4 ms·
I'm saying the article is a Marxist screed, not the book the article is talking about. Nobody who talks about the "violence" of "enclosure" is anything other th
by rayiner 7y ago
I'm saying the article is a Marxist screed, not the book the article is talking about. Nobody who talks about the "violence" of "enclosure" is anything other than a Marxist. It’s expressly Marxist terminology. And I’m flagging that because if you’re not a Marxist, it’s hard to even follow the reasoning of the article.
- jessaustin 7y agoSure, and nobody who talks about "natural monopolies" is anyone other than a telecom lawyer. The fact that we have different working vocabularies doesn't mean we can't communicate. I'm not a Marxist, and I'm reading TFA with interest. A careful reconsideration of how the Law adjudicates questions of property and how it changes hands might lead to a complete Bolshevik confiscation of all the McMansions. That's unlikely, however. It could be that nothing comes of this line of thought. What I would hope, instead, would be for small improvements to be made, so that some of the vast advantages enjoyed by well-lawyered capitalists might be eliminated in favor of a more just and fair system for everyone.
- int_19h 7y agoAre you claiming that "enclosure" is a Marxist term, or that the notion that the historical process of enclosure involved a significant amount of violence is a Marxist notion?
- machawinka 7y agoEverytime I see an elemental critic of the these legalisms and its schemes, there is always someone trying to play the marxist card. Someone who hasn't read a single line of Marx's books. This is not marxist. And if it were marxist then: so what?