4 ms·
The crux of the problem is authenticity. If I buy a Gucci handbag, I want a Gucci handbag. If the army buys an 8.8 grade high tensile bolt, it wants that exac
by specialist 7y ago
The crux of the problem is authenticity.
If I buy a Gucci handbag, I want a Gucci handbag.
If the army buys an 8.8 grade high tensile bolt, it wants that exact bolt.
As a customer and DIYer, I want authentic Apple parts, or equivalent.
Both Apple and us customers have a trust problem. Apple's current solution is to try to lockdown the supply chain. They, and every other manufacturer, needs to do better. Apple has huge challenges with fraud and counterfeits. Whatever.
I fix a lot of my own stuff. Nerd pride (before the fall). Not so long ago, I could get parts from directly Sears. I just rebuilt my washing machine. This time, it was a total pain in the ass.
Trying to end my rant: Just sell Louis Russman the parts he needs. At cost. Figure out how to make it right. So that both Apple and us customers are confident it's all legit.
PS- My first "real" job at age 16 was fixing Apple computers at a local dealership. This is an old problem, totally solvable.
- timw4mail 7y agoBefore Apple really made it a problem, most of their (computer) parts were more generic. You may have had to take out 40 screws, but then you could swap the drive. In that case, "authenticity" is nonsensical. Apple's problem with independent repair seems to be more of a "squeeze all the dollars out" issue rather than anything else.
- specialist 7y agoBoth can be true. Apple is both transitioning to a "rundle" (see my other comment) and combatting fraud. You're ignoring the rampant fraud. Just one example: https://appleinsider.com/articles/18/10/09/rampant-chinese-iphone-repair-fraud-forced-apple-to-develop-countermeasures https://appleinsider.com/articles/18/10/09/rampant-chinese-i... So one consequence is Russman has to buy a $100 battery pack to cannibalize it for a $1 chip which cannot be sourced any other way. To reiterate: Authenticity is a ubiquitous problem. For decades. For everyone. Military, Amazon & eBay, fashion, chemicals, pharmalogics, etc. Everyone. You may disagree with Apple's strategy. But they are doing a far better job than pretty much anyone else, absent government government oversight (eg FDA). To expand: Fraud and counterfeiting is a drag on the economy. Efficient open markets require trust. I'm disappointed that between the right to repair and trade wars (eg IP theft), this very basic root cause isn't acknowledged. If you (we) don't properly understand the disease, the intended cure will surely be worse.