6 ms·
The article conflates a lot of things that are not connected to limited liability (unsafe airplanes and pollution!?). And it misunderstands limited and zero lia
by LatteLazy 7y ago
The article conflates a lot of things that are not connected to limited liability (unsafe airplanes and pollution!?). And it misunderstands limited and zero liability, pretending the former is the later? Then it fails to understand liability all together.
I understand why there is a human need to hold someone accountable for everything. But that's not realistically possible. Trying or pretending it is leads to very weird results (like the article)
There are so many failures here, I'd go as far as to call it "not even wrong". It's just a mess of accusations and (incorrect) assertions. The cynic in me wonders if its intended to just appeal to people's prejudices. But maybe I'm just cynical...
- pmiller2 7y agoYou are misreading or misrepresenting what the article says. It is arguing that “limited liability” for shareholders de facto means “zero liability” for anything the company does. While that’s not strictly true, a shareholder in a public company indeed suffers no consequences for said company’s actions other than potential loss of their initial investment. The author is saying this is insufficient, as it leads to companies taking legal risks like building unsafe airplanes and causing pollution. Does this not reflect the world outside your window? When I can put money into a company, then sit on it over a period of years and just watch it grow, what’s my incentive to prevent the company from doing bad things? When I can do that for hundreds of companies at a time, in the form of an index fund or ETF, and be virtually assured my money will grow over the long term, why would I do anything to prevent the company from taking risks? TL;DR: “Zero liability” is not zero, it’s just so small it doesn’t discourage bad behavior.
- metalliqaz 7y ago"taking risks" isn't even strong enough. "doing harm." a capitalist system is a system by and for capital, and if capital isn't held to account for harm, it will never do anything to prevent that harm (the harm is almost always inflicted on those without capital). in fact, there is incentive to do more harm if it is profitable.
- voxic11 7y agoBut limited liability comes into play in none of his examples which is why he appears to be conflating issues. All of the examples he gives are of companies which had enough money to cover their liabilities (none of them went bankrupt due to the example misconduct). So it appears that the issue is with liability in general, not limited liability in specific.
- pmiller2 7y agoLimited liability is what makes people want to continue investing in Boeing after they made a plane prone to crashing, and Exxon after they leak millions of gallons of oil into the ocean. You can, and I think do, argue that those companies should have more liability for those things, perhaps in the form of prison sentences for negligence, or, at least, increased fines, but limited liability is what ultimately keeps the company going for the long term, in spite of what they’ve done.
- voxic11 7y agoBut Boeing and Exxon both are still around and still profitable and did not need to fall back on the principle of limited liability to protect their shareholders. So if anything that would indicate to me as a shareholder that both companies are not that bad at quantifying risk. Limited liability makes it less risky to invest in smaller, less established companies. Those with well established histories like Boeing and Exxon seem like they would actually be helped by eliminating limited liability as they have long histories of not needing to use it.
- pmiller2 7y agoYou're missing the point. If I could suffer unlimited liability beyond my initial investment for things Exxon does, why would I invest? What would happen to Exxon if everyone thought that way?
- dahfizz 7y agoPeople would stop being able to retire because any and all investment has become infinitly risky. That's what would happen.
- hogFeast 7y agoHow is losing money suffering no consequences? (I can tell you that I worked in investment management and sat in meetings where this kind of thing was discussed...no-one thinks this, companies that do bad things lose money...end...SRI is something that the good managers always did, it is just branded so bad managers can make money. Index funds are making it easier on companies but...that is a choice people are making to separate stewardship from their portfolio management).
- pmiller2 7y ago> a shareholder in a public company indeed suffers no consequences for said company’s actions other than potential loss of their initial investment. I didn't say "no consequences." I said the consequences were too small.
- hogFeast 7y ago...compared to what...you have lost 100% of what you put in. Any other system is about wealth transfer...it is generally not advisable to attempt to transfer wealth this way, there are unintended consequences.
- pmiller2 7y agoThe consequences are too small compared to what would be needed to prevent Exxon dumping millions of barrels of oil into the ocean. Who cares if it’s wealth transfer, anyway? If I lose my initial investment in a company, that money goes somewhere, right? Ergo, what we have is already a form of wealth transfer.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 7y agoCounterpoint: as a Boeing investor, exactly how much foreknowledge of and ability to prevent the 737 MAX disaster would you have had?
- tpm 7y agoYou probably wouldn't want to invest into something unknown if you then were liable for damages caused by it. Which is, I think, the point of the article.
- pmiller2 7y agoIt doesn’t matter, because all I can lose is my initial investment. That’s the point.
- bpt3 7y agoYou aren't virtually assured your money will grow over the long term, especially if you only invest in companies that make mistakes on the scale of Exxon and Boeing. It seems like your post is based on this premise, which isn't accurate. Also, I don't think anyone misunderstands what the author is saying, as it's very clear. It just makes no sense, isn't supported by the examples she brings up, and the proposed solution would do significant harm.
- pmiller2 7y agoYou are virtually assured your money will grow over time if you invest in enough companies. That’s the reason VCs and index funds exist.
- bpt3 7y ago1. No, you aren't "virtually assured". Past performance indicates that's the case over enough time (25+ years), but that isn't an assurance. 2. I'm not sure how this supports your argument, as an index fund investor is even more removed from the decision making process that leads to some sort of disaster.
- pmiller2 7y agoTake a look here and get back to me: https://www.slickcharts.com/sp500/returns https://www.slickcharts.com/sp500/returns You don't need to go to a 25 year time horizon to have a very high chance of making money. By my count, the S&P only lost money in 20 out of the past 94 years. According to https://www.thebalance.com/rolling-index-returns-1973-mid-2009-4061795 https://www.thebalance.com/rolling-index-returns-1973-mid-20..., there was no rolling 15 year period since 1973 where the index lost money. The index lost money in only 11 of 80 rolling 10 year periods from 1928-2008.
- bpt3 7y agoYes, I'm aware. I picked 25 years because that's about how long it took for the market to surpass the highs just prior to the Great Depression. My point, since you seem to keep missing it, is that "a very high chance" is not the same as "virtually assured", and "virtually assured" is not the same as "guaranteed", yet you seem to be conflating these concepts, as well as minimizing the current consequences of investing in an irresponsible company (losing your investment).
- js8 7y ago> I understand why there is a human need to hold someone accountable for everything You're right, there has to be a balance between punishment and forgiveness.
- jdmichal 7y agoThe basic premise seems simple and not-wrong enough: External costs are not borne by shareholders, so they are not priced into the market. I mean, that's kind of the definition of externality. Everything else is hot garbage, though. I don't understand why the shareholders are being dragged into this at all... Suddenly making millions of people partially liable for the acts of the company would result in nothing other than panicked crashes. Not to mention things like index funds suddenly becoming untenable -- imagine liability to the entire stock market?! And that to me is enough to confirm that this is barking up the wrong tree, because index funds are one of the best things to happen to the investment market for the average person. The answer is to internalize the costs to the corporation, so that the market can properly reflect them just like every other cost. This works fine, and doesn't destroy the very nature of the market or shareholding. EDIT: I mean this broadly. Not just carbon taxes and other classic examples of externalities. But also things like proper fines against damages discovered in court. Currently fines seem flatter than they should be. They're often enough to completely shutter a small company, but when scaled up often don't even negate the potential profits for megacorps.
- eesmith 7y agoI don't see that conflation nor that misunderstanding. > not connected to limited liability [like] pollution I'm pretty sure that's in reference to things like https://indyweek.com/news/legal-maneuver-absolve-duke-energy-responsibility-coal-ash-dumps/ https://indyweek.com/news/legal-maneuver-absolve-duke-energy... where a company offloads its pollution liabilities to an under-capitalized LLC: ] In most cases, the landowner would be legally liable for such damages. But the owner of the abandoned brick mine is not Duke Energy; it's Green Meadow LLC, a new corporation led by the president of Charah Inc., a Kentucky ash disposal company contracting with Duke on the coal ash project. ] Once Charah takes possession of the ash, Duke may not be responsible for the waste, legal experts say, a contingency that may be part of Duke's private contract with Charah. ] And if Green Meadow or Charah does not have the money to pay damages emanating from a lawsuit, then county governments and the state not Duke Energy may be ultimately forced to pay, legal experts say. > misunderstands limited and zero liability I find it hard to believe that "Katharina Pistor, Professor of Comparative Law at Columbia Law School, [and] author of The Code of Capital: How the Law Creates Wealth and Inequality." understands the topic worse than an HN commenter. > pretending the former is the later I don't see that. For example, Pistor writes "The corporate entity itself might face liability, perhaps even bankruptcy, but the shareholders can walk away from the wreckage, profits in hand." That distinguishes between limited and zero liability. A quick look (following the links) finds several papers related to piercing the corporate veil. Eg https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1517428&rec=1&srcabs=1871173&pos=2 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1517428&... describes how the inability to pierce the corporate veil may "improperly shield irresponsible business owners."
- LatteLazy 7y agoJust FYI, on the Green Meadow point, companies are already required to show that when they transfer liabilities like this, the entity transfered to is "properly funded". People can argue over what level of funding is required, but there are funding requirements. The article itself even mentions higher funding requirements when the EPA classes waste as a Hazardous etc. If that we're not the case, llcs would be a sort of crazy loophole to dump problems and walk away. But it's not. We already have a whole web of regulations, most based around requiring insurance and regulating insurer risk profiles... In answer to you the "profits in hands" quote, I think that's misrepresentation because its incredibly rare. How many times does someone invest in a company, magically get more than their investment back in cash and then the company goes bankrupt and have it all happen so quickly that it's fraud rather than just 10 years of success and failure? The article doesn't give even 1 example of that. Also to take advantage of limited liability a dividend needs to be properly declared and paid. Companies that realise they have major liabilities can't do that. That's why they don't. So the article pretends you can just wait till pay day, liquidate everything and throw the money over the fence and you get away with it.