4 ms·
When a pharmaceutical company makes some opioids that kill people, it's my mom and her 401(k) account that should be liable? And this will reduce inequality?
by kube-system 7y ago
When a pharmaceutical company makes some opioids that kill people, it's my mom and her 401(k) account that should be liable? And this will reduce inequality?
Not sure I'm buying that one.
- Geeek 7y agoI mean, she profited when the company sold all the opioids that caused the stock to go up, why should she be off the hook on the negative end?
- kube-system 7y agoShe didn't realize any profit if she still holds the stock. But that technicality aside, we already do hold her liable, but only to the amount of her investment. The point of my comment is, why would increasing her liability (from the amount of her investment, to everything she owns) decrease inequality?
- flyingfences 7y ago> we already do hold her liable, but only to the amount of her investment That's the thing, though - we don't. Her liability is limited to effectively zero. Her investment may lose value, but that is another risk entirely. If the company in which she is invested goes bankrupt with a billion dollar debt, she isn't on the hook for a penny of it.
- bpt3 7y agoHer 401(k) should definitely be liable, in that her investment in a company that arguably shouldn't be allowed to exist is lost. She should not be personally liable as she had no direct part in the decision to make opioids that kill people.
- gmiller123456 7y ago>my mom and her 401(k) account that should be liable? That shows one of the really big problems with 401k's, you pretty much get no say in what companies you invest in. Worse, you usually can't even get information about what companies you invest in.
- kube-system 7y agoI've never had a 401(k) where I couldn't get a prospectus for a fund that I'm invested in. And I've had some shitty 401(k)s