5 ms·
> The owner in question, who Jalopnik refers to as Alec, purchased the car last December. The dealer bought the car a month earlier from a Tesla auction, with b
by gnicholas 7y ago
> The owner in question, who Jalopnik refers to as Alec, purchased the car last December. The dealer bought the car a month earlier from a Tesla auction, with both “Enhanced Autopilot” and “Full Self Driving Mode” features intact
> TESLA: Tesla has recent identified instances of customers being incorrectly configured for Autopilot versions that they did not pay for. Since, there was an audit done to correct these instances. Your vehicle is one of the vehicles that was incorrectly configured for Autopilot. We looked back at your purchase history and unfortunately Full-Self Driving was not a feature that you had paid for.
So Buyer 1 bought a vehicle from Tesla that in fact had a feature. Buyer 1 then sold to Buyer 2, advertising this feature. Now Tesla is saying "Full-Self Driving was not a feature that you had paid for". That's incorrect under any interpretation of the events. Tesla could say that it wasn't a feature that Buyer 1 paid for, but Buyer 2 definitely paid for it because it was advertised as having the feature and that would have impacted his willingness to pay for the vehicle.
The way Tesla has worded this makes it seem like they would potentially disable features for people who buy Teslas used — regardless of whether the first owner paid for that feature — on the grounds that "X was not a feature that you had paid for".
I don't see how the $8,000 (or less, since it's a used vehicle?) that Tesla would get from this would be worth this terrible publicity.
- dangus 7y agoInterestingly, they also said that you can’t get refunds for accidental purchases because you can’t just pay for a new roof on your house and then ask for a refund after it’s done (or some analogy like that). Yeah no that’s bullshit, software can totally be removed, as we see here.
- resoluteteeth 7y ago> Tesla could say that it wasn't a feature that Buyer 1 paid for Tesla sold the car to Buyer 1 (the dealer) with the feature enabled. I think that means that it was in fact a feature that Buyer 1 paid for, even if they didn't purchase the feature in a separate transaction. If you sell someone a house with a roof, you don't get to go back and say "sorry I just noticed that the roof upgrade was never purchased for this house so I'm going to remove the roof unless you pay another $6000."
- jschwartzi 7y agoExactly. All Tesla is doing here is destroying the resale value of their cars. If Ford sells me a car that has ADAS installed, it's listed on the sticker, and the features work, then the price is completely immaterial and if they later try to disable it remotely I can't imagine the courts would look favorably on that. This just killed any remaining desire I might have had to buy anything from Tesla.
- JadeNB 7y ago> Exactly. All Tesla is doing here is destroying the resale value of their cars. Not just the resale value, but the value, full stop. If I buy a car, I'm more worried, at least in the short term, about its features ceasing to work for me than I am about their not working for the next buyer.
- gnicholas 7y agoThis article doesn't make clear if the sticker on the first sale listed this feature. I think this could be relevant if Tesla were dealing with Buyer 1, but totally irrelevant with regard to Buyer 2 (who would have never seen the sticker from the first sale).
- resoluteteeth 7y ago> This article doesn't make clear if the sticker on the first sale listed this feature. See the Jalopkin article which makes it clear that it did by showing the Monroney sticker from Tesla's auction to the dealer: https://jalopnik.com/tesla-remotely-removes-autopilot-features-from-customer-1841472617?rev=1580941196331 https://jalopnik.com/tesla-remotely-removes-autopilot-featur...
- URSpider94 7y agoThere is no Monroney sticker for an auctioned car. Monroney stickers only come on new cars, not on used ones.
- 7y ago
- CSSer 7y agoMy mind also went to the PR cost. Why try to go after their customers for their own mistake? The customer didn’t choose the pricing structure, they did. Put it on the P&L, move on and do better.
- justinclift 7y ago> I don't see how the $8,000 (or less, since it's a used vehicle?) that Tesla would get from this would be worth this terrible publicity. Isn't Larry Ellison on the board for Tesla now? Pretty sure the terrible publicity Oracle commonly gets hasn't bothered them in the slightest.