9 ms·
This kind of charging of specific foreign military or intelligence personnel for hacking US institutions is somewhat controversial in the US intelligence commun
by tzs 7y ago
This kind of charging of specific foreign military or intelligence personnel for hacking US institutions is somewhat controversial in the US intelligence community [1].
Their worry is that foreign countries will eventually retaliate by charging people who are involved in US government programs to hack those foreign countries.
Another worry is that indicting people might give away information information about your sources and methods.
[1] https://www.mcclatchydc.com/news/nation-world/national/national-security/article205363554.html https://www.mcclatchydc.com/news/nation-world/national/natio...
- ryanlol 7y agoYeaaah, it’s not like the US doesn’t do this https://github.com/649/EQGRP-TrickOrTreat/tree/master/pitchimpair https://github.com/649/EQGRP-TrickOrTreat/tree/master/pitchi... It’s ridiculous how many people here seem to think China is somehow special as far as this sort of hacking goes. Shadowbrokers leaks even make it easy to identify specific NSA operators, for example Michael A Pecoraro, Nathan S. Heidbreder, Gennadiy Sidelnikov and a Brian C Fong Going after specific Chinese individuals means throwing these US operators under the bus.
- xxpor 7y agoPart of the calculation of taking these types of jobs should be the consideration that there's a strong chance you'll never be able to visit a foreign country ever again.
- skim_milk 7y agoIs anything really going to change? If you had a role in US intelligence you're already going to know you really shouldn't leave the western bloc.
- vsareto 7y agoI guess there was some question as to whether government hackers could be treated just as badly as proper spies. If you're a gov't hacker, you should probably assume the worst is waiting for you if you are good at your job and avoid summer Beijing trips.
- advisedwang 7y agoDoesn't the alternative amount to a policy of "It's OK to break our laws so long as you are a foreign military"?
- javagram 7y agoIf we got in a war with China and soldiers fought each other, we wouldn’t try to charge the soldiers with crimes after the war for killing our soldiers, even though murder is generally worse than hacking. (Excepting war crimes, but is hacking a war crime?) Considering many of these soldiers are probably conscripts and might be killed or imprisoned if they don’t follow orders to hack us, I can see the case for treating them like normal soldiers and not like criminals. On the other hand I guess charging individuals is a way for the government to ignore that ultimately China’s government is the one responsible for their military’s actions.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ryanlol 7y agoThat’d match the current policy of “It’s ok for US to break any foreign laws”
- dontbenebby 7y ago>Their worry is that foreign countries will eventually retaliate by charging people who are involved in US government programs to hack those foreign countries. How are non "cyber" crimes handled? Is it normal to charge people for the murders, thefts, and other illegal activities intelligence officers perform? I'm not going to make a moral judgement here, I'll just say that I'm not a fan of treating "cyber" as some magical realm where there are no norms.
- mcny 7y ago> I'm not going to make a moral judgement here, I'll just say that I'm not a fan of treating "cyber" as some magical realm where there are no norms. On the contrary, I think we are pulling in too many assumptions into "cyber". Imagine this: if someone had left their door unlocked and someone came in and stole their lawn mower, you could say they deprived the owner of use of their lawn mower. However, imagine if equifax removed [authorize] in an http endpoint like /v2/person/:id allowing anyone to just GET /v2/person/1 .. 999999999 consecutively. Is this a criminal matter? I'd say no. I'd go further and say that this "cyber" fearmongering has gone too far and we should ABOLISH the CFAA. The EFF has still laid their hopes on reform but I for one think it is irredeemable and must be abolished with no replacement.
- dak1 7y agoJust to play devil's advocate: If an armored Brinks truck gets in an accident and cash spills all over, it's not legal to take just because it's no longer protected and on public land. Intent has to matter a lot in these cases, though. If a bill blows a mile away and somebody happens to find it with no knowledge of the crash, that's qualitatively different than witnessing the accident and then rushing to grab the money you watched spill out.
- dependenttypes 7y ago> it's not legal to take How about to copy? I think that a better comparison would be with an armoured truck having left open its doors and spilling top secret documents all over the road.
- driverdan 7y ago> Their worry is that foreign countries will eventually retaliate by charging people who are involved in US government programs to hack those foreign countries. Good. If you get caught committing a crime you should be charged with it. > Another worry is that indicting people might give away information information about your sources and methods. Also good. US intelligence should not be holding back 0days.
- kortilla 7y ago> Good. If you get caught committing a crime you should be charged with it. Presumably you’re fine with trying all of the US soldiers who killed other soldiers in war with murder?
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoWe have international law on killing enemy combatants, murder of civilians, surrender, treatment of prisoners,etc. Shooting the enemy is not murder.
- dwild 7y ago> Good. If you get caught committing a crime you should be charged with it. So any military personnel that kill someone while doing his job should be able to be charged for murder?
- dependenttypes 7y agoAs long as - the military personnel did not kill someone in order to defend themselves - they kill civilians - they kill other military personnel during peace time Then yes, they should be charged with murder.
- dwild 7y ago> - they kill other military personnel during peace time I see that you did some effort choosing the word "peace time" to be able to say "well we are at peace with China, thus this is fine to charge them", but at the end of the day, what is peace time? Does receiving the order to attack a target make it become a war? They got an order to attack the US company, this is not peace.
- avocado4 7y agoDidn't even have to open the thread to know that the top comment would be whataboutism. Essentially every China-related thread follows the same formula.
- Forgivenessizer 7y agoDoesn't "whataboutism" mean "don't know about anything else, because it could complicate matters"?
- jessaustin 7y agoFortunately, there is now a new consensus on "whataboutism": https://theoutline.com/post/8610/united-states-russia-whataboutism-cold-war-trump https://theoutline.com/post/8610/united-states-russia-whatab...
- tzs 7y agoHow is the top comment whataboutism? Whataboutism, according to my understanding, would be saying that it's OK for China to hack because the US hacks. That's not what the top comment is about. The top comment is about some in the US intelligence community saying that the US indicting named foreign hackers for hacking US targets might put US hackers in danger and might leak information about US intelligence capabilities.
- option 7y agowhat are the alternative? Escalate military tensions with them? Slap sanctions on whole populations (who actually don’t have a say in this since they live under dictatorship)? Start a war?
- ryanlol 7y agoWhy do anything? It’s well known that US intelligence hacks Chinese (and European!) companies, why escalate with indictments? The Chinese are perfectly capable of namedropping NSA employees too.
- Forgivenessizer 7y ago"sources and methods" Typically it means "there's some guy" and "SMS".
- Udik 7y agoIt's like charging US drone pilots with murder?
- cmroanirgo 7y agoRight. I find this announcement rather alarming as a non-US earth-living human. 1. Foreign nationals, working (?criminally) to exfiltrate information from US companies (or servers in the US) can now be subject to US laws directly? Isn't this the same as what I saw with the Julian Assange case, where he facilitated his actions while in a foreign country? It seems there's been a new international law that's been set up that draws a line for any international hacking? But the article doesn't read that way... There no international criminal courts mentioned... If that's the case, should I start recording all the US ips that try to hack into my servers, and take legal steps to have them arrested and extradited to my country? (What a nightmare!) 2. The ability for doxxing of these individuals by the US despite taking significant steps to hide their tracks indicates a certain level of Pwn-ership of the internet as a whole by the US. How could individuals have been revealed? Is ipv6 enough to de anonymise to individuals machines or is the US able to 'packet watch' across the entire internet? Edit: better wording of concerns
- ardy42 7y ago> 1. Foreign nationals, working (?criminally) to exfiltrate information from US companies (or servers in the US) can now be subject to US laws directly? Of course. We live in the 21st century, it's possible to commit crimes in countries you've never visited from halfway across the world. If such people weren't subject to criminal law where they committed their crimes, IT-support scammers, ransomware crooks, and all kinds of other criminals would act with even more impunity than they already do.
- onetimemanytime 7y agoI think I agree with it. Spies are spies and they're doing their thing. USA should just suck it up and force companies to improve their security. Should China issue an Interpol warrant for CIA's John Doe that handles US spy assets in China? I am sure there's a Chinese law against it