6 ms·
It's a phone number, not your bank account. It's public information. Do you want to sue the phone telcos for publishing the phone book?
by TylerE 7y ago
It's a phone number, not your bank account.
It's public information.
Do you want to sue the phone telcos for publishing the phone book?
- XMPPwocky 7y agoWhat's your phone number? I might call you and check- and check for VOIP numbers, too, so no fakes.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- techsupporter 7y ago> check for VOIP numbers, too, so no fakes Ah yes, continuing the fiction that anyone who uses a VoIP service must be a fraudster with a faked phone number. Just another in the long list of if you are not using Google or Microsoft e-mail and AT&T or Verizon or T-Mobile or Sprint postpaid mobile phone service, you're obviously up to no good and deserve whatever "anti-fraud" you get.
- Jestar342 7y ago> It's public information. No, it isn't.
- stuff4ben 7y agoyou have one of those private, encrypted phone numbers that prevents unauthorized usage? Get over yourself, it's public information.
- eternalny1 7y ago> you have one of those private, encrypted phone numbers that prevents unauthorized usage? Get over yourself, it's public information. Is it? If I find out your phone number, "stuff4ben", then I know who "stuff4ben" really is. People have been missing this for a LONG time now. Phone numbers are the unique identifier, especially with portability. You can use 50 different usernames across 50 different sites but with that phone number, I know they are all you. Which I can then link up to the 1,000 other sites you use those 50 usernames on without providing your phone number, and it's still likely you. The NSA's database must be very interesting out at the Utah Data Center. This is how it all works, because you can mask your IP address using Tor but you can't mask any of that unless you've taken very careful steps along the entire history of your internet usage, from the start.
- BoorishBears 7y agoEh, it pretty much is. At least in the US I have a pretty unique name, you can search my first name + "voter registration" and get my address, phone number, and birthdate Even if my name was common, it'd still be out there
- thiagomgd 7y agoBut on twitter you don't need to give anyone your real name. THAT'S the thing. There should be no way to tie your twitter account to you, unless you specifically allow them to share your information.
- ryanlol 7y agoIsn’t that really for twitter to decide? Besides, weren’t the people who had opted out from the “Let people who have your phone number find you on Twitter” unaffected by this?
- BoorishBears 7y agoSure, that's what the other replies above the comment I replied to are saying, but this is specific to phone numbers A lot of people are not aware of the fact this information is all public
- mstolpm 7y agoNo, its only public if you choose to disclose it. Phone numbers are PII (personal identifying information) in regards to the GDPR.
- tripa 7y agoSorry for the slight pedantry, but PII is some American thing. GDPR deals with "personal data". It's playing on words until you find out the PII definition isn't the one that's used to settle GDPR claims.
- RL_Quine 7y agoWhat’s your phone number? If it’s public you don’t mind sharing it. My address book is filled with people who would be very sad if that were made public.
- ckastner 7y agoIt's not public information, and it's considered identity-tied enough to be used in many forms of two-factor identification.
- moron4hire 7y agoIt is public information, and that's why it's ludicrous that it's used for two-factor authentication. Two-factor authentication is a dumb solution to a real problem. The problem should be properly solved, rather than hacked around with stupid solutions like "sending notifications to accounts that can easily be spoofed by willful actors".
- SAI_Peregrinus 7y ago> Two-factor authentication is a dumb solution to a real problem. The problem should be properly solved, rather than hacked around with stupid solutions like "sending notifications to accounts that can easily be spoofed by willful actors". SMS Two-factor authentication is a dumb solution. Actual two-factor authentication like FIDO U2F tokens is a better solution. Even TOTP is better than SMS auth.
- ghaff 7y agoPrivate vs. public isn't a fine-grained enough distinction. It's not private in the sense that most people give it out to lots of people so that they can be contacted. (Of course, in the case of landlines, they're mostly listed in a public directory somewhere but I assume we're talking mobile here.) BTW, you bank account number is the same way if you write checks. So they're not private in the way that some data (like health information) that you're only going to share very selectively is private. But it's mostly not public in the sense that you'll likely put it online unless maybe it's a business phone.
- jchw 7y agoYour identity is not public information on Twitter. Posting someone’s phone number and Twitter handle, if they did not explicitly share it anywhere, would be doxing, against almost any site ToS, and potentially even illegal.
- glofish 7y agopff, considering that a large number of two factor authentication protocols send you SMS your phone number might just as well be your bank account
- moron4hire 7y agoI'm sorry you're getting downvoted to oblivion on this. There are two cohorts on HN: those who think you can do whatever the hell you want as long as you put "startup" in front of it, and those who think anything a company does is the end of the world. And while I suspect these two cohorts overlap a lot, today you've definitely gotten hit by the latter.
- ubercow13 7y agoI don’t think that’s anything to do with it. Suggesting that other people shouldn’t be bothered about their phone number being leaked is like trying to argue away their rights. Naturally when you do that, people react negatively.
- throwaway55554 7y agoJust because it's public doesn't mean it should be shared with everyone. You wouldn't type your number into a HN comment, would you? Probably not because you know exactly what would happen.
- AlexandrB 7y agoIt may be public, but I don't see you posting your phone number on HN. Perhaps that's because you don't want everyone in the world to have it? Doesn't seem like an unreasonable expectation to me.
- zepolen 7y agoWhat's your phone number?