6 ms·
The parent wasn't claiming it wasn't stupid or wrong, they were talking about the tone. It's not quite Linus rejecting a patch with some choice insults, but it'
by luckylion 7y ago
The parent wasn't claiming it wasn't stupid or wrong, they were talking about the tone. It's not quite Linus rejecting a patch with some choice insults, but it's certainly in that direction.
- zentiggr 7y agoShe has seen and written about enough to be entirely justified in her tone. And she's always got an overall point about how to run things better / improve process / get newbies up to speed and past the 'every commit breaks things'. I'd take the time to go read the rest of her posts I haven't seen, and definitely learn a bit about surviving sysadmin work in larger organizations in the process.
- snlnspc 7y agoLinus has also seen and written about a lot. Would you say that he was justified in his tone prior to his apology for his tone? Granted that his tone and her tone were very different, but, imo, as a reader of her posts, this wasn't necessary. Educating junior devs is more productive than considering them randos.
- toyg 7y ago> Would you say that he was justified in his tone prior to his apology for his tone? I'll take my downvotes here, but personally I think Linus with that apology crossed the threshold into old age. Quoting Tomasi di Lampedusa: > The Prince who had found the town unchanged, was found much changed himself, whom never before would have used such accommodating words; and since then, invisible, began the decline of his prestige.
- rsynnott 7y agoBy grumpy sysadmin standards it seems very, very mild, tbh. And certainly nothing like Linus on a bad day.
- luckylion 7y agoI do believe that it's still what would today be called exclusive, unwelcoming, in short: "toxic". I don't mind that way of communicating, but I'm also absolutely fine with Linus' style. The comments in defense of this had a bit of a cultish feel ("she has earned the right to talk that way about people!!111"), but I gather that's more because people know her and may consider her a friend, so their perception is changed.