7 ms·
> Microsoft doing shady stuff again. Seems anything but shady? On the start menu in full sight and just explicitly suggesting their browser over Firefox. Doesn
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> Microsoft doing shady stuff again.
Seems anything but shady? On the start menu in full sight and just explicitly suggesting their browser over Firefox. Doesn't even claim anything about either browser, just suggests theirs! Seems as honest and upfront as any advertising could be? 'Try our band of coffee' effectively.
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoIt's advertising. Smack bang in the middle of the OS you paid hundreds for.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI get people don't want it. But it's the least 'shady' advertising I've seen in years!
- Avamander 7y agoDoesn't still make it okay.
- stanski 7y agoAny advertising that's badmouthing another product is shady. I don't know what advertising you've been seeing that's so much worse.
- chrisseaton 7y ago‘Are you still drinking coffee brand A? Try coffee brand B!’ Seems almost comically benign, 50s-style advertising to my ears.
- anoncake 7y agoIf Microsoft had run that ad in the usual places accessible to everyone that can afford it there would not be much outrage.
- knolax 7y agoImagine if the real estate company that built your house installed speakers that talk about how much better the furniture also made by that company is every time you installed IKEA furniture.
- alxlaz 7y agoIt's certainly shady, given that they own both the product they're advertising and the medium they're advertising it through. I don't expect that I'll be able to get them to give me a top spot for an ad saying "Concerned about Microsoft's tracking policy? Mozilla Firefox is here", or "Still using Edge? Why not just get the original -- Google Chrome is here'.
- zchrykng 7y agoNo, but Google would be more than happy to put the later on their main search page. Not really any different. Microsoft controls Windows and uses it to advance corporate goals. Google owns their search interface and uses it to advance their corporate goals.
- alxlaz 7y agoWhat does Google have to do with any of this?
- wlesieutre 7y ago>"Still using Edge? Why not just get the original -- Google Chrome is here' Is something Google would totally do. They've been pushing Chrome with the search home page for years.
- zchrykng 7y agoPeople are complaining about Microsoft pushing Edge on Windows. Google pushes Chrome on google.com all the time. Frequently with some negative comment about your current browser. They may be less negative now than what I remember, haven't looked at one in forever.
- alxlaz 7y agoI'm sure Google is shady in this, and many other ways, too, but I really don't see how it's important in this discussion. If Google is doing the same thing then I hope they choke on their Bacardi and Coke, too, but the news is that Microsoft is also doing it now. I'm not sure what the adequate reaction here would have been. Should I have added a "P.S. oh yeah by the way Google is also doing this, don't forget to hate on them, too?" line in my original reply, for completeness?
- Santosh83 7y agoThe wording "still using Firefox?" does suggest subtly that Firefox is outdated or passé... so no, their wording is problematic, as also is the placement of the ad. It is also unnecessary given Firefox's rather small market share and the fact that Edge will be bundled with Windows which means that almost everyone who doesn't use Chrome will likely use Edge.
- 34679 7y agoIf W10 is on 800,000,000 computers[1], and it costs each user 1 second of productivity, then every time that ad shows, Microsoft is stealing 222,222 hours of productivity from people and businesses around the world to advertise its subpar browser in an operating system they've already been compensated for. https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-says-windows-10-is-now-on-more-than-800-million-devices/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-says-windows-10-is-n...
- kuku4 7y ago>Microsoft is stealing 222,222 hours of productivity You better don't want your boss to know how much HN is stealing "hours of productivity" from you :)
- HenryBemis 7y agoHey, this forum gives us ideas, helps us learn more, helps us become better!!! If anything our bosses should give us more time to spend on HN!! ;)
- rsnor 7y agoI hate OS-level ads the same if not more than any other HN reader, but that's like saying we shouldn't be glancing out of the window for half a second because it would scale up to losing ~100,000 hours of productivity every day. It's a fraction of a ten-thousandth of a workday - anyone concerned with that level of optimization shouldn't be using humans to begin with.
- 34679 7y agoI think you're looking at it from the individual's point of view instead of Microsoft's. Of course at the local level a person or even small business shouldn't be worried about a second of time lost. I'm not saying we should be concerned with employees glancing out the window. I'm saying any decision that affects 800,000,000 people has very tangible consequences. I think an apt analogy would be the "Take a Penny, Leave a Penny" tray at convenience stores. Nobody cares if you take a penny from a gas station. But if someone figured out a way to take a penny from every tray in the world, that would raise some real questions about theft that would need to be answered.
- reportgunner 7y agoIt's bullying non-technical users into thinking that Firefox is old. They can be shy to ask anyone if Firefox is viable in fear of being ridiculed and they might end up thinking that Firefox is bad for months or even years. Perhaps they could have gone down a different road: > Still installing browsers from internet ? Edgium is here, faster and pre-installed. Try it out!