3 ms·
Too soon, I know, but can we soon start talking about abandoning all corporate-managed open source projects? I wouldn't be surprised at this move if I were a C
by 0xbadcafebee 7y ago
Too soon, I know, but can we soon start talking about abandoning all corporate-managed open source projects?
I wouldn't be surprised at this move if I were a CoreOS user, but I would be pretty pissed off that the next 6 months of my work would be migrating to a new platform for production work, all because the Linux distro I used got bought for its IP and customer list.
Or, say when HashiCorp is eventually bought, and suddenly its parent company decides, no more free tools for you, kids! Buy our other, more crappy products instead, but here's some free samples you can use at small scale. Also you need to rewrite all your code.
This extends to virtually every important project in the cloud computing ecosystem. They're all just run by companies, not a distributed decentralized community of users and developers (cat-herded by a BDFL) like every successful multi-generational open source project. There's also only one widely-supported Linux distribution in the world which isn't run by a corporation, meaning if that distribution ever goes down, everyone who uses Linux for more than its kernel is at the mercy of that given corporation, and we'll probably see massive fragmentation.
Open Source and GNU basically got its start to prevent corporations from preventing you from doing what you wanted with software, but it had a nasty side-effect: they can now make whatever you do with it obsolete and unsupportable. A bit like a car manufacturer no longer shipping replacement parts, forcing you to find some machinists to support an aging fleet of obsolete vehicles. And sure, if the impact is only to corporate engineers, who cares, but as one of those engineers, it is very annoying that we literally are letting them do this to us.
- yodon 7y agoThis isn't a corporate-managed open source problem, it's a single developer managed open source problem, with the corporate entity functioning like a single entity. Tons of great open source project exist as updating projects through the force of will of a single passionate developer. When that developer moves on, the project dies. The open source license grants others the ability to continue, but without that singular developer and their passion the reality is in most cases no one will pick up the project and carry it forward. Sure there are examples where projects do survive the death or disappearance of a maintainer, but there are far more projects out there in need of a new maintainer than find one.
- carapace 7y agoMicrosoft owns GitHub.
- einpoklum 7y agoIt's not too soon to _talk_ about it, even if this seems not to be realistic at the moment. As developers or users it is a good idea to push projects we're involved with to have non-corporate distribute governance to begin with, or move in that direction. Of course, that requires multiple people from different organizations or unaffiliated to "adopt" projects as the "apple of their eye", enough to be involved in managing it; and to avoid deterioration into the one-developer-project case. So, a lot of effort by a lot of people, we should each do our part where we are involved. Also, I'm sure there are lots of GNU/Linux distros which aren't run by a commercial corporation; certainly more than one.