7 ms·
Android (the OS part, the one you want opensourced) is pretty much not making any revenue (which is easy to see on the earnings report). So what you're basical
by izacus 7y ago
Android (the OS part, the one you want opensourced) is pretty much not making any revenue (which is easy to see on the earnings report).
So what you're basically saying is that government should decree to destroy Android as a product and let Apple take over the whole marked with its completely proprietary and DRM locked OS (which is also not earning any money by itself without the rest of Apple corporation to feed it).
- kryptiskt 7y agoA spun off Android Inc would be free to make lucrative deals for browsers, search, media and maps and stuff and would have the Play store too. It would do just fine.
- jdhdjsujwg 7y agoThen why didn't that happen naturally? People calling google a monopoly don't see that the future if innovation is megacorps and small businesses that try to ascend to selling out. This world where a business sticks to one problem domain is just a fantasy, it's the software version of a mom+pop. In the world of grownup companies it's Amazon vs. Apple vs. Google vs Walmart vs. Tencent vs. Facebook and maybe eventually the Europeans will decide they miss having clout as more than consumers on the world stage and then there'll be a European megacorp too.
- tsimionescu 7y agoThat is exactly what people calling Google a monopoly see, and that is what they want to prevent. As a rule, Big corporations do not innovate - they form cartels and sit on their products extracting rent. We have already seen the severe drop in innovation in the mobile space, now that the market is settled.
- Mirioron 7y ago>That is exactly what people calling Google a monopoly see, and that is what they want to prevent. I guess we will soon just use Chinese-made software too then.
- humanrebar 7y agoJust like we're all exclusively eating Chinese chocolate, drinking Chinese beer, driving Chinese assembled cars, and watching Chinese movies?
- to11mtm 7y ago> Just like we're all exclusively eating Chinese chocolate, - Not chocolate, but I was amazed when I saw a bag of dried apples came from China. > drinking Chinese beer, - I'd be more worried about it skunking... > driving Chinese assembled cars, This actually reminds me, I forgot to see how that spat where GM didn't want to have to pay taxes on Chinese assembled cars they sell in the US wound up finishing. > and watching Chinese movies? Someone made a rather convincing argument that the influence of Chinese financiers in the film industry has contributed to shifts in the movies we get. Now, there are those who may say 'But were any of those Megacorps?' The Apples were Dole, the cars were GM, and the movies (in question in the argument made) were Disney. My counterpoint to that is that one has to consider that China in this case is the megacorp, due to the level of involvement/oversight they have over the companies that operate in their country.
- zozbot234 7y agoThe point is that anyone can do this already. Heck, Amazon does it w/ FireOS. /e/ is the same deal.
- izacus 7y agoCan you show one example where that has worked? This model can already be used right now - and it hasn't been successful at all. Especially when there are other players left in the market that subsidise their development.
- antupis 7y agoFirefox is doing pretty well and it has 5% market share.
- Mirioron 7y agoThey've been bleeding marketshare for a long time. They're essentially the only realistic alternative to Chromium yet their marketshare is eroding. I'm not sure that's a good example of a successful spin off like that.
- estebarb 7y agoFirefox earnings come most from search engine royalties for being featured... Google keeps it alive. Basically Google is developing Chrome and funding its major competitor.
- acd10j 7y agoAndroid is already open sourced, It is Google play, Google Play services, and Pre-installed Google Apps that are proprietary.
- zozbot234 7y agoYup. Used to be called "Google Experience", even. I don't see how this proprietary part of "Android" or whatever can exist outside Google as a business. And AOSP sans Google Experience is a thing already, as well.
- izacus 7y agoIt is, and it's being actively developed by Google at a rather big expense. Just like pretty much every other major opensource project - even Linux itself is majorly developed by a few corporations.
- 0zymandiass 7y agoI'm sure it's a large expense. However, they make more money from the data and market share they get from it. Why else would they keep moving things out of AOSP and into their proprietary frameworks? Same for Linux itself - however in that case, there isn't incentive to make it proprietary, because the companies are either making money from hardware sales or from support contracts.
- m4rtink 7y agoActually, it's now a few but rathet a pretty big bunch of very different corporations & many of them direct competitors. And thanks to the kernel project & its license, they can still work together towards the common good.
- StreamBright 7y agoWhat market are we talking about? Android is a free software. Google subsidized OS development for Android phone vendors to be able to collect more data and support its ad business better. Is this not the case?
- izacus 7y agoYes, this is exactly the case. Android is Google's opensourced software that's being continously supported and developed by Google. And that also includes Google making deals with partners to install said operating system on their devices, making sure it's compatible across the ecosystem and providing long-term support. If you order Google to abandon the project, you're effectively ordering to stop them from investing into the operating system while allowing their main competitor to keep subsidizing development of their iOS operating system.
- humanrebar 7y agoYeah, it only makes sense if we also require hardware vendors to support installations of other OSs. Which maybe we should do too, though it gets to be a more complicated proposal at that point.
- StreamBright 7y agoI agree with the first part disagree with the second part. You cannot sell a phone without an operating system. One of Apple's most lucrative business is selling iPhones. "allowing their main competitor to keep subsidizing development of their iOS operating system." I do not think this is true. Apple simple spend money to develop iOS so it can sell iPhone. You could not sell cars without engines and you cannot sell mobile devices without operating system. The entire ad money subsidising X phenomenon exists because Google does it, very successfully. I absolutely dislike the concept of surveillance capitalism and I do not want to participate in this. Mobile phone vendors should develop their own OS and price their products accordingly instead of forcing me to consider only iPhone/iOS if I do not want to install some hackware or adware as the OS of my device. I want to pay for the goods I use and it is not ok to give something for "free" when free means that my entire digital life is sold for the higher bidder.
- melling 7y agoApple is a premium brand. They are never taking over the whole market.
- wyattpeak 7y agoApple sold around 40% of all smartphones in the US last year.[1] That's pretty close to Google's 46% of adtech that is the motivating statistic of the article. [1] https://www.counterpointresearch.com/us-market-smartphone-share/ https://www.counterpointresearch.com/us-market-smartphone-sh...
- melling 7y ago4 out of 10 phones in the US. Globally, they’re 2 out of 10? Microsoft still is around 88% desktop market share. Now that’s a 25 year old monopoly.
- saalweachter 7y agoIf this is US anti-trust we're talking about, global statistics don't matter.
- protanopia 7y agoWorldwide, Apple has around a 12% marketshare for smartphones. https://www.idc.com/promo/smartphone-market-share/vendor https://www.idc.com/promo/smartphone-market-share/vendor
- tsimionescu 7y agoSure, if the only viable business model for Android is to underhandedly sell people as eyeballs for advertising, perhaps Android should not exist. If Android weren't free, perhaps we would have more paid alternatives to Apple. The problem with free and open-source software seems to be that you can't have a vibrant market of alternatives, development tends to acrete around 1 or 2 successful projects, with perhaps some satellites sitting at much, much lower market share. This wouldn't necessarily be problematic, but it becomes so when those core few popular solutions are controlled and monetized by a single huge corporation.
- rglullis 7y agoKilling the Free OS does not give me any guarantee that the invasive advertising is not going to show up on future "paid alternatives to Apple". As it is now, I'd rather have to be vigilant to what I put on my Android phone than having no Android phone and trust the other big companies they will not take the chance of exploiting ex-Android user base.
- tsimionescu 7y agoOf course. But killing the business model of pretending to give away stuff for free when you're actually making money by selling the 'customer's data does guarantee that this business model will not show up again.
- rglullis 7y agoAndroid is not a "business model". It does not need to make money by itself to be justifiable. All Android needs to do for Google is to help them to commoditize their complements* Killing Android is not going to stop Google from collecting data much like Facebook still collects data from people who install Instagram/FB on their oh-so-pricy iPhones. If what you really want is to ask for regulation to stop data collection from the companies, be my guest. But advocating the destruction of one of the largest software ecosystems which is (mostly still) based on F/OSS is cutting off the noise to spite the face. * https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/
- gumby 7y agoThe purpose of Android is to provide some counterweight so that google doesn’t have to pay so much to Apple to be the dominant mobile search engine. It is an economic losss on its own terms but saves Google much more than it costs. They would be foolish to divest it as it is probably not viable as a standalone entity (for reasons others have mentioned)
- sjg007 7y agoI don’t think this is true.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoTwo words: Play Store. Android is profitable.
- webmobdev 7y ago> Android (the OS part, the one you want opensourced) is pretty much not making any revenue (which is easy to see on the earnings report). All licensed Android phones are also forced to bundle Google apps like Youtube, Chrome, Play Store, Google search, Drive etc. And all these products make Google a LOT of money. Not to mention the amount of personal data it helps Google collect. Google didn't buy and develop Android out of kindness for its customers.