5 ms·
Random thoughts: 1. I applaud the fact that they are actually quitting the company to voice their disapproval of these policies. In my mind all the "internal a
by paxys 7y ago
Random thoughts:
1. I applaud the fact that they are actually quitting the company to voice their disapproval of these policies. In my mind all the "internal activism" happening at Google and others is massively hypocritical. One cannot publicly criticize a company while enjoying cushy paychecks fueled by those very activities they despise.
2. If they think Google is discriminatory towards LGBT employees and minorities, contributing to climate change etc., they are in for a big shock once they are really out of the Google and SV bubble.
- binthere 7y agohttps://i0.wp.com/thenib.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/mister-gotcha-4-9faefa-1.jpg https://i0.wp.com/thenib.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/mist...
- gnicholas 7y agoThat oversimplifies things a bit — leaving a company is not as extreme as "leaving society".
- shadowgovt 7y agoRegarding (2): while it's true that the average is absolutely terrible, that can actually increase the importance of not letting the leaders off the hook for screwing up. i.e. the world ought to look more like the leader, not the average; regression to the mean is not desirable.
- pm90 7y agoStrongly disagree. > In my mind all the "internal activism" happening at Google and others is massively hypocritical. One cannot publicly criticize a company while enjoying cushy paychecks fueled by those very activities they despise. Absolutely incorrect. Paychecks have nothing to do with whether you as a person find the company's policies palatable or not. Google employees provide a lot more value to Google than they are compensated for. They are well within their rights and should be encouraged to voice their honest opinions. > 2. If they think Google is discriminatory towards LGBT employees and minorities, contributing to climate change etc., they are in for a big shock once they are really out of the Google and SV bubble. So you would have them STFU, because the rest of the country sucks? This sounds completely backwards and doesn't make any sense to me.
- scardycat 7y ago> Google employees provide a lot more value to Google than they are compensated for. how? can you justify what makes these people (you) so special? IN all honesty, they are probably overvalued in every sense. >Absolutely incorrect. Paychecks have nothing to do with whether you as a person find the company's policies palatable or not You are right because they already made their money and can afford to quit over whatever. Of course it has to do with money. Anyone who thinks otherwise is lying to themselves. If money did not matter, they would have not worked at Google, there are other ways to make the world a better place than add snow effect on photos.
- baddox 7y ago> how? How do we know that employees provide more value than their compensation? Because Google makes profit.
- scardycat 7y agoSo? Facebook makes profit, the gas station down the street makes profit. How does a software engineer at Google worth more value than one at timbuktu? No, they are not. They just are not in the right place at the right time. Do you think selling ads is changing the world? Do you think that makes you worth more than someone else? Wake up and smell the coffee.
- baddox 7y agoWhen I say "value" in this context I'm just talking about money. I'm not making a moral value judgement about individuals or the company overall. All I'm saying is that employees are clearly creating more monetary value for the company than what they're being compensated.
- andrewzah 7y ago> the gas station down the street makes profit The gas station down the street isn't paying its employees six figure salaries. That employee might be making $7.25 an hour, which is the federal limit. Assuming 40 hours per week and 52 weeks per year (no time off!), that's 15k before taxes. Is that gas station clerk a better/more worthwhile person than a gas station clerk in timbuktu? > Do you think that makes you worth more than someone else? Getting paid more than someone else doesn't make you a better person than someone else. It just means you're earning more income, and that company is willing to pay you that income for any multitude of reasons. That's it. Programmers can provide immense value to companies, and companies make handsome profits despite paying their engineers immense salaries. This also has to do with cost of living in some areas: chicago is more expensive than many places in the world, so if you want to base a company in chicago and pay someone who lives in chicago to work for you, you need more money. It's not rocket science. I think many companies don't need to be based in SF or Seattle, etc, but that's another discussion.
- baddox 7y agoConsider what happens if everyone who has a moral complaint about their employer immediately quits rather than staying around and attempting to chase the complaint up the management hierarchy and/or educate and organize other employees to voice the complaint. I think utilizing one's power as a worker and aligning other workers to increase workers' power is far from hypocritical. It's a great way (perhaps the only reliable way) to hold companies accountable for their actions and improve companies' treatment of workers and society.
- paxys 7y ago> Consider what happens if everyone who has a moral complaint about their employer immediately quits This is in fact the quickest way to ensure that this behavior immediately stops
- baddox 7y agoI don't think that's true, precisely because the employee with a complaint can potentially increase their leverage significantly by educating and organizing other employees around the cause. Your analysis seems to assume that there's some fixed percentage of employees who think some action from their employer is bad, and if that percentage is high enough, then all those employees could quit, which would either somehow signal to the employer that their action was bad or would damage the company so much that they would need to change their actions. I think that's wishful thinking, and of course the percentage of employees with a complaint is not fixed and can be directly increased by internal efforts to organize. That applies not just to internal awareness, but also public awareness: note that we're only having discussions about cases where employees attempted to organize other employees.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoIf everyone who participated in the Google Walkout (20% of their workforce) stayed out until Google addressed their complaints, rather than returning to work after their lunch hour was over, all seven demands would've been met, instead of one. (And they probably would've still got paid!) I have my doubts that tech companies could operate with a sudden loss of 20% of their workforce and talent base. If a company knows you will return to work no matter how much you complain, they are not going to take you seriously. (This was the Walkout's mistake.) And if, as an individual, you make too much noise, you'll just get fired. (See numerous individual examples.) Decisive collective action works, and that's what unions figured out a long time ago.
- crdoconnor 7y ago>One cannot publicly criticize a company while enjoying cushy paychecks Why is it that you think that the people who see the sausage being made are exactly the ones most unqualified to criticize it?
- paxys 7y agoThese people aren't seeing the sausage being made — they are the ones making the sausage
- notJim 7y agoOkay, so we're all at the sausage factory one day making sausage. We notice that we're shoving an awful lot of rat shit into the sausages, but the boss says it's more profitable this way. We get together and tell the boss, look we're not gonna keep shoving rat shit into the sausage. To you, this is illegitimate, because we're paying our rent out of profits from the rat shit, after all. So fine, we decide to leave. Now the boss hires new employees, and the process continues. Ultimately, I think hypocrisy is the wrong lens to look at this through. Activists are not seeking purity or moral perfection, we're seeking change. Change requires organizing, which has to start within the company. An individual employee does fuck-all if they leave by themselves.
- ameister14 7y ago>We get together and tell the boss, look we're not gonna keep shoving rat shit into the sausage. No, that's not it at all. He's saying you get together and tell the boss "Hey, there's some rat shit in this sausage, but I'm gonna go ahead and keep making it." That's why it's perceived as illegitimate. You're expecting other people to sacrifice but not yourself.
- paxys 7y ago> We get together and tell the boss, look we're not gonna keep shoving rat shit into the sausage Absolutely no one at Google is doing that. What is happening is that these employees are telling their bosses "we would prefer not to shove rat shit into sausages" and the bosses are saying "no". Then these employees are going home and posting about it on social media and going back to work making the same sausage the next day.
- kick 7y ago2. If they think Google is discriminatory towards LGBT employees and minorities, contributing to climate change etc., they are in for a big shock once they are really out of the Google and SV bubble. This is a particularly subversive brand of whataboutism. "Company has participated in Bad Thing." "Ah, but Other Company also participates in Bad Thing! Your criticism of Company is therefore invalid!" "Company took $1,000,000,000 from Bad Industry! We should scold that behavior!" "Ah, but Other Company took $2,000,000,000 from Bad Industry! Company therefore shouldn't be criticized!" One action can be bad without negating the badness of another action.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 7y agoWhataboutism is one of the most ridiculous accusations thrown around willy-nilly these days. Sure, if you have no idea what happens in the world, you can arbitrarily find anything outrageous. It is trivial to create outrage in a vacuum, blind of all facts that threaten to challenge your rose-tinted world view.
- gkoberger 7y agoMy only concern (this goes for political administrations too) is that resigning is a one-time thing. It gets press, hurts a bit, but that’s it... then you’re out and can’t make internal change. And you’re replaced with people more comfortable with the bad status quo. I respect when people stay, too... they’re trying to make change from within where they have some power, rather than outside where they have none.
- tehjoker 7y agoStrikes are more effective than unorganized internal advocacy and quitting. They force management to consider the viewpoint of workers or they lose control and money.
- notJim 7y agoYou can't start with the strike though. One person striking is called a sick day. You have to start with organizing, which necessarily means that you're going to be working at a place whose practices you disagree with.
- jancsika 7y ago> One cannot publicly criticize a company while enjoying cushy paychecks fueled by those very activities they despise. Quitting one's job is disruptive enough that it's reasonable for one to make several good faith attempts to make changes from the inside before pulling the trigger. And that includes making public critiques as people from every industry do all the time. There are of course cases where one only gives lip service in order to gain social karma points while continuing to rake in the dough. But separating those cases from the actions of reasonable, ethical people takes more than setting a "one bit" Manichean flag for hypocrisy. Don't get me wrong-- skepticism should be used when assessing any critique by someone still collecting a paycheck. But rejecting all such claims out of hand strikes me as flip and extreme. Or at least doing so requires a persuasive argument, and you did not provide one.
- MeltySmelty 7y agothis person is definitely mentally ill and does not realize they live in a bubble
- agumonkey 7y ago1. seconded leaving a job early is already tough, leaving a big profile name over politics even more so 2. didn't their datacenter carbon neutral though ? or is this Apple ?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]