3 ms·
I thought this would be fluff, but this is a genuinely interesting schema for modelling research-type organizations that I haven’t seen before. (If you think it
by derefr 7y ago
I thought this would be fluff, but this is a genuinely interesting schema for modelling research-type organizations that I haven’t seen before. (If you think it’s “just X”, the page does spend some time clearly compare-and-contrasting with anything you might think to analogize it to. It’s not quite any existing thing.) It probably is consultingware of some form, but I don’t mind scavenging insight from a predatory situation if there’s some there to be taken.
One thing I would like to see, though, is a list of historical evidence that this paradigm does better than the standard academic “publish papers to gain notoriety” paradigm. Turtleocracy has been tried before, I’m sure, even if by accident—there are only so many relationship graphs a small set of humans can end up in. I’m pretty sure some private research organizations work[ed] like this?
But I’d like an analysis of how much their working-like-this contributed to their success or lack thereof. It’d be interesting to contrast different private research institutions, e.g. {Bell Labs, RCA Labs, maybe Oak Ridge?} on their comparative Turtleocracy-ness vs their comparative “throughput” in pumping out new foundational knowledge (which I assume is the goal here.)
- edelwax 7y agoYes, right, Turtleocracy is partly modeled on PARC, Bell Labs, etc. But I don't begin to know how to answer this question about "how much their working-like-this contributed to their success or lack thereof" -- are you an organizational sociologist? If you have some methodological ideas here, I'd love to hear them. I'm not sure where people are getting the consultingware idea. We don't have any consulting relationships with businesses at all. Guess our copy is misleading somewhere?