3 ms·
I seem to be the first to raise the Deming point of view again, but I'm glad to, so here goes: One of the big problems with trying to rate workers is that most
by kqr 7y ago
I seem to be the first to raise the Deming point of view again, but I'm glad to, so here goes:
One of the big problems with trying to rate workers is that most workers have approximately the same rating. In other words, the differences in ratings are not statistically significant; they are just as well explained by pure chance.
Building a system where you incentivise and promote on a random draw of cards is bad in and of itself, but doing it and then labeling it as being based on merit is actively hostile to anything you're trying to accomplish. You are building a culture of people stabbing each other in the back in desperation to win your lottery, and not a healthy environment of cooperation and focus on productivity.
Yes, sometimes you have a worker who performs off the charts in either direction. That's a great opportunity! If they perform much better than someone else, put them in a position where they can coach and train others in how to do things that well. If they are much worse, try training them or otherwise find them a different job they can do better.
Other than that special case, the only way to improve the performance of the system is to give the workers better tools, better information, better understanding, more cooperation, better ability to do their job. The manager is the only one standing in the way of the workers doing a better job.
But then how do you assign bonuses and raises when everyone performs approximately the same? Split them across everyone. That simple. Think in terms of incentivising the team, not the individual.
And things like promotions that can't be shared among many people? Ask the workers themselves who they think are a good fit for the position. Chances are they know that hell of a lot better than a manager will. And it is abundantly clear how to get a promotion: make a good impression on your team. Cooperate, teach, help out, be nice, do good work. And these are -- by a weird coincidence -- just the things you want to accomplish.
- eadmund 7y agoI mostly agree with you, but: > And it is abundantly clear how to get a promotion: make a good impression on your team. Cooperate, teach, help out, be nice, do good work. … it strikes me that the problem is that the way to get a promotion would be to seem to cooperate, teach, help out, be nice & do good work, not necessarily actually do those things — one might end up with promotees who simply know how to game the system. It might still be preferable to the current state of affairs, which as you note hardly works.
- ricardobeat 7y agoIf the assessment is done by the colleagues who benefit from those behaviors, at that point "gaming the system" means actually doing those things. You can only fake it when the evaluation is done by a third person / manager.
- k__ 7y agoCrabs in a bucket. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crab_mentality https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crab_mentality
- xvilka 7y agoIf you split the bonuses between the team evenly then outperformers will go to another company that will offer them personal incentive which will be bigger that way.
- kqr 7y agoObviously don't do that when you actually have outperformers. My point was that even if you think you do, that's very rarely the case.
- rightbyte 7y agoYou imply that the outperformers would be fairly recognized by management. I guess that both concerning layoffs and bonuses doing lifo respectively uniform or linear with time at the company would have best results. My understanding is that the bosses don't really know how much valuable work people do.
- whiddershins 7y agoThis entire premise, that people are usually more or less equally capable at a given task, doesn’t correspond to my experience at all, across several industries. It seems ideological, or philosophical or based on limited industries. It can also be dehumanizing to imply people can’t get any result from trying hard, or that everyone has equal abilities. I’m just not exactly sure why you are saying this, what it is based on, and what the goal is here.
- jt2190 7y ago... [P]eople are usually more or less capable at a given task... True. But few if any “jobs” held by knowledge workers are just a single, repetitive task, over and over, like Demming was observing when he studied productivity on assembly lines. So while you may find a team has variation among members when looking at a single skill, as a manager it’s really hard to pin down the success of the team to one thing done by one person. In fact, from a management point of view, “success” is often “we got the job done” and not “everything was done perfectly”, so a team member who does one or two things really well is treated more or less like an outlier, and their work averages out.[1] Unless... Unless the manager has unwittingly pitted the members of the team against each other, in order to find the “top performer”! This will reduce productivity of the team overall as they waste time defending against each other. A net loss overall. Don’t get me wrong, there are times when competition is healthy, but quite often it’s applied as a kind of micro-optimization that doesn’t really benefit the organization overall. (Many orgs have enough money to allow this nonsense, unfortunately.) [1] Try and write a job description for someone on your team, and you’ll quickly realize how complicated it is to even know what skills are key, which are nice to have, etc.
- kqr 7y agoThere's an important distinction to make which I'm not sure I've successfully communicated: when I'm saying there generally is no "statistically significant" difference, I'm not saying everyone performs at the same level. There can be huge variations in performance between people. But this variation tends to be internally consistent. You don't have one or two workers that perform multiple standard deviations away from the mass. Think of it as drawing people from a distribution with large variance. When assigning bonuses to individuals, you're looking for statistical anomalies, i.e. you want to find that one person that appears to be drawn from a completely different distribution. That is what is very rare. Large variation in performance but without any statistical anomalies still means everyone is performing "within the systems natural boundaries." There's no reason to suspect someone comes at it from a completely different angle. That said, of course you want to minimise the variation of your system. If nothing else because it makes it easier for you to find the true outliers. But you don't reduce variance by giving raises to the top performers -- that will, at the very best, make them perform better, thus increasing variance further. Better try to reduce variance by bringing the other people up, which requires much more involved management than just giving more money to the ones with the high numbers.