5 ms·
I wonder why geoengineering proposals, such as seeding the oceans with iron[1], aren't more often discussed as possible mitigations to climate change. [1] - ht
by pmoriarty 7y ago
I wonder why geoengineering proposals, such as seeding the oceans with iron[1], aren't more often discussed as possible mitigations to climate change.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_fertilization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_fertilization
- triceratops 7y agoBecause we've already conducted one grand experiment with planet-scale climate modification, inadvertently. You'd have to have a very high degree of confidence that the "cure" won't make things a lot worse. And that's without even getting into the question of who'll pay for it. The countries most affected by climate change - tropical, developing - are least able to pay for it.
- jandrese 7y agoIIRC that project was ultimately a failure. The plankton didn't sink to the bottom as expected, instead they were eaten by fish and failed to sequester much carbon.
- throwaway5752 7y agoBecause absent a near halt on CO2 emissions they are worthless. We will keep emitting past the point where they are useful and will have a much steeper cliff to fall off. If you have ever seen Futurama's "Crime of the Hot", think of dropping the increasingly large ice cube as the analogy. If we solve emissions, then I think everyone agrees we can look at accelerated weathering and other sequestration strategies.
- wongarsu 7y agoThere's also the option to spray sulphur dioxide into the upper atmosphere to reflect sunlight, similar to volcanic eruptions. I think the main problem is that the effects are hard to predict, so you really only want to do it as a last resort. If we fail to restrict our release of greenhouse gases and CO2 sequestration doesn't get economical and funded in a sensible way, our best option is probably solar shades in low earth orbit (giant sheets of ultra thin foil). It's more expensive than dumping iron in the oceans or sulphur dioxide into the atmosphere, but it's predictable and easy to undo.
- wcoenen 7y ago> our best option is probably solar shades in low earth orbit (giant sheets of ultra thin foil) A thin reflective foil would not stay in a stable orbit because of solar radiation pressure. Instead, you can put it near the L1 Langrange point but slightly more sunward to compensate for that pressure. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4550401/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4550401/
- melling 7y agoI wonder why we’re still in emitting large amounts of greenhouse gases now instead of trying to fix the problem later. 40% of the worlds electricity is generated using coal. If we changed this 10 years ago, we’d have less problems today. If we change this today we’ll have less of a problem in 10 years. We’re coming up with all kinds of clever ideas to deal with the problem in 2050. This is a slow train wreck happening over decades.
- jbattle 7y ago> I wonder why we’re still in emitting large amounts of greenhouse gases now Because enough people make a LOT of money from the status quo
- mistrial9 7y agoagree - but, its not very constructive to put coal on a global average.. Certain economies are really changing, and other economies really are not. There has to be some constructive way forward that engages this...
- jobseeker990 7y agoEnvironmentalists are against technical solutions to climate change because people wouldn't learn anything. They need to experience the effects of their actions so they learn from it. Otherwise they'd just expect technology to save them every time they cause a disaster.
- gbrown 7y ago> because people wouldn't learn anything I mean, I suppose that's part of it, but the biggest reason (if by "technical solutions" you're talking about geoengineering) is that it's pants on fire crazy to run uncontrolled global scale geoengineering experiments. Unfortunately it's looking more and more likely that we'll be left with little choice.
- hcknwscommenter 7y agoNot only is it pants on fire crazy. Most options will almost certainly NOT work. Sequestration, iron seeding, accelerated weathering, and sulfur areosols all suffer from huge scale issues that no one has a serious answer for. I can't keep up with all the crazy ideas, "cloud brightening?", launching 100 MM nanosatellites to dim the sun?, but none of these can scale to the problem. LUCKY FOR US, the problem can be fixed by dramatically lowering emissions. We shall see if we actually come together in time.
- kaybe 7y agoUS congress is funding sulfur aerosol as well as sea salt cloud seeding research, from what I heard with experiments. I feel that even nobody in the community thinks it's a good idea we're getting kind of desperate since so many politicians are asleep at the wheel. https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/01/us-geoengineering-research-gets-lift-4-million-congress https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/01/us-geoengineering-re...
- kaybe 7y agoMostly it's a question about cost, really. Arguably, we should rule out solar radiation management - in the models you get the weirdest side effects, for example if you ramp up amount of stratospheric sulfur aerosol to the maximum effect (which doesn't even cover all of the warming we have already committed to btw), the jetstream collapses. Do you want to be the one to run that test for real? Also, they only combat a part of the problem, eg sea acidification is untouched. (Still, there is coffee talk about a sulfur test from the US soon.. the person they have in mind doesn't seem too stoked though. Not sure what the state is.) Carbon sequestration appears feasible. Options include increased biomass (limited effect and needs protection forever), direct removal (how to store safely and longterm?) and enhanced weathering. All of those cost more per ton of carbon in both energy and price compared to not burning fossil fuels. Techniques don't really exist yet to be deployed at scale either, plus the energy needs to come from somewhere. However, if you have a look at the 1.5°C IPCC report, all the pathways given there assume some kind of carbon capture. The most optimistic one just needs trees, the business-as-usual one needs a massive effort of capturing about half of our yearly emissions starting in 10 years. (!) [0] [0] https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/sites/2/2019/02/SPM3b.png https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/sites/2/2019/02/SPM3... edit: By the way, we have enough fossil fuels in the ground to reach 5000 ppm of CO2. At 1000 ppm humans already have measurable cognitive decline.
- hcknwscommenter 7y agoI think the human mind has difficulty understanding the scale of the problem. Carbon capture cannot work. A ton of coal releases way more than its weight in CO2 when combusted. Same (but a little better at the margin) for oil and Nat Gas. https://www.bp.com/content/dam/bp/business-sites/en/global/corporate/pdfs/energy-economics/statistical-review/bp-stats-review-2018-carbon-emissions-methodology.pdf https://www.bp.com/content/dam/bp/business-sites/en/global/c... We are talking about GIGATONS a year of CO2 that needs to be captured and put somewhere. For every mountain top that is removed, we would have to figure out where to put three more mountains. Not going to happen.
- aurelwu 7y agoiron seeding can increase amount of cyanobacteria which recently have been identified as potentially being methanogenic, thus this might not be a good idea. Unintended side effects of most geoengineering solutions are a big problem - some things like marine cloud brightening might be a bit less risky though. The other big issue is that most of those measures are just a bandaid which offsets a fixed amount of CO2, so it counter acts a few years of emissions but then you can't scale it up anymore. Adding Sulfur to the atmosphere for example can have a cooling effect but alongside other bad effects like acid rain, there are also studies showing that after a certain amount of sulfur, it does not provide a lot of negative forcing anymore.
- davidw 7y agoFeels a bit like logging into the production server to edit the code there. Maybe it'll come to that, but... might be nice to address some of the root cause issues.
- LorenPechtel 7y agoIron seeding was tried--not a good idea. Yes, it had the predicted effects in terms of plankton growth and the rest of the food chain. It did take a lot of CO2 out of the air. However, some of the animal life fell into the deep ocean and slowly decayed--releasing methane. Methane is a far worse greenhouse gas than CO2. Lots of fish but no climate benefit.
- i_am_nomad 7y agoI’d need a source for this, because this seems incorrect. Most of the captured carbon would enter a food cycle, and while some of it might become methane, much more of it would be constantly cycled in the ecosystem, and some would end up as calcium carbonate.
- LorenPechtel 7y agoMost is--it's just the amount that escapes as methane produces as much greenhouse effect as the CO2 that was removed.