29 ms·
> Implies that there is intrinsically some computer system that continually parses the commanded stick deflection and applies an overlay. That's not how the 73
by pdonis 7y ago
> Implies that there is intrinsically some computer system that continually parses the commanded stick deflection and applies an overlay.
That's not how the 737 works. The 737 is not a fly by wire aircraft. The pilots control the rudder, ailerons, and elevators electrohydraulically; there is no computer filtering. The electric stability trim system, which is what MCAS feeds its input into, controls the trim tabs on the elevators. This does not change anything about the pilots' inputs to the elevators, but it does change the aerodynamics of the elevators in a way that can limit the pilots' ability to control pitch.
> this plane is more or less stable except that under some conditions it will make the pilot soil their pants at higher AoA, which is where the promises of MCAS come in. Big deal.
If the 737 MAX had been a new aircraft type, it would not have been a problem. There might still have been some adjustment needed to meet FAA certification requirements for stick force (basically, the stick force is supposed to increase with increasing angle of attack, so the pilot has to pull harder to keep the nose going up as you get closer to a stall). But there would not have been a need to cobble together anything like MCAS.
The problem was that Boeing wanted the 737 MAX to be certified under the existing 737 type certificate (because otherwise the potential customers wouldn't want it, since they didn't want to have to re-train and re-certify all their pilots), which meant that the stick force as a function of angle of attack had to be the same as for previous 737s. But the new engines on the 737 MAX made the plane aerodynamically different, so the "natural" stick force was different. MCAS was a software kludge to try to change the stick force.
- garbage_937648 7y agoGood point
- kayfox 7y ago>If the 737 MAX had been a new aircraft type, it would not have been a problem. If the aircraft was a new type this still would have been an issue that would have to be corrected, see FARS 25.173.
- pdonis 7y agoYes, which is why I said: "There might still have been some adjustment needed to meet FAA certification requirements for stick force"