5 ms·
Upvoted. Your observations, calculus, and conclusions are correct. I'd only suggest that we're already paying for those externalities. It's just that those co
by specialist 7y ago
Upvoted.
Your observations, calculus, and conclusions are correct.
I'd only suggest that we're already paying for those externalities. It's just that those costs are off book. So the feedback loops are broken. Making improvements all but impossible.
A carbon tax would update our accounting rules to capture those costs in a direct and efficient manner.
- jandrese 7y agoThe fundamental problem with the Carbon Market is that we are missing the entire second half of the equation. There is no viable large scale carbon removal technologies that would allow us to set a price per ton of carbon released. The market doesn't work because it is all supply and no demand. If we were serious about this there would be hundreds or thousands of companies competing on the most cost effective way to remove carbon from the atmosphere. All companies would be required to buy enough carbon removal to make them zero net emissions. When you buy a gallon of gas it would have whatever the current market value of 5.5lbs of carbon removal factored in right at the pump. Or that would happen at the refinery and be reflected in the final price of the gas. Unfortunately if you wanted to jump start this market it would be very disruptive to the global economy. Governments worldwide (it's too easy to export pollution, this needs to be a worldwide solution) would have to agree on a very high price to get the market started to avoid undercutting companies wanting to get into it and let the money start forming a pile so terrifically large that people would be scrambling to develop carbon capture technologies faster and cheaper than the competition. There would be a lot of cheating and lying that would need to be policed worldwide. Our current system of governments is not capable of pulling this off. Carbon markets are something people try to entice capitalists with, but only because they don't think people will look at the details. To actually implement them would send those same capitalists howling and screaming to their nearest governmental body with exceptions and rollbacks in hand.
- hcknwscommenter 7y agoMost serious carbon market proposals are not primarily related to removal/sequestration. They are related to reducing emissions. You get credits for emitting less and/or producing low emission technologies (solar panels, EVs, etc.), and can sell them or use them to reduce your tax burden. This type of thing works, when done right.
- thinkcontext 7y agoIts not that they aren't primarily related to it, most proposals are neutral as to whether a ton of CO2 is avoided or sequestered. It just so happens to be the case that its relatively expensive to capture and sequester CO2 from the atmosphere compared to emissions avoidance. The lowest hanging fruit is efficiency (better insulation, more efficient appliances, cars, etc), followed by lower carbon forms of electricity, etc. We'll likely need to do sequestration but, assuming a gradually rising carbon price, it won't make economic sense to do it at scale until we've done the more cost effective things first.
- jandrese 7y agoThe nice thing about working markets is that it would naturally pressure people to do the cost effective stuff first. If buying carbon offsets is appropriately expensive you have a major incentive to avoid buying them.
- jandrese 7y agoThat's just a tax with makeup. That's why they never work in the real world, and why they fall apart under any political pressure. The point of the market is that it provides political pressure from companies on both ends so it is insulated from political whims, at least to some degree. If some company wants to grease their local politicians to get exceptions or have the price set low they get pushback from other companies that want to redeem those credits at full price.
- WorldMaker 7y agoThought experiment: It would be interesting if you could somehow reverse centuries of terrible marketing on blood diamonds and make sequestered/captured "man-made" diamonds more valuable to the average person than ones mined, you might find a lot more interest in sequestration/capture.
- WorldMaker 7y agoPinning carbon pounds to diamond prices might still be an interesting idea. At about 2268 carats per pound, the 2016 per carat cost of diamond at $30,925 (USD) gives us $70,137,900 (USD) per pound of carbon. That actually sounds like a reasonable base price to set carbon taxes/market rates, given what we know/expect of carbon models lately. (No idea how you'd bootstrap that without crashing modern society, but this is currently still mostly a thought experiment.)
- aaron-santos 7y agoAt 222M USD to drive to work in the morning, I'd certainly find other modes of transportation.
- jandrese 7y agoAt that rate you would exhale around $38,500 worth of carbon every day.
- themagician 7y agoMath aside, this highlights that the core problem is people. Too many people. The solution to a lot of the “worlds problems” is less people. A Thanos-style snap would be great for humanity if it was possible.
- WorldMaker 7y agoNot at all. The vast majority of greenhouse gas production has been in industrial processes. While sure, all of that is largely in service to people, it isn't people (and people would be just as happy with similar processes that had fewer externality problems like greenhouse gases; the underlying problem there is Capitalism doesn't take such externalities into account in choosing between alternatives). The early Malthusian models were wrong and this sort of eugenics talk is counter-productive, if not sick/dangerous.
- cesarb 7y ago> carbon removal technologies that would allow us to set a price per ton of carbon released Interesting idea. This reminds me of the "Future Cost Function" used in my country to decide the marginal cost of another MWh of hydroelectric generation. Since this country generates over half of its power from hydroelectricity, and the amount of rain varies seasonally (and also depends on the conditions of both the Pacific and the Atlantic), there's always the question: should we use more of the water from the dams, or should we save the water for later and use the thermal generators instead? If we use too much water, and the next rainy season doesn't rain enough, the reservoirs could run dry (which is really bad, since we don't have enough thermal generators); if we save too much water, we're wasting money on expensive fuel (and in the worst case, the reservoirs could get full and have to throw away the excess water, without having the chance to use it to generate electricity). The "Future Cost Function" model simulates the future cost of the thermal generation for several scenarios, to arrive at a cost for the water which minimizes the total cost (given that less costly generators are dispatched first, so a higher cost for the water means more and more costly thermal generators will be dispatched). What you propose seems similar: you are suggesting to use something we can easily measure (the cost of removing one ton of CO2 from the air) to decide a price for something which would appear to have a zero price otherwise (the cost of emitting one ton of CO2 into the air). I would go even further, given the similarities with what I described above, and somehow put a "target concentration" in the formula, so that initially the cost is higher (to fund removal for the extra CO2 which is already there) and automatically winds down to near zero if the concentration gets near the target (or even overshoots it).
- jandrese 7y agoI wouldn't worry about that last point too much. We've already put so much extra carbon into the atmosphere that even with large scale decarbonization we won't make a dent in the problem in our lifetime.