2 ms·
I don't see that conflation nor that misunderstanding. > not connected to limited liability [like] pollution I'm pretty sure that's in reference to things lik
by eesmith 7y ago
I don't see that conflation nor that misunderstanding.
> not connected to limited liability [like] pollution
I'm pretty sure that's in reference to things like https://indyweek.com/news/legal-maneuver-absolve-duke-energy-responsibility-coal-ash-dumps/ https://indyweek.com/news/legal-maneuver-absolve-duke-energy... where a company offloads its pollution liabilities to an under-capitalized LLC:
] In most cases, the landowner would be legally liable for such damages. But the owner of the abandoned brick mine is not Duke Energy; it's Green Meadow LLC, a new corporation led by the president of Charah Inc., a Kentucky ash disposal company contracting with Duke on the coal ash project.
] Once Charah takes possession of the ash, Duke may not be responsible for the waste, legal experts say, a contingency that may be part of Duke's private contract with Charah.
] And if Green Meadow or Charah does not have the money to pay damages emanating from a lawsuit, then county governments and the state not Duke Energy may be ultimately forced to pay, legal experts say.
> misunderstands limited and zero liability
I find it hard to believe that "Katharina Pistor, Professor of Comparative Law at Columbia Law School, [and] author of The Code of Capital: How the Law Creates Wealth and Inequality." understands the topic worse than an HN commenter.
> pretending the former is the later
I don't see that. For example, Pistor writes "The corporate entity itself might face liability, perhaps even bankruptcy, but the shareholders can walk away from the wreckage, profits in hand."
That distinguishes between limited and zero liability.
A quick look (following the links) finds several papers related to piercing the corporate veil. Eg https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1517428&rec=1&srcabs=1871173&pos=2 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1517428&... describes how the inability to pierce the corporate veil may "improperly shield irresponsible business owners."
- LatteLazy 7y agoJust FYI, on the Green Meadow point, companies are already required to show that when they transfer liabilities like this, the entity transfered to is "properly funded". People can argue over what level of funding is required, but there are funding requirements. The article itself even mentions higher funding requirements when the EPA classes waste as a Hazardous etc. If that we're not the case, llcs would be a sort of crazy loophole to dump problems and walk away. But it's not. We already have a whole web of regulations, most based around requiring insurance and regulating insurer risk profiles... In answer to you the "profits in hands" quote, I think that's misrepresentation because its incredibly rare. How many times does someone invest in a company, magically get more than their investment back in cash and then the company goes bankrupt and have it all happen so quickly that it's fraud rather than just 10 years of success and failure? The article doesn't give even 1 example of that. Also to take advantage of limited liability a dividend needs to be properly declared and paid. Companies that realise they have major liabilities can't do that. That's why they don't. So the article pretends you can just wait till pay day, liquidate everything and throw the money over the fence and you get away with it.
- eesmith 7y ago> The article doesn't give even 1 example of that Though it does link to https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1871173 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1871173 "The Modern Law of Corporate Groups: An Empirical Study of Piercing the Corporate Veil in the Parent-Subsidiary Context" ] Empirical analysis treating the application of substantive piercing doctrine to the parent-subsidiary context is virtually nonexistent. This Article begins to fill that void. The underlying project is an empirical analysis of piercing the corporate veil in the parent-subsidiary context. The Article's first objective is to describe statistically the propensities of modern courts for piercing the corporate veil in the parent-subsidiary situation. Its second objective is to use advanced statistical techniques to explore potential causal relationships regarding piercing the veil in the parent-subsidiary context. Both of these objectives are unique to this study. The hope is that courts, commentators, and practitioners may be better equipped to understand and predict under what circumstances a court is likely to exercise its equitable discretion and hold a parent company liable. Fraud or misrepresentation was discussed in 46.4% (n=167) of the piercing cases, and found to be present in 7.2% (n=26) of them. (See page 1128.) Undercapitalization (which I mentioned) was in 44 of those cases. So examples are out there.
- LatteLazy 7y agoThat's fine, but those are cases where by definition they were caught doing things that are NOT allowed. The article's point is that you can off load your liabilities and keep the profits perfectly legally. Those cases prove that isn't true.
- cmendel 7y agoBut you are moving the goalposts now. You: > The article doesn't give even 1 example of that GP: > It does. You: > but They weren't supposed to. Me: They did though.
- LatteLazy 7y agoNo, the article gives no examples of how companies can walk away from their liability by legally abusing llcs. It links to an article with examples of the opposite, disproving the very thing the author claims.