6 ms·
The hiring process is a black box for a reason. The HR department's role is to protect the company first, not the employees, and certainly not prospective emplo
by rchaud 7y ago
The hiring process is a black box for a reason. The HR department's role is to protect the company first, not the employees, and certainly not prospective employees. If feedback can be interpreted as being discriminatory, or reflective of bad company culture in general, well, word gets around.
For much of the time, the reason people don't get the job is that there was someone marginally more qualified/attractive/likeable, or some combination of the three; the classic "there were many qualified candidates and we could only choose one" line in the rejection email.
That doesn't help the interviewee beyond telling them that it's a numbers game, but that's the truth.
- oceanghost 7y agoThis. I have done hundreds of interviews, and I used to do a very easy, basic comp sci test. The last question I would ask was, "Tell me about a book, cd or movie that you've read/listened to/watched that was interesting or excited you." The point was to see if the person was engaging with the universe, not to judge their taste or anything else. You'd be surprised how many people get tripped up by this. The worst answer I ever got was a guy who said the last album he bought was "Free Bird" (which is not an album), and was 40 years old at the time of that utterance. This person could honestly not think of one thing that excited him since then. He also ranted about Object Oriented Programming like it was a brand new thing. The best answer I ever got, was a gentleman who was not the strongest candidate but was clearly intelligent. His answer was, "I know this is not a recent author, but I love Bukowski." And he spoke at length about his novels and poetry, and even was aware that our office was only a few blocks from where one of the pivotal scenes in one of his novels was set, and that after the interview he had actually scheduled some time away from his job to go there. perfect answer In my report to HR, I mentioned that he probably needed to study a little but was quite intelligent, but had fantastic enthusiasm for literature and that he was very engaging. Of course, HR put an immediate stop to the thing with the reasoning that someone could say that their favorite book was the bible, and that could form the basis for a religious discrimination case. After that, I declined to do interviews anymore.
- rchaud 7y agoThis scenario of an interviewee answering with the name of a religious text is an interesting point; transparency in interviewing is a two-way street. In a way, I can understand why people get tripped up on the "casual/lifestyle" question. Interviewees may not think of it as a casual question, but rather another question to weed out the desirables from the undesirables. So people may censor themselves or their honest beliefs because they want the job. Which is a position I totally understand.
- justforyou 7y agoSo now that person likely thinks that the reason they did not get hired was because of talking about Bukowski. Also, why did you even mention the enthusiasm for literature bit to HR?
- orangecat 7y agoThe point was to see if the person was engaging with the universe, not to judge their taste or anything else. You'd be surprised how many people get tripped up by this. Not surprised at all. You know your motivation; they don't. It probably causes lots of candidates to mildly panic as they try to decide what they can say that won't make them come across as too weird/boring/old/etc.
- oceanghost 7y agoThat's fair. Is it, inequitable of me, to expect someone to describe something that excites them?
- reificator 7y ago> Tell me about a book, cd or movie that you've read/listened to/watched that was interesting or excited you. [...] You'd be surprised how many people get tripped up by this. Yeah, because they'd rather be shown to freeze up rather than have the conversation go like this: Them: I actually really liked the album Mouth Moods. It's an album full of remixed songs and mash-ups, kind of like what Weird Al does. You: Oh? I've never heard of that. Tell me about your favorite song on that album. Them: Oh... uh.... it's a song called Bustin. You: Bustin? Them: Yeah it's... well, it's the song from Ghostbusters but chopped up and remixed. You: So it's about busting ghosts? Them: Uh... well... no. It's about how bustin... makes me feel good. You: I'm sorry? What are you busting that makes you feel good? Them: Never mind, forget I said anything.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoBingo. After the interview is done and the answer is a solid NO, as a company we have NO BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP with you. Any iota of effort we put towards you is essentially wasted effort, even if very minor. What changes that discussion further is that there is a small, but still quite real, possibility of lawsuit, social media rant (as another comment mentioned), or even a disgruntled applicant shooting up the place. (I believe Pres. William McKinley was shot by a disgruntled would-be bureaucrat who didn't get a job...) A perfunctory if generic rejection is a safer choice. Short-list candidates who made it to a 3rd interview, or folks who we reached out and headhunted (but didn't choose) may be a different story, but those are rare edge cases.
- rockostrich 7y ago> as a company we have NO BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP with you I think this could be phrased as "we have the choice to have no business relationship with you." But it's not a good idea to straight up cut off candidates. We've had plenty of cases where we just didn't think we had the capacity to help a candidate get up to speed and thought if they worked somewhere else that could provide that to them then we could hire them 6 months to a year down the line. It's not the standard, but it's happened before.
- kryptiskt 7y agoIn a vacuum that might be true, but software engineers know other software engineers, and there are plenty of forums for discussing hiring experiences, including HN. If a company systematically treats people they don't intend to go further with like crap, their reputation with other candidates will suffer. You'd like failed candidates to not talk shit about your company when their friend considers applying.
- wvenable 7y agoNot giving feedback though is not "treating them like crap" in fact the opposite is far more likely to be true (as interpreted by the non-hired candidate). You literally can't go wrong doing nothing.
- BurningFrog 7y ago> well, word gets around. Yeah, but that also true if you give good constructive feedback with your rejections. The "word" doesn't have to be bad, you know :)
- Kalium 7y agoYou're right, but it's also not difficult for genuine, high-quality feedback to be taken poorly. You can tell someone that they're not as good at data structures or database design or scalable systems or whatever core job skill you needed them to be. That can be highly useful, actionable feedback. It can also readily feed into a very different framing. It's rarely difficult for a candidate to decide that whatever core reason is a fig leaf and something more ego-preserving is the real reason. I think we've all had coworkers who didn't take feedback well. I've definitely known people to whom all feedback is personal attacks. It's also, unfortunately, well-known and well-documented that people share negative thoughts more often and more readily than positive thoughts. So, you're absolutely right. The good word can get around! There may be more risk to trying than is obvious, though.
- Apocryphon 7y agoWhy not formalize the process and include non-disparagement clauses that applicants must sign to receive feedback? Then risk of retaliation is reduced.
- Kalium 7y agoThere are definitely options, but it's worth bearing in mind that contracts are for when for things go wrong. Are you willing to sue someone for saying something bad after getting post-interview feedback? Seems unlikely to help with bad PR, but I'm not an expert. Legal might not be the right tools for this. Some industries (consulting, as mentioned by others) seem to have standardized ways to give feedback.
- Apocryphon 7y agoIt would at least deter most people from acting on anger over feedback. Those who aren't dissuaded by the contract would have acted in anger even if they didn't receive feedback.
- pm24601 7y ago> If feedback can be interpreted as being discriminatory, or reflective of bad company culture in general, well, word gets around. If the feedback can be interpreted in such a way .... then the rejection is discriminatory. Pure and simple. "Culture fit" reasons are code for bias. "Culture": * national origin * age * religion * gender * sexual orientation.... ... all protected classes, yet covered with the "culture fit" excuse to protect a company from being accused (correctly) of discrimination.
- rchaud 7y agoI agree. Looking back at my comment, I did phrase it in a way that made it sound like "the company has no choice but to do this"; that wasn't my intention. Discrimination on the basis of the school you attended, your nationality/race/ethnicity, even what you choose to do in your free time, is likely to be behind more than a few rejections. "Culture fit" is a polite fig leaf to hide that.
- pm24601 7y agoProps for your recognition