3 ms·
Interestingly, the same transistors have revolutionized audio amplifiers. I'm a musician, and typically play with an amplifier. Over the years, my amp has gone
by analog31 7y ago
Interestingly, the same transistors have revolutionized audio amplifiers. I'm a musician, and typically play with an amplifier. Over the years, my amp has gone from 40 pounds of steel, copper, and vacuum tubes, to a 15 pound solid state amplifier, to a 2.5 pound switchmode amp, with no loss of tone quality that I can perceive.
The rise of the new "micro" amplifiers has been driven in no small part by improved MOSFETs that can switch faster and more efficiently, at higher voltages. I can't imagine that demand for musical equipment drove this development, but we certainly benefit from it.
- hdiriekei 7y agoQuality micro amplifiers (class D) are extremely difficult to design. They are way outside the possibilities of amateurs or boutique shops, unlike classical amps (class A, ...)
- baybal2 7y ago> They are way outside the possibilities of amateurs or boutique shops I disagree, take a look at what that guy does: https://twitter.com/amiteque https://twitter.com/amiteque
- kragen 7y agoWhat are the pitfalls?
- analog31 7y agoOwning a good enough oscilloscope is actually an issue. The switching signals are high speed, and subtle variations impinge on both the efficiency and stability of the amplifier. Many of the components are operating in their regime of non ideal behavior, e.g., a capacitor is not just a capacitor. Circuit board layout is also a big deal. Even the commercial amplifier makers have mostly reverted to buy-in modules. Most of the "mini amps" sold for bass guitar contain IcePower modules made by a division of Bang & Olufsen. I've gone so far as to simulate a switchmode amplifier in LTSpice just for fun. I'm quite heavily into electronics, but have made it a personal rule not to mess around with homemade line powered equipment that I would actually take to a performance. I don't want to become known as the whiz kid whose homemade gear blew up on stage. ;-) At lower power levels, there are some IC's made by Texas Instruments and others that shouldn't be too difficult to apply, but you can also get entire amplifier boards with these chips from online suppliers for next to nothing.
- nwallin 7y agoDefine "good enough oscilloscope"? A rigol 1054z can be had for $4-500. What do you need from an oscilloscope that the 1054z doesn't provide? I'm not saying you're wrong, I just don't understand.
- analog31 7y agoThat's probably good enough, but certainly better than what I have at home. In fact, I bought a couple of those for my workplace.
- rasz 7y agoHow is owning an oscilloscope capable of <~50KHz BW an issue? Those are the only frequencies you should be worried about in an audio amp.
- detaro 7y agoNot for testing a class-D amp, which switches in the MHz range, and you do want to test if it's stable, if your filters actually get rid of the HF parts, ... And even for an analog design 50kHz wouldn't really be enough for many potential problems which happen above that. Worrying just about the audio range is not enough.
- analog31 7y agoIndeed, and it's the high frequency behavior where you see if you're getting charge on and off the gates of the MOSFETs fast enough with just the right timing.
- unlinked_dll 7y agoAlso a guitarist. I own 3 amps, two tube and one hybrid. Used to have a solid state. You really can't tell the difference? It's night and day to me, even with the newer Fender mustangs that have great models. I won't turn in my HT40 for a solid state until Kempers can deliver the same quality at the same price (which I picked up off craigslist for $400). Now my little mono price 15W (which is loud as hell) sounds pretty terrible in most settings but I haven't found a solid state that can give the same character with the right settings. Plus real spring reverb, i can't kick a DSP to make it jangle. If you're talking acoustic sure solid state wins every day of the week. But in the mid tier amp market for electrics tubes win out. I do think though that most people don't know how to use a tube amp to get a good tone though. Crank the power amp volume and use your gain as a volume control, push the input with a clean boost or light drive to get distortion. The harmonics stack through the chain, and that's how you get the crystal clear sound without being drowned in noise or fuzz. It's also something you can't do on a solid state, since the input is buffered and the DSPs don't really handle that idea well.
- analog31 7y agoI'm just an upright bassist. I firmly believe that DSP could emulate any guitar amp. If it's real, then it can be measured, and if it can be measured, then it can be simulated. What I think is the big deal is, an amp might be capable of producing a certain tone quality, but that tone quality is unreachable if the controls don't cooperate or are not intuitive. It's a user interface problem. What's more, if it's frustrating to the guitarist, they will notice even if the audience (or the bassist) doesn't. I also think it's a non-problem to some extent because tubes are not prohibitively expensive, and guitar amps don't need to be exceptionally powerful.
- nullc 7y ago> I firmly believe that DSP could emulate any guitar amp. If it's real, then it can be measured, and if it can be measured, then it can be simulated. This is absolutely true, but the possibility of it doesn't tell you anything about someone having been successful at it. One way to think about is that the market for the product can be split into three populations: Those who will buy even if the simulation is poor (they can't tell, don't care, or buy based on price or other wizbang features), those who won't buy no matter how good the simulation is (they don't care about the cost/weight/power, are happy with the classic stuff, ones snub simulations for social reasons, ones who prefer products without long boot times or with physical knobs, or just can't tell and are going to be conservative), and those who would buy but only if it's good. I think in many cases this last group is much smaller than the other two. As a result it doesn't necessarily make commercial sense to make the simulation especially good. Even in the case of linear effects (e.g. typically reverbs) where it's easy to measure them and determine scientifically that any difference would be (nearly-)inaudible there are many implementations that don't even bother to try being particularly faithful. For non-linear effects like guitar amplifiers it's much more difficult to objectively characterize their performance. [I own no tube amps or other similar things, but I understand why people do.]
- dreamcompiler 7y agoClass D (or Class T) amplifiers are just switching power supplies "turned sideways." By which I mean that the important input changes from the AC power to the regulation signal. The latter is a DC reference voltage in a power supply; it's the audio input in an amp.