5 ms·
I don't understand. I don't want my start menu to search my files or the internet or be smart in any way, I just want it to show my installed programs or apps o
by lentil_soup 7y ago
I don't understand. I don't want my start menu to search my files or the internet or be smart in any way, I just want it to show my installed programs or apps or whatever you want to call them. If I want to search my files I have a program for that, if I want to search the internet I open my browser. Why do we have to over complicate things! Who asked for this?
- lsd5you 7y agoLikely a rhetorical question, but they're trying trying to become the place where people go to look for things ... since apparently there is a massive amount of value (at least enough to risk the windows user experience) in controlling that entry point into search.
- r00fus 7y agoThe same reason IE was integrated into the OS in 1998. To embrace, extend & extinguish.
- colejohnson66 7y agoWhat are they embracing so they can extinguish in this instance?
- dntbnmpls 7y agoThe IE integration with Windows was to extinguish Netscape Navigator. So I'm guessing this move is probably to destroy chrome and indirectly google search. Microsoft used their OS monopoly to destroy Netscape. Not sure if it will work today since they don't dominate the smartphone space.
- xkemp 7y agoOr, maybe, document/file search is a pretty useful and commonly expected feature for a desktop operating system? And extending it to online search is an entirely natural next step? Even if this were a plot against Google, it would simply be bog-standard competition. It has absolutely none of the characteristics of "Embrace, Extend, Extinguish".
- catcalendar 7y agoI can't believe you'd suggest something as rediculous as users wanting a unified search bar that just gives them what they want regardless of context. History has shown time and time again that users like diversity and would prefer a solution that they can tailor together in a piecemeal fashion after trying all their options.
- coribuci 7y ago> What are they embracing so they can extinguish in this instance? Firefox, linux, open source. It's really funny how a lot of open source projects are hosted in github.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI would be ok if it did things in a predictable and configurable way. But it sometimes feels almost random.
- agumonkey 7y agoAt this point.. I think it's fair to call it a MS tradition. I don't think I ever recall searching in windows to be useful out of the box (or even after tweaking). Compare this to stuff like Everything..
- cosmiccatnap 7y agoAdvertisers and government agencies ask for this...
- blondin 7y agothey failed to find a good place for that search, but the feature, itself, is extremely valuable. on the mac, for example, spotlight search is part of things i do on autopilot. that's how they should have presented that search functionality. a keyboard shortcut, big search field in the middle of the screen... cortana shouldn't have been the front focus here... i still use it though. would be sad to see it go! i use it to see where stuff and settings that were obvious and easy to find before are now hidden.