3 ms·
> The most frustrating part of the Librem 5 right now is easily the power management, which isn't nearly complete. The phone is dead nearly all the time, becaus
by dangus 7y ago
> The most frustrating part of the Librem 5 right now is easily the power management, which isn't nearly complete. The phone is dead nearly all the time, because so many basic charging features we normally take for granted don't work. First, the phone doesn't seem like it has any kind of idle power mode. It is hot from the minute you power on until the battery dies, even with the screen off. You can't leave the phone on the charger overnight to charge it—you'll wake up to a dead phone. I think what is happening is that there's no trickle charge, so the phone charges to full, then stops charging, then the battery dies.
Yikes. In my mind, this isn't actually a phone in its current form. It's like a small desktop computer put into a plastic case with a battery.
I have never seen the case up close until this point. It truly looks like a crude hobby project, almost to the level of being 3D printed.
I have no idea why Purism didn't leave most of the hardware design to someone who already has a generic modern smartphone done and completed, then they could have added on to it by swapping out some proprietary bits. Instead we get this Frankenstein of a project, sold to the public long before it's done (along with marketing copy that makes the company look unethical - there should be big warnings on the store page about how far along this project truly is and what you're getting for your $750).
The worst part about this is that it makes all open source projects look bad. It makes them look like a bad compromise. And that's not true at all - a lot of open source projects are great alternatives, and many are even better than their proprietary competitors.
$750 gets you an iPhone with sophisticated cameras, the fastest mobile processor on the market, and software support for 5 years if not longer. Walk into stores across the country to get service and support. What Purism is telling us is, essentially, if you want to take a stand against the proprietary world, you have to give up everything. You have to use a chunky, ugly, crudely assembled phone. You have to give up acceptable power management. And you still have to pay $750, all of this on the cusp of Apple releasing a new $399 phone according to rumors, Google selling $399 phones, and budget brands like Motorola providing an absolutely acceptable experience for under $200 on some models.
- vxNsr 7y ago> I have no idea why Purism didn't leave most of the hardware design to someone who already has a generic modern smartphone done and completed, then they could have added on to it by swapping out some proprietary bits. Either you didn’t actually read the article or you’re being intentionally obtuse. They very clearly state the reason that they couldn’t use the regular supply chain. All the usual suppliers refused to work within the “confines” of OSS. They were lucky to find a CPU that works at all within their definition and needs. If you read the article you’d know that the author spends the entire first page explaining the compromises that were made in favor of OSS. There is no supply chain for this sort of project. Purism is the first company to actually attempt it. Look, I have no horse in this race, I’m a happy Win and iOS user, I have no plans on changing that. But I commend the effort and definitely believe in the mission. OSS hardware is a compromise right now! That’s just a fact. People like you who can only see the flaws and refuse to understand how we got here are unhelpful.
- seba_dos1 7y ago> Purism is the first company to actually attempt it. To be exact, Purism isn't really the first - however, earlier successful attempts were made long enough time ago to be hardly relevant in today's context (like Openmoko) and/or very limited in their scale (like GTA04).
- dangus 7y agoI may seem unhelpful here, but I'm also taking this from the perspective of a potential customer. If you read Purism's marketing on their website, read the blog posts, and the verbiage on the store page, and then you run out and buy this phone, you'll be under the impression that you're getting something much more close to functional than it actually is. Essentially, this product should be labeled as an early development kit. But the marketing on the website is even trying to sell this to parents, who should absolutely not buy this phone for their children (because it's not done and it'll be dead anytime you try to call them because the power management is broken).
- seba_dos1 7y agoThe revision being sold (Evergreen) hasn't been released at all yet, it's scheduled for Q2. To get the earlier revisions that are being shipped already you had to explicitly opt in and double confirm via e-mail that you're aware of possible issues.
- iamnothere 7y agoI'm assuming this will be fixed by the Evergreen batch. The early release batches were labeled as such and buyers had an option as to which batch they wanted.
- ta999999171 7y agoYou're ignoring the intangible of not being spied on. If this doesn't matter to you, fine, but ignoring it is disingenuous.
- gridlockd 7y ago> What Purism is telling us is, essentially, if you want to take a stand against the proprietary world, you have to give up everything. To be fair, when it comes hardware manufacturing, that's pretty much the state of affairs. They had to give up almost everything, and they have no choice but passing that on to you.
- iamnothere 7y ago> $750 gets you an iPhone with sophisticated cameras, the fastest mobile processor on the market, and software support for 5 years if not longer. Walk into stores across the country to get service and support. What Purism is telling us is, essentially, if you want to take a stand against the proprietary world, you have to give up everything. You have to use a chunky, ugly, crudely assembled phone. You have to give up acceptable power management. And you still have to pay $750, all of this on the cusp of Apple releasing a new $399 phone according to rumors, Google selling $399 phones, and budget brands like Motorola providing an absolutely acceptable experience for under $200 on some models. You could get this for $750, and it wouldn't be open source. That's the whole point of this project. Nobody is buying a Librem who doesn't care about freedom. Mainstream devices are cheaper for a reason: ecosystem/app store lock-in and (in the case of Android) capturing your data. Economy of scale is a factor too. Choosing open tech shouldn't be a sacrifice, but it usually is. There's less money coming in, so the end experience will never be as polished.
- ethbro 7y agoAssuming the $750 vs $200 price disparity... That means $550 is what the Android collection of companies is willing to pay to acquire your personal data stream. (And a price at which they think they can make a profit off you at)