8 ms·
It's particularly interesting to look at the mobility statistics of asian americans (many of whom are also immigrants) as a category: http://www.equality-of-opp
by rayiner 7y ago
It's particularly interesting to look at the mobility statistics of asian americans (many of whom are also immigrants) as a category: http://www.equality-of-opportunity.org/assets/documents/race_paper.pdf http://www.equality-of-opportunity.org/assets/documents/race....
If you look at table 1 on page 56, you can see that for white americans, the probability of a child ending up in the top quantile of income where a parent is in the bottom quantile of income is 11% (about half the probability one would except of there was zero correlation between child and parent incomes). For Asian Americans its almost 27%. A white child born in the bottom quantile is about 2.5 times more likely to stay in the bottom quantile (28%) than to rise to the top quantile (12%). An asian child born in the bottom quantile is about 1.5 times more likely to rise to the top quantile (27%) than to stay in the bottom quantile (12%).
- screye 7y agoI think this might have to do with the type of Asian-Americans that immigrate to the US. (esp. this generation) [Strike out] Asians mostly use high-skilled visas / education based visas as a door to enter the nation. Almost by definition, this beings in the subset of Asians who grew up in a culture of education and hard work. [\Strike out] I think, the cultural boon/curse of living vicariously through your child also leads to parents pushing their child towards "lucrative" / "respected" careers. There might also be a snow-ball effect, where Asians aspire to pursue careers where Asians have traditionally succeeded. That would be professions in STEM fields, which have high median wages. [Strike out]The real title should be -> "Children of Asian immigrants who were top percentiles in their own countries, perform at a similarly high level"[\Strike out] edit: didn't see the lower quartile number. Renders my argument invalid.
- CaoCao 7y agoThat's just immediately falsified by the fact that he's talking about children of Asian immigrants in the bottom quartile. The high-skilled visa workers are not in the bottom quartile.
- wyxuan 7y ago+1 to this. In order to even get an application for h1b there is even a requirement for employers that they are paid above a certain amount
- whenanother 7y agohttps://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=google&job=&city=&year=2019 https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=google&job=&city=&year=201... assuming that google pays the highest h1b salaries, if you sort the jobs by lowest to highest earnings. you see that many are barely earning a little more than 100k in the most expensive cities in the world. if an apartment cost 2k a month and half your income goes to taxes. you are left with 25k to pay for food and a car and medical coverage. why would they do this?????!!!!! to get the word google on their resume. another issue is that people here are treating income as a measure of wealth. that's hilariously naive considering how so many ceo's today don't even take a salary. immigrants do not come here and severe all ties to their families in their home countries. you can not compare immigrants that are a specific sub group of people to a non-immigrant population which typically represents a wide range of demographics. it's the same argument made against those stats regarding how low females are paid. they never compare men and women in the same field of work. not only are you not comparing people in the same field of work, you are not comparing groups of people in the same class. immigrants are twice as likely to have a college education vs the non-immigrants. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Education_of_immigrants_in_the_United_States#Overview https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Education_of_immigrants_in_the... "Parents’ educational level when the child was 8 years old significantly predicted educational and occupational success for the child 40 years later." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2853053/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2853053/ so this is a bs study that compares very different groups of of people to come up with a very misleading point.
- rayiner 7y ago> Asians mostly use high-skilled visas / education based visas as a door to enter the nation. The minimum salary for an H1-B Visa is $60,000, which would put someone at the 68-th percentile of individual income (or the fourth quantile). The statistics I am referring to are for asians whose parents had incomes in the lowest quantile (below about $19,000 today) between age 11-22. Now, that could capture a lot of immigrants who have skills or education back home, but are underemployed once here. (E.g. college degree back home, but working in food service here.) But it excludes immigrants who were able to use their degrees or skills to provide financial advantages to their kids in the U.S.
- BurningFrog 7y ago> Asians mostly use high-skilled visas / education based visas as a door to enter the nation I'd like to see some numbers on that. Lot's of Asians have come as refugees over the years, and also as family connections. Yeah, the ones I meet at my Silicon Valley job are highly educated and often on that kind of visa, but that's of course a big selection bias trap...
- yibg 7y agoI’m what’s considered 1.5 generation immigrant. My parents are first gen immigrants and while I wasn’t born in the west, I spent a considerable portion of my childhood here. My parents friends and their children are all in similar situation with children arriving at different ages. Anecdotally, all of the parents of this batch came poor, most of us were below poverty level because all of the parents came as older students (30s and some times 40s) doing their masters or PhD. None of their previous degrees or work experience counted so everyone started from scratch. Add to that the language and cultural barriers and it took everyone a while to get back on their feet. The children though had no barrier other than being in poor families. Education and hard work were very much valued. The family situation were stable and there was a lot of time investment from the parents in helping with homework etc. There was also a push towards professions fields. My parents half jokingly said to me I can pick any field of study as long as it’s medicine, law or engineering (ended up in engineering). So end result, all the children are doing well professionally and financially. Definitely in the top quartile, but not super wealthy. From my own and my parents social circles this seems to be a very common pattern.
- TimPC 7y agoThere might be some hard to account for factors. Many immigrants end up in worse jobs than they had in their home countries. Some doctors end up driving cabs for instance. If your parent is a doctor with the income of a cab driver I'd expect you to have more upward mobility than if your parent is a cab driver with the income of a cab driver.
- icsllaf 7y agoAlso, there's a factor of where the people live. Someone who is a cab driver in Los Angeles might be making the same money as someone who is a mechanic in Nebraska. But the possibility of upwards mobility and higher education in Los Angeles is much higher than that of rural areas. Most immigrants move to large metropolitan areas than the countryside.
- sjg007 7y agoWe know that some metro regions have greater upward economic mobility for sure. I think the Bay area has the highest mobility.
- glofish 7y agoWhile anecdata can be useful in general, in this particular case I have a hard time believing that the case you describe: working in a worse job than your home country, is informative or representative. There is a wisdom of crowds at work, especially when it comes to huge decisions such as immigration - no country offering worse prospects is ever the target of large scale immigration.
- tmcb 7y agoThat specific case may seem too radical, but there is some logic in moving to a different country with less promising job prospects if, say, your home country is ravaged by war or by systemic violence. Also, citizens of countries with fickle economies and high inflation could benefit from having an income in a more stable currency, especially if they are breadwinners for their extended family, in which case they send back money they earn abroad.
- bsanr2 7y agoSomething that many HNers will probably be embarrased to admit being surprised by is how higher education attainment rates for immigrants don't exclude African immigrants. In fact, black immigrants from Africa and the West Indies have among the highest degree attainment rate of any group. This belies the lower college-and-advanced-degree attainment rate for black Americans as a whole. All of this seems to suggest that there is something about the American education system - and perhaps our overal culture - that is failing our children, and our black children in particular. This also makes me wonder if there's data about the mobility of native vs immigrant blacks. If it's similar, it would align with other data that show that degree attainment only serves to partially overcome the barriers to upward mobility placed in the way of black workers. I'm of the opinion that many of the impediments that punish or withhold assistance from minorities often bleed over into mainstream American life. The specific drum I'll keep beating is that if, perhaps, the infrastructure to battle the crack/cocaine epidemic as a public health issue had been allowed to be built to a robust state, the opioid epidemic would not have become so dire. The apathy towards these issues, even as they encroach upon "mainstream" middle class life, must be part of the mechanics of the calcification of class in America.
- codingslave 7y agoMost of the reason for immigrant children doing so well is the fact that immigrants are often more driven, ambitious, and at the top of their peer group. So the USA gets a biased sample of immigrants from countries like Nigeria. None of this is happening in a vacuum, and interpreting it as such is misguided propaganda.
- glofish 7y agoCorrect. A self-selecting sample if there ever was one. Immigrating and deciding to live in another country takes a lot determination. If you take ambitious and motivated black parents in America I am quite sure their children far outcompete the averages.
- plopz 7y agoHow long in the family history does it take to lose that ambition/motivation? The colonists back in the day had to have had those same qualities. Maybe even more so with all the added risk and dangers of the time.
- pen2l 7y agoI would bet that these poor Asian Americans are highly educated. I know that my dad, after arriving here in 90s and having to feed 6 mouths, worked odd jobs for the first 10 years despite having gotten a masters in chemical engineering in Asia, never topped more than 40k. But the five of us now each make 6-figures. I know many stories like this. But I also know a couple folks who were poor, but not educated -- their kids are not doing well financially.
- Reedx 7y agoAsians also have the highest median income in the U.S.[1] Culture seems to play a significant role in their success. Notably they tend to focus on education and prioritize it over other things[2]. 1. https://www.statista.com/statistics/233324/median-household-income-in-the-united-states-by-race-or-ethnic-group/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/233324/median-household-... 2. https://www.wsj.com/articles/culture-explains-asians-educational-success-11553640350 https://www.wsj.com/articles/culture-explains-asians-educati...
- brightball 7y agoI wonder how much of this comes from insulation from cultural trends that seem to try to push away every cultural norm in favor of something else. I’d imagine immigrant families that haven’t fully assimilated into all that are less influenced.
- JabavuAdams 7y agoClearly white kids need more of the right kind of child abuse! Beating the snot out of your white kid because you're a drunk loser? No. Emotional abuse directed at producing a doctor/lawyer/engineer -- yessss! BrownDadLove (tm).