This is a strange comment. It sounds like you’re using black wrong. First of all, when you pick Black, you throw away your own style guide (at least where black

This is a strange comment. It sounds like you’re using black wrong. First of all, when you pick Black, you throw away your own style guide (at least where black is concerned; keep the bits about function naming, etc). Secondly, you should only have one noisy commit, that being the very first commit in which you integrate Black. Thereafter, Black runs before code is committed so all code in code review is already formatted. Yes, if you already have comprehensive style linters and a team that agrees on style, you won’t see as much benefit, but you won’t need to maintain your custom linters or style guide or have all of these conversations about style (you also don’t need to iterate with a linter).