2 ms·
I don’t publish or review too much, but I do a little. One of the recently frustrating events to me is that I got comments back from a reviewer that made an inc
by prepend 7y ago
I don’t publish or review too much, but I do a little. One of the recently frustrating events to me is that I got comments back from a reviewer that made an incorrect factual statement along the lines of “it’s against government policy to share x type of data.” And then discounted large parts of the conclusion as impossible or inappropriate. That was the only substantive comment from the reviewer.
We responded back to the editors refuting it and showing the relevant policies and regulations showing how data sharing for x was allowed.
The next message back was from editors declining. So further feedback.
I would have really liked to learn more about why the reviewer thought what they thought and why what seemed like clear evidence to my co-authors and I wasn’t to the peer reviewer and editors.
I’ll never know and I don’t spend many cycles contemplating it, but this new trial in Nature would help me understand the criticism better.