2 ms·
> So going back to the old system would either lead to very cursory and potentially incompetent reviews... Yeah, this is side I'd pick. I'd rather have many m
by BurningFrog 7y ago
> So going back to the old system would either lead to very cursory and potentially incompetent reviews...
Yeah, this is side I'd pick.
I'd rather have many mediocre submissions published fast than the current system. Let the "real" review happens after after the results are public.
I see how reasonable people can pick the other side.
- petschge 7y agoIn many many subject areas we already have that through the use of preprint servers such as Arxiv. No need to get rid of the upsides of peer review just to get that.
- BurningFrog 7y agoThen maybe things are pretty reasonable. At least in those fields. I feel at a disadvantage in this discussion because I don't really now what I'm talking about :)