4 ms·
What's with the flamebait thread title? Why not just keep the title of the original blog post: "Will the Female Founders Please Stand Up?" I don't see anythin
by mindcrime 16y ago
What's with the flamebait thread title? Why not just keep the title of the original blog post: "Will the Female Founders Please Stand Up?"
I don't see anything in that post to support any suggestion that "YC is sexist" at all. If anything, it's just the opposite; some YC founders came out for the explicit purpose of helping aspiring female founders. What's the problem again?
As for this bit:
But the circumstance produced an outrageously uneven power structure between the men and women in attendance.
YCombinator created a dynamic where every man at the table was there to “advise” and every woman at the table was there to “be advised”. Every man was a “guest of honor” and every woman was a “paid attendee”.
I know my way around a conversation about startups, and I regularly earn the respect of my male peers in conversation. Were I to meet any of these men in a different context, we would have been on a level playing field. But at this dinner table, for my life I could not convince these men to engage me as a peer. My comments were interpreted as questions and were met with “well, actually…” remarks. There was very little back and forth, and my opinion was of no consequence. The power structure of this dinner precluded any woman from being taken seriously at the table.
How does gender even factor into this equation? Would it have mattered if some of attendees were men? The attendees would still have been the "aspiring" founders and the "advisers" would still have been the "advisers," the ones brought there to serve up knowledge. Or what if some of the advisers had been female? Would that have made any difference to the "balance of power" bit? No.
- jbooth 16y agoWomen might have had a little more insight on navigating the 98% male world of tech as a female founder. I think the dinner's a great idea and hate to criticize YC for trying to do a good thing (good on them for trying in general), but some successful women (from outside the YC diaspora if there aren't enough in it) could be more encouraging and englightening, given the topic.
- mindcrime 16y agoSure, I said in another comment that one would expect - intuitively if nothing else - to find some female founders. But that section reads like the OP found it to be some horrible, horrible thing just because - due to circumstance - all the advisers were male and the attendees were female; and went off on what felt like a bit of a weird digression. Balance of power? Not being treated like a peer? I'm just saying that if you're at an event where you are - by nature - positioned in something of a "advisee" or "student" role, that you are in the "advisee" or "student" role regardless of your gender. And sometimes it's ok to put the ego aside, quit worrying about getting the other person to accept you, respect you, or whatever, and just listen and learn. I mean, nobody likes being talked down to, or patronized, right? I think that's something that transcends gender. But sometimes we accept it because there's something to be gained.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]