3 ms·
A culture that is consistently truthful will develop a substantial advantage over one that isn't; over time they will have better information and make better de
by roenxi 7y ago
A culture that is consistently truthful will develop a substantial advantage over one that isn't; over time they will have better information and make better decisions. The example in the article is a really good example of the problem with the fallacy - they couldn't come up with something that makes sense. The ends are unjustifiable; money is being routed to a charity that is ineffective at saving drowning puppies. There are presumably charities that can save 200 puppies for $1.2 million that should be getting the money instead. People who could save puppies for $1,000/puppy will not bother trying because they will think they are inefficient.
The argument in the original (Jessica Taylor) argument rests heavily on the idea that there is nobody who could do better out there. In a world of 7 billion people that is a bad assumption. And that is the problem with lies - we have the technical capability to solve a dizzying array of problems the the point where and the major challenge is working out what the problems are then prioritising improving our handling of them.
There needs to be an appeal to consequences example that makes more sense for the argument to start. The consequences of lying about capability in a world with highly refined knowledge, research and development systems are substantially greater than the short term consequences of this particular example. Suppressing facts will not help save puppies, it will numb the response.