4 ms·
> Perhaps a rule that anyone in a decisionmaking position who earned over $1m total comp last year is partially liable for fines against the company? Limited l
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> Perhaps a rule that anyone in a decisionmaking position who earned over $1m total comp last year is partially liable for fines against the company?
Limited liability is almost always irrelevant to megacorps, because they're large enough that any given liability doesn't actually bankrupt them. Which also means that managers in a company that size would still expect it to never happen and it wouldn't impact their behavior, and they would just carry insurance against it anyway.
On top of that, it doesn't even really help the victims, because if you have a claim which can bankrupt a $100B corporation, the few million in additional assets you could get from the managers is a rounding error.
If you're really trying to affect behavior, criminal penalties for the managers would tend to be more effective, but they also tend to already exist in cases of malice rather than negligence. Negligence tends to be punished with financial penalties rather than prison, and then we're back to the money getting paid by the corporation itself or insurance.
- admax88q 7y ago> they would just carry insurance against it anyway. A lot of people in this thread keep citing insurance, as if you can _just carry_ insurance for anything. This completely ignores the actual insurance companies in the equation. Insurance companies are not limitless pits of funds, they won't just give insurance to anyone for anything. If a manager has a track record of damaging behaviour or works in an industry that does obvious harm, why would somebody give them insurance? People are talking like the results are useless unless it personally bankrupts the managers responsible, the goal is not to hurt the person responsible as much as possible, its to actually provide compensation for victims, and provide a market force to reduce harmful behaviour. You can't just "get insurance" for anything. If you were legally liable for harms, and you had a track record of harmful decisions or work in a obviously harmful industries, then the insurance companies are unlikely to provide you insurance or will charge you high enough premiums that those who are more responsible or do safer work are economically advantaged.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> If a manager has a track record of damaging behaviour or works in an industry that does obvious harm, why would somebody give them insurance? If a manager has a track record of damaging behaviour or works in an industry that does obvious harm, why would somebody hire them? The liability to the corporation as things are now is the same as what it would be to the insurance company. And that's assuming that actuarially the people who have made mistakes in the past are more likely to make them in the future. Maybe the people who have made mistakes in the past are the people who have learned what not to do and are a safer choice than someone with less experience, or at least are not sufficiently more risky that the difference in insurance premiums would be prohibitively large. > People are talking like the results are useless unless it personally bankrupts the managers responsible, the goal is not to hurt the person responsible as much as possible, its to actually provide compensation for victims, and provide a market force to reduce harmful behaviour. Making the managers responsible for corporate liability doesn't do much for victims because the managers typically have far less money than the corporation itself. All it can really do is try to motivate the managers to avoid the liability, but it doesn't even do that when it's the insurance company and not the manager that pays in the event of liability anyway.
- admax88q 7y agoYou're ignoring the fact that shell corporations used as liability shields are widespread. Look at all those abandoned oil wells that nobody will pay to clean up because the corporations that owned them don't exist anymore. Managers have assets, insurance companies have assets, shell corporations designed to shield other corporations and managers do not have any assets. > And that's assuming that actuarially the people who have made mistakes in the past are more likely to make them in the future. Moreso I'm assuming that the actual actuaries will be incentivized to assess this correctly when somebody actual has to pay when things go bad.
- bpt3 7y ago> Limited liability is almost always irrelevant to megacorps, because they're large enough that any given liability doesn't actually bankrupt them. And that's what needs to change, not the concept of limited liability itself.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> And that's what needs to change, not the concept of limited liability itself. Suppose you go to a drive through and order a coffee. The restaurant is negligent; their coffee is unreasonably hot, the lids they use don't seal well and their employee spills the coffee on you. You get second and third degree burns, sue them and get awarded a million dollars. If it was a mom and pop restaurant, they're bankrupt. Their restaurant isn't worth $1M but now they owe you that much and they don't have it so they go out of business. If it was a national chain, they make $1M less profit this year but none of their locations close. Maybe they fire that employee, start using better fitting lids on their coffee or don't serve it so hot anymore. Their behavior was the same, the liability was the same, the only difference is that they were big enough to pay the money without going bankrupt. That's not necessarily bad. Better that the victim gets the $1M they were awarded instead of something less than that. Better that the other employees who weren't negligent don't lose their jobs too. As long as the liability is enough to get them to fix the problem (or, ideally, to have predicted it and prevented it to begin with).
- bpt3 7y agoYes, I agree with all of that. I also don't think that allowing companies to externalize their costs (either implicitly or explicitly) is beneficial to society, and that is why I said that the regulatory environment needs to change in scenarios where that's not the case.