2 ms·
So... a meta point: this is another example of a submitted story that absolutely flies up the rankings, currently sitting right at the top of HN after 20 minute
by ajross 7y ago
So... a meta point: this is another example of a submitted story that absolutely flies up the rankings, currently sitting right at the top of HN after 20 minutes, despite no particular reason to be there.
It's not a rigorous test, there's no data on other browsers or earlier versions, it's a github issue on one particular js/DOM benchmark detailing a likely regression. There aren't any details I can see on what hardware is tested. Even if you wanted to start researching chrome performance, this is a bad place to start.
So why is it up so high after just a few minutes and 54 upvotes?
- _bxg1 7y agoI think the number of comments factors in, and maybe even viewership. It also seems like the rate of upvotes matters; I've seen single-digit posts rise to the front page. For better or worse the algorithm seems to prioritize posts that people are interested in, not necessarily posts that people have indicated to be high-quality.
- keanzu 7y agoThere's a 'overheated discussion detector' https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16020089 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16020089 A good rule of thumb for this effect is when the number of comments on a submission exceeds its score.
- meredydd 7y agoA reliable way for an article do do well on social media is to be fun to argue about, or to be supporting evidence in a broader ongoing argument. In this case, there is a broad ongoing argument about Google and its products [jumping the shark/being evil]. That argument is so much fun that, as I write this, almost every single top-level comment in this thread is a salvo in that argument, only tenuously connected to the OP. This article is just a convenient place to have the argument. (I have a personal learning experience here: The first article of mine that hit the HN front page was a writeup of a PyCon talk entitled "To Make the World Better, Remove Some Javascript from it"[0]. It also shot to the top within minutes, and was [defensibly] flagged off the front page very quickly, because the title alone immediately turned it into a place to argue about JS [not] being evil, rather than discuss the Python-to-Javascript compiler I was talking about. Suffice it to say that subsequent articles have been more modestly titled!) [0] https://anvil.works/blog/pycon-talk https://anvil.works/blog/pycon-talk