4 ms·
Why would you assume that American accent(s) changed, but not British ones? Maybe it's the British accent that changed since then, not the American one, so it'
by jrochkind1 7y ago
Why would you assume that American accent(s) changed, but not British ones? Maybe it's the British accent that changed since then, not the American one, so it's not that Americans lost their British accents, but that British accents changed and American ones stayed behind.
Or of course, both probably have changed.
After reading the article -- yup, in that vein.
But I think this is an important conceptual shift for us in even what questions we ask. We are inclined to think things are much more stable than they are, especially within geographic bounds. We assume British accents must be more stable in the British geography, and it must be American accents that changed. When in fact there's no reason to have this assumption, because that's not how things work, the right question in the first place, even before you know anything, is "Why have American and British accents diverged", without assuming one was stable but not the other.
Now, the trick is realizing this applies to culture in general, not just accents or even languages. Consider how this applies to those genetic tests telling people they "are" 35% German or something and what people think this means about the stability of the category of "German" over generations...
- dragonwriter 7y agoThe first sentence of the article addresses that.