3 ms·
Why do we even need to take a census in the age of omnipresent state surveillance? Our governments already know exactly where we are and what we're doing practi
by krapp 7y ago
Why do we even need to take a census in the age of omnipresent state surveillance? Our governments already know exactly where we are and what we're doing practically at all times, tracking our web activity, listening in through our phones and devices, reading our mail, tapping into the data servers of the few tech companies that won't happily hand over our private data directly to governments with a smile. And in a few years the mass deployment of facial recognition software and self-driving cars will allow governments to correlate race and gender to our travel and purchase habits down to the last second and foot.
An actual census seems like a quaint atavism. The UK can just ask the NSA to count its citizens and provide whatever demographic data is required, and the US can ask the same of the UK. Problem solved.
- akmarinov 7y agoPublicly admitting that is probably something that they don't want to do. On the other hand, stopping a census for dumb reasons is one way to do it without publicly admitting they already have the data.
- krapp 7y agoThey don't need to publicly admit anything, thanks to Wikileaks and Snowden, it's a matter of public record. Since we don't have any choice about whether or not to participate in the panopticon, and it's clear no one is going to do anything to stop it, then it should at least serve some public good. Offer a public API and let Western countries build services directly on top of it.
- specialist 7y agoEvery time I make this painfully obvious point, I also get downvoted. I'd really like any of the downvoters to explain their objections. How can any one working in tech or policy deny the existence of ubiquitous demographic databases? How is this even controversial? Source: Worked very hard for a decade to protect both patient and voter privacy.