3 ms·
At least one virtue ethics system can answer the "why" without infinite regress - the Judeo-Christian one. Honesty is a virtue because God is not a liar. That
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
At least one virtue ethics system can answer the "why" without infinite regress - the Judeo-Christian one. Honesty is a virtue because God is not a liar. That is, the virtues are virtues because they correspond to the character of God.
Now, you could try to turn that into an infinite regress by asking where God's character comes from. But within that system, God is self-existent - he doesn't come from anywhere, he has no cause. (You can disagree with the system, but within the logic of the system, the problem doesn't exist.)
And one nit: Honesty is a virtue because dishonesty so often rewards the dishonest at the expense of everyone else. I don't think it's because dishonesty was punished, it's that others suffered when someone was dishonest. Those others got the idea that dishonesty was a bad thing, because they were on the receiving end of the consequences.
- barrkel 7y agoBecause of damnation, eh? Appeals to a higher power usually come with an afterlife, for consequences.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoYes, you can make a consequentialist argument within that system. But you can also make a recursion-free virtue-based argument.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoRight, making something up is a way to solve the infinite regress problem. Other religions have similar moral systems with similar problems in terms of evidentiary basis. Another example of this is natural law, which is not actually a thing, however much we might wish it were.