ 17,000 field staff as part of the census: https://census.gov.uk/jobs/ https://census.gov.uk/jobs/ > Cost of running a few trial runs of one 10,000 house town or city to perfect the process: £100k The census trial ran in four local authority areas each with populations in the hundreds of thousands.
- deadbunny 7y ago> Scan every sheet. OCR it (free). There is no way this is anywhere near approaching free.