6 ms·
If what you've said is all accurate, then yeah, absolutely 100%. Imagine if you return a MacBook to Apple. As part of refurbishing it, they disable half the RA
by Waterluvian 7y ago
If what you've said is all accurate, then yeah, absolutely 100%.
Imagine if you return a MacBook to Apple. As part of refurbishing it, they disable half the RAM (make up a reason, it's broken or whatever). And then sell it to someone described as in its current state.
Heck Tesla could take the engine out and sell it as a lawn ornament. As long as they're not committing crimes by misrepresenting what they're selling.
- sukilot 7y ago> as-is. with original RAM advertised, or the new advertised RAM advertised, or no mention?
- austenallred 7y agoOr if you bought a MacBook and they wiped all of the software you bought from Apple on it and sell the hardware as is? That’s what happens, no? The problem here is the lack of disclosure that the car didn’t have FSD. If Tesla buys a car they can resell it with whatever features they’d like.
- frogpelt 7y agoAnother HUGE part of this is if you are going to sell your Tesla to a third party, you cannot guarantee the feature set they will get. So, if you pay $8,000 for auto pilot etc. you should not expect to recoup a dime of that money when you sell the car to a buyer who has read this story.
- kempbellt 7y agoSeems almost equivalent to selling a personal computer with a copy of Photoshop on it. Before you sell it, you're probably going to want to wipe the hard drive, and therefore Photoshop is gone. I don't know the legalese behind Tesla's features being "licensed" or "sold" as a part of the car, or to the owner, or what the right outcome is here. I get both sides of the argument though.
- frogpelt 7y agoI get the analogy. My point is most people buying used cars will not see used cars and used computers as analogous. And the other point is, even if someone sells a car that supposedly has FDC and EAP enabled it would be foolish to pay for it. Because Tesla can "audit" and remove it on a whim.
- _ph_ 7y agoNo, if you buy a car with FSD or Autopilot, Tesla won't remove it on a whim.
- olivermarks 7y agoAnyone read the Tesla Digital Rights Management small print on this? If I buy a car with extra options (leather, premium stereo etc) I would subsequently sell it with those options. It appears Tesla are removing the digital rights options the PO would have paid for, reverting the car to a base model with option buy new subscriptions - is that correct or do I misunderstand?
- _ph_ 7y agoYou misunderstood. If you privately resell your Tesla, the purchased licensed software stays with the car. This car was sold and priced by Tesla s not having autopilot. Consequentely, they removed it, when they discovered, it was still activated. But a car purchased with the autopilot option, keeps it.
- leereeves 7y ago> a car purchased with the autopilot option, keeps it. What evidence inspires you to say that? Do you have private information showing that Tesla did in fact say: "the sticker is wrong, the test drive is wrong, this car doesn't include FSD"? According to the story, Tesla sold this vehicle at auction with FSD enabled, and with a sticker saying it had FSD. In the absence of other evidence, that means Tesla sold the car with the autopilot option, and then removed it.
- leereeves 7y agoOn the other hand, if FSD is treated like software, you should still own a license for the FSD software, and be able to use it on a new Tesla without paying for it again. But somehow I suspect Tesla won't allow that either, and they'll try to argue that every buyer (even used) has to pay them for FSD on every car. Or they'll switch to a subscription model where you have to pay every year.
- _ph_ 7y agoOf course you can. If you bought the car with auto pilot, you can sell a car with auto pilot. Tesla has nothing to do with it. The article describes a case, where the dealer seems to have bought a car without autopilot.
- leereeves 7y agoNo, the car had autopilot when Tesla sold it (Nov 15), then Tesla later removed AP, after they sold the car (Nov 18), because the new owner hadn't paid for AP.
- _ph_ 7y agoAutopilot was active, but according to the article update, not purchased by the dealer. The deal between the dealer and the final owner of the car didn't play a role in this.
- leereeves 7y agoThe dealer was the owner when Tesla disabled AP, not Tesla. That's a third-party dealer who bought the car at auction, not a Tesla-dealer (which don't exist). The dealer is a private party. It shouldn't matter whether the dealer or Alec was the owner, the point is, Tesla wasn't.
- _ph_ 7y agoThe question is, whether that dealer bought the car with the autopilot included. If yes, he can sue Tesla, if not, then it was ok for Tesla to disable it. And the updates point to the fact, that the car was sold without autopilot as a feature.
- leereeves 7y ago> And the updates point to the fact, that the car was sold without autopilot as a feature. What updates point to that? The sticker says the car had AP, the disclosure doesn't say otherwise, and everyone seems to agree the car did in fact have AP enabled when Tesla sold it on Nov 15. What evidence says Tesla sold the car without AP? It doesn't matter that Tesla's records say the car shouldn't have had AP, it did have it. It also doesn't matter whether Tesla wronged Alec or the dealer here. In either case, if the story is accurate, Tesla sabotaged a car they'd already sold because they accidentally left a feature enabled that they didn't want to.
- pbreit 7y agoApple’s refurbished products have absolutely been scrubbed of any extra software added by previous owner.
- gnicholas 7y agoYeah, and it's clear the computers come wiped. The issue here is that they sold the car with a sticker that included several mfr-added features and then later took them away.
- pbreit 7y agoIt's not clear what the dealer thought they were buying from Tesla nor how the dealer represented the car to the buyer. The brand new sticker is generally not used in a pre-owned sale. There would be a new sticker.
- bm1362 7y agoThat’s not a great analogy. Apple sells a computer with an extra Siri service. You return it and they resell to another consumer who has the option to purchase the Siri package. Seems reasonable to me.
- stevewodil 7y agoIt can be looked at like if you buy Final Cut Pro from apple, when you trade in the MacBook they reset it thereby removing that application The next owner doesn't get final cut pro just because you purchased it
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pxeboot 7y agoIn that case, the original owner keeps their FCP license. Does Tesla allow auto pilot to be transferred to a new model?
- virgilp 7y agoIf you sold FCP back to Apple with the computer, it’s all fine. Problem is - Apple gives laptop with licensed FCP to computer dealer to sell, dealer puts up price for “MBP+FCP”, then Apple remotely wipes it claiming it was there by mistake. At the very least a large misstep for Apple, and misrepresentation on the dealer’s part. Customer who buys it did nothing wrong.
- stevewodil 7y agoThat I'm not sure of, anyone have experience with this?
- leereeves 7y ago> Imagine if you return a MacBook to Apple. As part of refurbishing it, they disable half the RAM (make up a reason, it's broken or whatever). And then sell it to someone described as in its current state. This is more like you bought a MacBook from Apple, which had 8GB of RAM, but when you downloaded a software update, half the RAM was disabled. Then when you complained, Apple said "Oops, we shouldn't have sold it to you with 8GB."