5 ms·
This is just the nature of public transit. Half of car commutes in LA are under 30 minutes: https://www.geotab.com/time-to-commute https://www.geotab.com/time-t
by rayiner 7y ago
This is just the nature of public transit. Half of car commutes in LA are under 30 minutes: https://www.geotab.com/time-to-commute https://www.geotab.com/time-to-commute. Just 7% of public transit commutes are under 30%, and 27% are over an hour. Part of this is because U.S. public transit is bad. But driving in the U.S. is still faster than taking public transit in other countries. The average commute in the U.S. (where 5% take public transit) is half as long as in Korea (where 55% use public transit): https://www.oecd.org/social/family/LMF2_6_Time_spent_travelling_to_and_from_work.pdf https://www.oecd.org/social/family/LMF2_6_Time_spent_travell....
I used to have what was a pretty great commute. I'd walk a block from my high-rise apartment in westchester to the train station. In 35 minutes I was at Grand Central, and then I'd walk another block to my high-rise office. Now, I dream of working at the suburban office park I can get to in 5 minutes (during rush hour) from my house, which is right across the street from my kid's day care. Maybe in an electric car even.
- helen___keller 7y ago> Now, I dream of working at the suburban office park I can get to in 5 minutes (during rush hour) from my house, which is right across the street from my kid's day care. I agree with the appeal, but I've always found the biggest issue with this dream is the need for utter stability. If you quit your job, you might end up with a new one at an office 30 minutes down the highway. If your partner works, it's even harder to keep two commutes low. If you move with each new job, you may have to uproot your kid and send them to a new school.
- rayiner 7y agoFor sure.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoCommute time is mostly a function of metro area population, not mode of transportation. Half of South Korea's population is in the Seoul metro (which has a huge population), so the average commute time is very high. Compare NYC to LA: LA is driving dominant and has the longer commute time, despite a smaller population than NYC.
- adjkant 7y agoIt's not about population but rather density. LA's big public transit problem (outside of the driving first culture lobbied for by American car companies) is actually one of zoning and building.
- robomartin 7y ago> outside of the driving first culture lobbied for by American car companies Sorry, this is false. Los Angeles simply didn't evolve to favor public transportation in the way a lot of European cities have. A simple example of this is the ridiculous concentration of tech and aerospace companies inside of a zone that requires almost everyone to use the 405 freeway. I know people who would rather have their fingernails removed without anesthesia than do drive the 405 in rush-hour traffic. I might include myself in that group. Who gives out building and business permits? Car companies? No. The city, the county, the State. Why do they allow such concentration? OK, maybe concentration makes sense at some level. Why, then, do they allow concentration where they do? One look at the map --particularly if armed with traffic pattern familiarity-- instantly tells you it isn't a good idea to pile-up so many businesses in these areas. So, no, car companies have nothing whatsoever to do with it. It's about urban planning and design. We could use public transportation but it would take me somewhere in the range of two to three hours longer per day to go almost anywhere and come back. Sorry, my time is far more valuable than that. And, to complete the picture, this means spending somewhere in the range of six hours per day coming and going from the aforementioned tech centers. And then you have to work 8 to 10, if not 12, hours per day.
- cmendel 7y agoThis isn't true though. There used to be light rail in LA, it was bought up and then shuttered by Ford and the like.
- robomartin 7y agoI said a lot of things there, which part isn't true, that it would take me six hours to take public transport to some parts of Los Angeles from where I am? With regards to the myth of car companies driving or forcing urban development in a place like Los Angeles (really, think about that for a moment), here's the most complete research on Los Angeles mass transport I have ever found: https://media.metro.net/projects_studies/crenshaw/images/presentation_crenshawlax_2014-09.pdf https://media.metro.net/projects_studies/crenshaw/images/pre... There are an array of interconnected competing interests that drive the evolution of a city or region. For example, good union jobs building highways, suburban home developments and driving buses (one train = one conductor; 100 buses = 100 union jobs), etc. No, car companies are not that powerful. Los Angeles did this to itself over a very long period of time and for a number of reasons not having much to do with this fable of a car company promoted car culture. The simplest explanation is: It just happened. This isn't unlike the internet, which just exploded at one point and it is what it is. If we had to design it from scratch today with the benefit of hindsight we would likely change quite a few things. Same with cities. You get what you get, unless someone early enough had enough vision or was naturally restricted in some way to take a more favorable path. EDIT: I stand corrected. I just checked with Google Maps. There is NO way to take public transport of any kind. Well, at least Google can't solve the routing problem. I think there might be a way if I took something like three buses to get close to where I might be able to reach light rail. Plain and simple, Los Angeles didn't evolve to favor mass transportation.
- bobthepanda 7y ago> Now, I dream of working at the suburban office park I can get to in 5 minutes (during rush hour) from my house, which is right across the street from my kid's day care. Maybe in an electric car even. Personally, I find you need some kind of minimum time separation from work, otherwise you don't get the sense of separation between work and home life. I had a 5 minute walk from my house as a work commute once, and I much prefer my 30 minute bus ride today, because by the time I get home I'm in "home mode". The main issue with transit time in the US is that American cities have made intentional policy decisions that result in land uses being far apart and sprawling areas, so a nonstop car trip is the only reasonable option. But everyone making nonstop car trips doesn't scale, which is why the Lincoln and Holland have hour-long waits into the tunnels more often than not.
- njarboe 7y agoTunneling could let nonstop car trips scale. If the Boring company can produce a similar improvement in tunneling costs that SpaceX is on launch costs, it could be a reality.
- bluGill 7y agoThey can't though. There isn't enough 3d space under the earth that can be practically reached.
- bananabreakfast 7y agoWhat? Sure there is. There's an enormous amount of space under every city to dig through before it becomes impractical to reach.
- bobthepanda 7y agoThe problem is access/exit points to the surface. Graded ramps are high capacity but take up a lot of space since the grade can't be all that steep. Elevators don't take up a lot of space but are really slow, and have worse reliability issues due to the moving parts. How many spots on the surface exist that you could just take a chunk out of for either? Most land in existing cities is already being used for buildings or roads or sidewalks.
- dionidium 7y agoI think this is all correct, but I'd just encourage people to think through the tradeoffs in play. Nothing can compete on time with an extensive point-to-point road network. But a city designed that way is going to be less healthy, harder to walk or bike in, more polluted, noisier, more spread out, and with far more transportation-related deaths and injuries.
- mlrtime 7y agoWhy not just move closer to work?
- CamperBob2 7y agoIt can be tough to do that when both you and your partner work.
- brewdad 7y agoThis. When I lived in Phoenix, my wife worked 30 miles south of downtown. I worked 20 miles north of downtown. Fortunately, we both loved the older neighborhoods downtown and schools weren't a factor at that time in our lives. If they had been, we would have lived 5 miles from her job and I would have had a two hour commute each way or needed to find another job closer to home.
- unapologetic 7y agoNow you dream of an absurd and unsustainable lifestyle.
- sjg007 7y agoThat drive would’ve been 1.5 hours probably.