3 ms·
Why do you believe NSA spying decreases the risk of nuclear war, or helps stave off climate change? Also, it's not that we "love privacy", it's that we dislike
by einpoklum 7y ago
Why do you believe NSA spying decreases the risk of nuclear war, or helps stave off climate change?
Also, it's not that we "love privacy", it's that we dislike oppression. And believe you me - most people in my part of the world know very well how the US is oppressing them through military and intelligence means. We don't want to live under the US' boot, and the NSA is part of that boot.
- mirimir 7y agoI didn't say anything about spying staving off climate change. That's pretty much a done deal, at least to the extent of destroying our current civilization. We've been in free fall to that, for at least a decade. And about nuclear war. Although I'm not expert, it seems pretty obvious that uncertainty increases the risk of war. Sure, I hate oppression. And I'm not into oppressing others. But the problem is all the assholes who are driven to oppress others. If I could snap my fingers, and have them all die instantly, I would. But that just ain't gonna happen. And indeed, it's arguable that they've been selected for, since the development of agriculture and animal husbandry. I got that from Morgan's Black Man. So anyway, I just do what I can for myself and those close to me, and what I can to help others. I don't focus so much on changing the system. Given how people are, it seems kinda pointless.
- adrianN 7y agoYou could argue that uncertainty reduces the risk of war because you're only starting wars where you're reasonably certain that you can win. Uncertainty about your adversary's capabilities then prevents war.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoToo much uncertainty can also risk war. It all depends on what you're uncertain about. MAD doctrine is based on both sides being reasonably sure neither can get away with a first strike. There is interest in having that fact independently verifiable; spying is both providing that verification and serving as an incentive against overstating your actual capabilities.
- abbadadda 7y agoTo be fair, I don't think a search warrant is oppression if used correctly. If there was something analogous for encryption I wouldn't mind. Problem is an "encryption search warrant" likely would happen without anyone knowing about it.
- austhrow743 7y agoGives those who get a kick out of war and conflict something to do that isn't lob nukes at each other. Same reason you want layers of government with progression at a small scale available to many. So all the people with political ambitions aren't all trying to start their own governments and revolutions. Busy is stability.