4 ms·
I recommend people in the West to read more on the Yalta process. This single meeting was what set the fate of the world for the early cold war. The parallels
by baybal2 7y ago
I recommend people in the West to read more on the Yalta process. This single meeting was what set the fate of the world for the early cold war.
The parallels with today are just too much to ignore.
- mannykannot 7y agoI agree that it is well worth studying, but with the realization that much of what happened there, and afterwards, was determined by the realities of the strategic situation. For example, Stalin was going to occupy eastern Europe regardless of what transpired in Yalta.
- Spooky23 7y agoIt’s more an example of the fog of war and timing. If the Germans collapsed a few months later or the trinity test had happened earlier, the US would have had the opportunity for a lasting victory instead of a stalemate. Once available, the US was very willing to use its monopoly to wave the baton of atomic destruction. The constraints of finishing off Japan and the possibility of open war with the Soviets would have been very different.
- JadeNB 7y ago> … the US would have had the opportunity for a lasting victory instead of a stalemate. I am sure I'm missing the point, but the US (together with the other allies) did achieve a lasting victory. It surely wasn't a theoretically optimal victory, but it was unquestionably lasting (for about 70 years, apparently). Am I factually wrong, did I misinterpret your meaning, or is it something else?
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI agree that it was a very important process but what are the parallels with today? I think the current situation is more like 1920s and 1930s.
- epicureanideal 7y agoI'd be interested to hear in what ways you think it's similar to the 1920s and 1930s.
- i_haz_rabies 7y agoFraying alliances, inequality, out-of-date military doctrines, increasing American isolationism, increasing polarization, rising fascism, tension in Europe, tension in East Asia, tension between established powers and new powers...
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI think in the 1920s you saw a decay of established institutions, recession and consequently the rise of populists like the nazis. I think it’s very similar to that right now. A lot of people think that the system is not working for them anymore. That leaves an opening for strong leaders that explain everything by blaming problems on “others”. You see that with trump and also a lot of countries in Europe. Yalta was about rebuilding a world system. Right now we have to be careful about existing systems falling apart.
- redis_mlc 7y ago> I think in the 1920s you saw a decay of established institutions, ... No. The inter-war period was just a lull, as Germany was not occupied and did not feel defeated. The onerous reparations actually incentived Germany to re-ignite WW1 into WW2. Britain and France might as well have asked for it. > A lot of people think that the system is not working for them anymore. Rulers don't care about people, especially Trump. Study the de Vos appointment to understand how profoundly an oligarch he is.
- Spooky23 7y agoThere’s more to it than just Germany. The postwar disillusionment with the old order and the boom/bust was amplified by things like radio and telephone. The world moved faster, and that brought good and bad things. That’s what worries me... our institutions haven’t caught up with the internet.
- handedness 7y agoSome would argue that it was Bretton Woods in '44 which set the fate of the Cold War (and beyond), including setting the stage for Yalta in '45.