6 ms·
Sure, it's immoral to abandon your loyal American workers in search of cheap labor overseas. I know a lot of people who talk like this. However when it comes t
by gaius 16y ago
Sure, it's immoral to abandon your loyal American workers in search of cheap labor overseas.
I know a lot of people who talk like this. However when it comes to spend their own money, they always go for whatever's cheapest, whether it's clothes, electronics, whatever. You can literally see these people ranting about worker's rights while wearing Primark and talking on a Huawei OEM'd handset.
Me, I'm a capitalist, and proud of it, but y'know, I'm the one willing to spend a little extra for a UK PLC product. Bullshit talks, money walks.
- jmm 16y agoKind of unfortunate that this is the top comment here since the article has nothing to do with the immorality of outsourcing. I took his mention to be a throwaway nod of the head to the typical discussion of outsourcing. Then he moved on.
- gaius 16y agoNo, the agenda of the author is clear. A few paragraphs below: a mere assembly plant, bolting together modules designed and produced elsewhere as though from kits
- jmm 16y agoThat might be a sad state of affairs but I didn't see the author making it out to be the result of an immoral decision. Just a bad decision.
- jhghjmhnbgv 16y agoThere are suggestions that part of the motivation was to reduce the power of the heavily unionized workers in Seattle and allow the company to transfer to a cheaper assembly plant in the south - just as car makers had done. If you are only doing final assembly you can move the plant every 10years or so to get the best deal from local government. It's difficult to do that if you need an army of people with a lifetime of skills.
- borism 16y agofull sentence doesn't make this agenda so clear: Boeing's goal, it seems, was to convert its storied aircraft factory near Seattle to a mere assembly plant, bolting together modules designed and produced elsewhere as though from kits. of course it is still designed in Seattle, and many of those parts and outsource partners are still in the USA, only 30% is from abroad according to the article.
- nitrogen 16y agoContrast the positive adjective "storied," applied to the term "aircraft factory," against the negative adjective "mere," applied to the term "assembly plant." Reading only that sentence, it's quite clear which the author prefers.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jhghjmhnbgv 16y agoIt wasn't the foreign suppliers that were the problem - Mitsubishi delivered the wings on time. It's was the excessive outsourcing to layers and layers of subcontractors without enough oversight. So a one mall plating shop in Albuquerque goes out of business and a critical path component is missing. This is fairly common in defense, highly specialized components are subbed out to small shops - there are lots around LA - the problem here was that there was so many layers of sub-sub-sub contractors all being bidded out to the cheapest supplier nobody had any idea who was making what. That works for Walmart - it doesn't work for Boeing. How they thought they were going to ensure40years supply of spare parts is anybodies guess
- quanticle 16y agoJust to elaborate on your point, the outsourcing model works for Walmart because Walmart is selling numerous separate products, rather than an integrated whole. It seems that Boeing forgot that lesson and started thinking of their airplane as a "collection of parts flying in close formation".
- jhghjmhnbgv 16y agoAlso very few of Walmart's products are critical path - if they run out of lemon scented cleanup squares the store still opens (gratuitous hitch hikers reference)
- ChuckMcM 16y agoHow does it work for EADS ? (Airbus manufacturer)
- jhghjmhnbgv 16y agoThere are very much fewer sub-contractors. Major system components are built in different plants in different countries but all by a handful of airbus subsidiaries or major aerospace corps. So the supply chain is much shorter and shallower There were still screwups, a different version of the CAD package meant changes didn't propagate and the Airbus 380 wiring looms were all made the wrong length. There were early warnings of Boeing's problem. The prototype had to be built with non-aerospace rivets which had to all be removed and the plane rebuilt for it's first flight. Aerospace grade rivets were in short supply and Boeing was just looking for the cheapest supplier who didn't deliver. Japanese companies taught us about the value of close working relationships with suppliers 20years ago, the car makers have learned it but Boeing didn't - they acted more like a Walmart buyer and it cost them.
- hyperbovine 16y agoAssuming the foreign workers are not being exploited or abused, I don't understand why it is any more or less moral to channel your commerce to them as opposed to people in your own country.
- lotusleaf1987 16y agoWell, when you spend your money in a local economy the money tends to circulate back around. Say I shop from a farmer's market, I support people living in my community who can then spend that money on other local goods/services, and eventually some of that money may make it's way back to myself. If I shop at Wal-Mart, the money leaves my local economy forever and basically just goes to shareholders and overseas manufactures. I also think local merchants are more likely to sell goods/services that are better for their local economy than a big box retailer that is completely disconnected from the local economy.
- pavel_lishin 16y agoSo the reason it's moral is because you might get the money back? Isn't that just self-interest?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThis claim is ridiculous. Your mental model of the economy involves tracking the movement of a particular dollar bill and ignoring the movement of dollar bills which start at distant locations. This is a fallacy. If you shop at Walmart, that particular dollar bill is put on a truck and sent to Walmart Secret World Headquarters hundreds of miles away, and it eventually makes it's way to producers a world away from you. On the other hand, Walmart (and other businesses located hundreds of miles away) will buy goods from your locality, ship them to other distant locals, and send you a different dollar bill in return. The fundamental issue is whether gains due to comparative advantage > shipping/logistics costs. As a result of shipping/logistics costs dropping rapidly (walmart has been a pioneer here), the non-local goods have won out. (Granted, none of this has anything to do with the morality of giving a job to a guy named Jose instead of a guy named Joe.)
- retube 16y agoCan't upvote enough. People have no problem that they can buy a kettle for £5 that was made in China, but take issue withe the fact that manufacturing jobs are going to... China.
- dragons 16y ago>> People have no problem that they can buy a kettle for £5 that was made in China, but take issue withe the fact that manufacturing jobs are going to... China. Well, some people have a problem with that. Some people try to buy fair trade goods, and don't mind paying more for locally made items. But it's getting harder and harder to find an item that's not made in China. A few years ago I tried to find a blood pressure monitor that was made anywhere but China. No luck. The only choice I had was not to buy one at all, and that wouldn't work for me. I've experienced this problem time and again.
- retube 16y ago> Some people try to buy fair trade goods, and don't mind paying more for locally made items Some, yes. I'll wager it's a minority though.