5 ms·
I don't think it's only cultural, software businesses also have very few assets that could be liquidated. Volkswagen might finance 2/3 of everything it does wit
by wongarsu 7y ago
I don't think it's only cultural, software businesses also have very few assets that could be liquidated. Volkswagen might finance 2/3 of everything it does with debt, but if it just stopped tomorrow and sold all production facilities then lenders would get more than half their money back. If a typical software startup stops operating and sells off all its assets it gets a bit of spare change and the lenders leave with close to nothing.
- martinald 7y agoI'm really not sure if that's the case. With some stuff (eg: car fleets) which are pretty liquid they may get a return. But on some super specialised machinery for VW which only makes VW specific parts they are going to really struggle to get any money for it.
- sokoloff 7y agoIndustrial machinery is usually more fungible/configurable than that. No one (except the secondary parts makers) has much use for the dies to stamp out Tiguan fenders, but lots of sheet metal fabs (inc other auto makers) can use the stamping presses. It might be 30¢ on the dollar, but that’s likely better than the office chair and laptop that a software startup will leave behind.
- martinald 7y agoOh totally agree at them getting something for it. Just I doubt they'd get 2/3rds of the value of equipment.
- ska 7y agoThe claim was different : that maybe 2/3 of their business activity was financed, and if it was liquidated tomorrow the lender would be able to get “more than half” of that back.
- ec109685 7y agoThe users paying each month are the assets in this article’s thesis. As long as when a company shuts down, they transition their users to a new entity (since they are valuable reoccurring revenue), the lenders will get paid.
- sokoloff 7y agoAre you imagining a successful company with a large book of users generating a healthy ARR? If that’s the situation, the lenders will get paid, because the business will keep running. The more likely risk to a bond holder is that the company fails to generate a healthy business, pays most of the loan out in salary while trying, and now the lenders own the company which is a couple of two year old laptops and a few thousand per year in ARR that cannot be profitably served.
- stanleydrew 7y agoThe essay is explicitly talking about the former. Rather than sell a bunch of dilutive equity at Series B, a company with decent recurring revenue could collateralize that revenue stream and sell it.
- nemothekid 7y agoIn what situation would you opt for a dilutive series B where you had enough revenue that a bank would collaterize it for you? If you are profitable, then it’s probably wiser to not take the dilution round. If you aren’t, your revenue is likely worthless as I can’t imagine a bank would have the risk appetite to turn a money losing venture into a profitable one by taking it over
- ec109685 7y agoYou need the money to scale sales operations to the level of revenue.
- nemothekid 7y ago
- juped 7y agoUsually you do a voluntary reorganization between the creditors and the business in the event of default, and a business with steady revenue is often an asset worth owning.