3 ms·
I think the bigger issue is the fact that they 'feed' Watson the question via a text file. That was probably the most (only?) disappointing thing they revealed
by evo_9 16y ago
I think the bigger issue is the fact that they 'feed' Watson the question via a text file.
That was probably the most (only?) disappointing thing they revealed. It would seem that voice-recognition is far enough along where that shouldn't be necessary. Maybe adding that would delay Watson just enough to seem far? Or perhaps I'm over simplifying the difficulties of adding voice recognition to Watson?
- ianferrel 16y agoThe interesting question is whether the computer can do natural language processing, not whether it can recognize spoken words. Even the human contestants don't rely on the host reading the questions; they read the board. I guess you could argue that Watson should do OCR of the board, but that's not actually a hard problem, so it wouldn't really add much to the challenge. They're focusing on language processing, not environmental sensors.
- evo_9 16y agoRight, perfect - that is actually more fundamental and exactly what I was getting at. Is the game currently fair? It's hard to say but watching it seems like there is an advantage there for Watson. I do like the way Jennings downplayed it though. I think he was being almost too kind but compared to how Kasporov handled himself, this is hugely better.
- arctangent 16y agoI haven't seen the video yet but I think the facts will show that the game is reasonably fair, given the different species participating. Whether or not there is an advantage for Watson is, I suppose, rather the point of the exercise ;-)
- Qz 16y agoOf course it's not fair. The question is whether Watson's advantages are offset by its disadvantages.
- sp332 16y agoHumans on the show don't necessarily have to do voice-recognition either. The text is presented to them on the screen, and I'm sure they can read it faster than Trebek.
- zach 16y agoExactly. It pops on the screen instantly, even if there's a video attached. A contestant with a bad eyeglass prescription is a goner. Waiting to hear to the clue puts a player at a major disadvantage, especially on really short clues. However, there is one very notable exception: Eddie Timanus. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eddie_Timanus#Jeopardy.21 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eddie_Timanus#Jeopardy.21