3 ms·
I would argue the Merkle tree (or any other recursive signature algorithm) is the most important quality of a blockchain. To say that git is technically a block
by bob1029 7y ago
I would argue the Merkle tree (or any other recursive signature algorithm) is the most important quality of a blockchain. To say that git is technically a blockchain is not entirely inaccurate IMO.
I think you are looking for the other qualities that typically apply to a blockchain such as the implicit need to "mine" its resources. Git simply produces these resources incidentally. I think this is the only major difference.
- CiPHPerCoder 7y ago> I would argue the Merkle tree (or any other recursive signature algorithm) A Merkle tree is not a recursive signature algorithm, because a hash function is not a signature algorithm. https://paragonie.com/blog/2015/08/you-wouldnt-base64-a-password-cryptography-decoded https://paragonie.com/blog/2015/08/you-wouldnt-base64-a-pass... (Yes, you can build signature algorithms out of hash functions, but definitions matter.)
- meowface 7y agoIt's still missing important pieces. They both fall under the superset of "hash chain" / Merkle tree, but cryptocurrency blockchains are designed to deal with the possibility of bad actors. Git can't ensure trust, unless you PGP sign commits. Git + PGP + some computationally expensive mechanism to broadcast verified PGP key attributions + a consensus algorithm might be a little bit like a blockchain, but I can't think of a good use case for that. Git repos generally aren't intended to be pushed to by the whole world.
- hannasanarion 7y agoA blockchain doesn't ensure trust either. The blockchain "trusts" whoever has the most powerful hash cracking array.
- meowface 7y agoI should've said "attempt to ensure trust".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- CiPHPerCoder 7y agoIncidentally, this is a problem I've worked on previously. https://github.com/paragonie/libgossamer/tree/master/docs https://github.com/paragonie/libgossamer/tree/master/docs
- andrewflnr 7y agoThe most important part of a block chain is its consensus mechanism. The merkle tree is relatively trivial.
- jnwatson 7y agoThere's significant difference in opinion of what part of the Bitcoin protocol is the "blockchain". Usually, people talk about the persistent stuff being the blockchain. In that case, bits sitting in storage don't implement a protocol, therefore don't have a consensus mechanism. In other words, the blockchain is just the data structure, the consensus sits outside of that as a distributed protocol. Of course, parts of that data structure enable the protocol to work, which is the most interesting property of the blockchain, but that's just blocks, merkle trees, and chained signatures.
- andrewflnr 7y agoIf you're focusing on the construction of the term "blockchain", you're already lost. The name is a red herring. It's very clear that the innovative aspect of the technology, the part that enabled all the interesting applications, is the protocol layered on top of the merkle tree. That's the part that needed a new name, and deserved a better one than it got.