8 ms·
Understandably there’s a lot of anger directed against the police and administrators that censored Dr Li. Of course they will be convicted of corruption or misc
by simonh 7y ago
Understandably there’s a lot of anger directed against the police and administrators that censored Dr Li. Of course they will be convicted of corruption or misconduct or something, but that just makes them victims too. They were doing their jobs exactly the way they were trained and incentivised to do it. I’m not justifying them, actively supporting a corrupt system is a corrupt thing to do, but them being punished by the system they worked for is bullshit.
I just hope Chinese people realise that the censorship of their protests about this is exactly the same as the censorship of Dr Li. It’s the same system run by the same people for the same reasons.
It’s crap like this that the HK protesters are trying to keep out of HK. Most Chinese mainlanders swallowed the party line about HK. I hope this gives them cause to reconsider that attitude.
- datashow 7y agoAlso remember lots of things changed under Xi. China never allows political dissidence, but it is under Xi where everything in WeChat is heavily monitored and people get arrested for all sorts of minor things. So Xi is personally responsible for the Wuhan coronavirus outbreak.
- chaostheory 7y agoBefore XJ, China seemed to be gradually opening up. IMO it was inevitable that one of their metros would eclipse Silicon Valley. Now with XJ in power, a lockdown on freedom of expression, and a more perfect execution of state policy; I no longer see it happening. It’s more likely that India will have Silicon Valley’s successor in the future, if anyone can produce one
- keanzu 7y agoThat's a technological advance and not a policy change. WeChat didn't exist prior to 2011 and Xi Jinping rose to power in 2012.
- datashow 7y agoThere were other popular social media platforms in the past, such as Sina Weibo and other online discussion boards, which were not heavily monitored as WeChat is.
- keanzu 7y agoFair enough. At that time, and we are talking going back 10 years now, did the government lack the will or the technical capability to carry out the large scale monitoring?
- datashow 7y agoI don't think it is a technical thing. Remember niubo, which ran from 2006 to 2013? https://baike.baidu.com/item/%E7%89%9B%E5%8D%9A%E7%BD%91 https://baike.baidu.com/item/%E7%89%9B%E5%8D%9A%E7%BD%91 It is just a website, there is no technical difficulty to shut it down.
- simonh 7y agoMy wife is Chinese and we used to use Skype to video-chat with her family. From about 2008 the only version of Skype you could download in China was called TOM Skype, a modified version with back doors enabling Chinese state surveillance of communications. Links to regular Skype download sites were blocked and redirected you to TOM Skype. So none of this is really new. As technology and platforms have developed, the Chinese state has improved and expanded it's surveillance and suppression apparatus. I'm no fan of Xi and the situation has definitely worsened under him, but this is how the system works.
- AareyBaba 7y agoWhen Fury Overcomes Fear by Xu Zhangrun - is a good read. The professor who wrote this has been suspended. http://www.chinafile.com/reporting-opinion/viewpoint/viral-alarm-when-fury-overcomes-fear http://www.chinafile.com/reporting-opinion/viewpoint/viral-a...
- ashwinaj 7y ago> I just hope Chinese people realise that the censorship of their protests about this is exactly the same as the censorship of Dr Li. It’s the same system run by the same people for the same reasons. They are so brain washed into believing that China is the greatest country ever. Even Chinese citizens in the US, despite seeing the drastic differences in the governance, human rights, free speech etc. still believe China can do no wrong.
- the-dude 7y agoIn the U.S. this is called 'American exceptionalism'.
- ashwinaj 7y agoSure, but people can openly criticize the US govt and it's policies. Can they do this in China? A sense of national pride should not trump objectivity.
- the-dude 7y agoOf course they can criticize the US govt in China.
- ashwinaj 7y agoI am talking about Chinese citizens criticizing the Chinese govt. __in China__ the same way as American citizens can criticize the American govt. in America, if it wasn't obvious. And by criticizing I mean openly criticizing in public, not hiding behind some pseudonym online
- PeterisP 7y agoIt comes off as a play on the old Cold War joke (crude translation of how I remember it being told in the 1980s in Russian) with an American and a Russian discussing about their regimes; and the American proudly says - we have freedom of speech, I can go next to the White House with a banner saying "Reagan is a fool!" and that's going to be okay; to which the Russian responds - so what, that's not any advantage, I can also go to the Red Square with a banner saying "Reagan is a fool!" and there won't be any problems...
- allovernow 7y ago> Of course they will be convicted of corruption or misconduct or something What? No such thing will happen. This is an authoritarian regime. The government will never admit wrongdoing. They'll attempt to sweep it under the rug and continue operating with a "perfect" record.
- keymone 7y agoAuthoritarian regimes often punish scape goats to appease public.
- tartoran 7y agoThats a known tactic of authoritarian regimes. And people don’t get it, they’re brainwashed and powerless
- wefarrell 7y agoIt's human nature and isn't unique to authoritarian societies. People prefer to know that a problem was caused by a villain rather than a systemic failure. Authoritarians are particularly good at getting people to take the blame.
- keanzu 7y ago> Authoritarians are particularly good at getting people to take the blame. Everyone is guilty of something, you can get people to take the blame for things they didn't do even in a democracy. "Most of the defendants were persuaded that they had repressed memories of the crime." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beatrice_Six https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beatrice_Six
- allovernow 7y agoGood point. I hadn't considered that. What a terrifying way to live - serving your government knowing that at any point you may be thrown under the bus for following orders.
- im3w1l 7y agoI can see where you are coming from, but don't these police and administrators have some level of discretion?
- rebuilder 7y agoEnough rope to hang themselves. Create a culture where it's clear how you need to exercise your discretion, and refrain from giving direct orders. Voila, scapegoats.
- theseadroid 7y agoOff the topic, but I feel somehow because HKer only wanted to keep the bad things out of HK, that made the mainland Chinese less sympathetic toward them. To fight against the bad things HKer have to ally with mainland citizens to fight together, which I don't think is being considered even. There's no 独善其身 in this.
- godelski 7y agoI'm not a HKer, but I often her them say things along the lines of "country over party" or "love the country, not the party". I definitely have heard discussion about a desire to unite with mainlanders, but my understanding is that they are having a hard time spreading the message to the mainland. I think reasons for that should be apparent given this particular discussion about censorship.
- yorwba 7y agoFWIW, I have mainland Chinese friends who generally identify as patriotic, but who also use VPNs etc. to better inform themselves. They went to Hong Kong during the National Day celebrations and shared their observations on Weibo. They took note of the fact that there was lots of graffiti, but the only vaguely patriotic slogan was "love the country, not the party". The post wasn't taken down, as far as I know, so the message spread at least slightly, despite the censorship.
- theseadroid 7y agoIf possible could you please provide some sources? Or it’s just heard in person? I’ve been living outside of China for years and read many pro independent sources especially during the protests but haven’t seen any on uniting with mainlanders. And during the protests I’ve seen reports of protesters trashing businesses that are related to mainland and infrastructure connecting to mainland. I don’t think they think every mainland business is CCP sponsored don’t they?
- godelski 7y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/HongKong/comments/crn4qr/im_starting_to_see_a_lot_of_antimainlander/ https://www.reddit.com/r/HongKong/comments/crn4qr/im_startin... I'll admit, on /r/HongKong the "unify with mainlanders" posts don't rise up. It is not trendy. Probably because a lot of people interact with mainlanders that are against their movement. Which my understanding is that this is a selection bias (mainlanders that support them aren't seen). But this is going to happen in any movement that has a lot of fear in it (there is clear justification for the fear).
- mc32 7y agoAlso factions will use these sorts of events to push other factions out. Depending on the scale of things we might see some changes at the top. It’s no accident that mr Xi is putting one of his lieutenants in charge of the response (to have separation and also convenient pint to blame —but that only goes so far).
- tomphoolery 7y ago> but them being punished by the system they worked for is bullshit. It's not bullshit, it's comeuppance. This is what happens when you just follow orders. The punishment fits the crime.
- Nextgrid 7y ago“Following orders” should IMO be graded against the surveillance capabilities of the state. Disobeying orders on moral grounds was way easier before, but nowadays the people “following orders” are subject to the same surveillance as everyone else so dissent and disobedience is harder and can be squashed easily.
- derefr 7y agoSo, in your opinion, being coerced to kill someone with a gun to your own head would make you guilty of a crime? Most systems of law disagree. There is a large difference between "orders" that disobedience to results in being fired, or a dishonorable discharge from a military; and "orders" that disobedience to results in being disappeared. The latter is plain-and-simple coercion, no different than being held hostage and being told to do something by your hostage-taker.
- PavlovsCat 7y ago> being coerced to kill someone with a gun to your own head no such thing. > There was a widespread conviction that it is impossible to withstand temptation of any kind, that none of us could be trusted or even be expected to betrustworthy when the chips are down, that to be tempted and to be forced are almost the same, whereas in the words of Mary McCarthy, who first spotted this fallacy: "If somebody points a gun at you and says,'Kill your friend or I will kill you,' he is tempting you, that is all." And while a temptation where one's life is at stake may be a legal excuse for a crime, it certainly is not a moral justification. -- Hannah Arendt, "Personal Responsibility Under Dictatorship"
- lostmsu 7y agoBut there is no gun to their head. Even in China refusing to comply with an order will not give you a death sentence. Also, being allowed by law does not make stuff automatically justified.
- keanzu 7y ago> I’m not justifying them, actively supporting a corrupt system is a corrupt thing to do Ok, I'll justify them. There is almost no chance that anyone in the saga decided to do the evil thing because they wanted to watch the world burn. Not the government policy makers nor the police who carried out their orders. Every person is doing what they believe is the right thing. Some of the people were mistaken. With the benefit of hindsight we can see that Li Wenliang was not mistaken. How many SARS II hoaxes has the government stomped on that we never heard about. How many doctors or patients in a nation of ~billion people have misidentified an outbreak of the common cold as "the next SARS" in the last 17 years. They aggressively stamp out the embers of a rumor before it gets going and becomes a raging fire of panic. This time the government erred, it wasn't a misidentification, the virus was real. They aren't evil or corrupt or murderous. They are fallible humans and they make a mistake.
- radicaldreamer 7y agoWhat hoaxes would have involved 7-8 doctors in the same city, at the same time?
- edanm 7y agoThat's a false dichotomy. It isn't either a hoax, or real. More importantly, it isn't that either the government decides to stamp out info, or hoaxes/misidentifications will become a "raging fire of panic". In most of the western world (among other places), everyone is free to say what they like. The government doesn't get the right to decide what you can and can't say. And yes, hoaxes happen. Misinformation happens. But I don't think there have been these massive problems that you're foreseeing. And what's more, it's not clear that the government has the right to decide what's worse - these kinds of problems, or potentially more people dying.
- keanzu 7y agoI was trying to suggest that human are fallible - doctors, patients, police and policy makers all; however I used the word hoax way too much as both responses focus on that. I've reworded. Hopefully that addresses the issue? > the government decides to stamp out info There are other ways, as you've described, but I believe this is the way the Chinese government has demonstrated that they prefer to handle it. You can argue it is a wrong choice but I can't accept the OP's characterization of it as a corrupt choice.
- kingludite 7y agoSomeone living in a dictatorship (I dunno which) told me there is one advantage to it: No one believes the official news. He got the impression people in the west really believe everything they read while in reality our western news is as propagandized as theirs if not more.[sic] I don't know how gullible the Chinese are but I assume they find the official narrative pretty suspicious.
- simonh 7y agoAt least in the west you get to choose your propaganda. There is no single party line all the media have to toe, and different media outlets frequently disagree vigorously with each other.
- kingludite 7y agoIt's not what they say it is that they dance around the same narrow narrative. How many billions of news worthy topics would there be? We both come to HN in our search for something interesting to read or talk about. After the limited, carefully designed scope has been injected into the collective here too people cant resist pumping it to the front page. If there are specially hot topics that everyone must talk about and everyone is looking at the left hand the right hand is doing all kinds of highly news worthy malicious things that no one talks about.
- simonh 7y agoIf you think you can do a better job than the mainstream media, go ahead and do it. Nobody will stop you, but you don't get to tell people what to be interested in or care about, any more than the Chinese authorities should.
- kingludite 7y agoNot sure what you mean with better. However great the content is doesn't matter. Producing great content consistently is already going to cost money. Buying readers is going to cost even more. How much would it cost to take on say newscorp? But say for sake of argument you happen upon a pile of money at the end of some rainbow. If you then chose to publish rebellious unflattering articles about the status quo there will be infinite funds available to silence you. Not that you will ever get to that point. I look at things like facebook likes and youtube views for US presidential candidates. There are lots of candidates! The amount of attention they get drops to 200 views per video at the green party. Slightly further down they don't have the likes or views to account for direct friends and relatives.The numbers are so incredibly low that we can see non of the journalists around the world even took notice. The system is perfect, you cant do better than this.