4 ms·
Sure, if the only viable business model for Android is to underhandedly sell people as eyeballs for advertising, perhaps Android should not exist. If Android w
by tsimionescu 7y ago
Sure, if the only viable business model for Android is to underhandedly sell people as eyeballs for advertising, perhaps Android should not exist.
If Android weren't free, perhaps we would have more paid alternatives to Apple. The problem with free and open-source software seems to be that you can't have a vibrant market of alternatives, development tends to acrete around 1 or 2 successful projects, with perhaps some satellites sitting at much, much lower market share.
This wouldn't necessarily be problematic, but it becomes so when those core few popular solutions are controlled and monetized by a single huge corporation.
- rglullis 7y agoKilling the Free OS does not give me any guarantee that the invasive advertising is not going to show up on future "paid alternatives to Apple". As it is now, I'd rather have to be vigilant to what I put on my Android phone than having no Android phone and trust the other big companies they will not take the chance of exploiting ex-Android user base.
- tsimionescu 7y agoOf course. But killing the business model of pretending to give away stuff for free when you're actually making money by selling the 'customer's data does guarantee that this business model will not show up again.
- rglullis 7y agoAndroid is not a "business model". It does not need to make money by itself to be justifiable. All Android needs to do for Google is to help them to commoditize their complements* Killing Android is not going to stop Google from collecting data much like Facebook still collects data from people who install Instagram/FB on their oh-so-pricy iPhones. If what you really want is to ask for regulation to stop data collection from the companies, be my guest. But advocating the destruction of one of the largest software ecosystems which is (mostly still) based on F/OSS is cutting off the noise to spite the face. * https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/
- tsimionescu 7y agoGoogle's business model is to sell consumers to advertisers as efficiently as possible. Android makes money for Google by achieving that (plus a little extra from the app store). If Google were somehow forced to stop collecting data from Android devices, they would have no reason to continue developing Android (and the same will be true of Fuchsia). Apple on the other hand makes its money from sales of its hardware and from their 30% cut of the much more profitable App Store. They are likely also collecting data and probably extracting value from that as well, and they are certainly allowing other companies (such as Google and Facebook) to release their data-collecting apps on their platform; but if data collection was entirely prohibited starting tomorrow, Apple would still be selling and developing iOS. F/OSS is not a good in itself. Technology is technology. A F/OSS data collection program is exactly as bad as a proprietary data collection program - the purpose is much, much more relevant than the development model, in the grand scheme. So sure, I have nothing against Android itself (I prefer it to iOS personally). But if attacking the data collection model had to cause the end of Android, I would accept that in a heartbeat, and I think most privacy advocates would as well.
- rglullis 7y ago> Google's business model is to sell consumers to advertisers as efficiently as possible. The problem of oversimplifying some concepts is that we end up with absurd statements like this accepted as fact. > Android makes money for Google by achieving that. You are confusing tactics with strategy. Android is not a tactic, it is strategy. (Please do read the link I posted before) > F/OSS is not a good in itself Yeah, well, that is just, like, your opinion, man. For plenty of people there is a lot of inherit value associated with Software being Libre. The mere fact that I can take a fork of Android, remove the G-Services part that I don't like and install it on a rootable device, while not being able to do the same with iOS, is an concrete example of that. > A F/OSS data collection program is exactly as bad as a proprietary data collection program. Your issue here is not with Android, rather with the myriad of other Google Services that come in the OS. I am failing to understand why you keep conflating the two. Are you also going to start asking for Google to stop contributing to the Linux kernel because they use it on Android and their servers?
- IMTDb 7y ago> Sure, if the only viable business model for Android is to underhandedly sell people as eyeballs for advertising, perhaps Android should not exist What if I am fully aware that they sell my eyeballs for revenue and I am OK with that because I find the amount of ads to be acceptable compared to the value I get from the product ?
- monadic2 7y agoMoney has worked just fine for millennia. Why do we need google as a middleman all of a sudden?
- tsimionescu 7y agoNot all contracts are legal. For example, you are not allowed to sell your kidney, even if you are fully aware of the implications. Obviously, selling your data is not as harmful to you as selling a kidney. But it is still harmful, and it is also extremely harmful to society when many people do so.