2 ms·
> A domain isn't property in any standard sense of the word I'm not sure what you think the "standard sense of the word" is, but "property" in any sense is alr
by pdonis 7y ago
> A domain isn't property in any standard sense of the word
I'm not sure what you think the "standard sense of the word" is, but "property" in any sense is already a fiction: it only exists because we humans agree to all act as if it does. We make such agreements because it's the only way to prevent incessant conflict over scarce resources. This applies to domain names as much as it does to houses, cars, etc.
> what you're talking about is known as "eminent domain" and is already a real thing for real property.
And is abused by governments quite often. For example, see Kelo v. New London.
> Actually in this case "civil forfeiture" (for the crime of extortion) would probably be a better analogy.
Which is also abused by governments quite often.
- gpm 7y ago"Property" has a standard sense, as in a legal sense... domains derive value from an informal understanding that DNS providers respect them, which has nothing to do with their standing as property in the legal sense if they even qualify (I'm not sure, but I don't think they would). No argument from me that governments do abuse eminent domain and civil forfeiture... that doesn't mean they are never good ideas. This is one of those cases that they are.
- pdonis 7y ago> "Property" has a standard sense, as in a legal sense... That makes it clearer where you are coming from. Then the answer is that it depends a lot on the jurisdiction, on who the parties are, and other things. There does not appear to be settled law either way. However... > No argument from me that governments do abuse eminent domain and civil forfeiture... that doesn't mean they are never good ideas. This is one of those cases that they are. Eminent domain and civil forfeiture both assume that the things being seized are property. If domain names are just service contracts, you're talking about things like injunctions to prevent performance of the contract, which are different beasts legally.
- crooked-v 7y agoDomain names get regularly treated like property in legal disputes, and enough judges doing that creates a certain precedent regardless of the contracts involved.
- pdonis 7y ago> Domain names get regularly treated like property in legal disputes In some disputes, yes. In other disputes, they get treated like service contracts. That's why I said there does not seem to be settled law either way.