3 ms·
Ooo, this is fascinating. What's your syllabus? I'd love to understand the economics of buying this kind of software, versus buying lots of niche software versu
by tootie 7y ago
Ooo, this is fascinating. What's your syllabus? I'd love to understand the economics of buying this kind of software, versus buying lots of niche software versus hiring a services firm to build versus hybrid approaches.
- hef19898 7y agoNot the Op nor teaching in this field. Back the day I worked for a couple of years as super key user for SAP, modules MM and PP (material amangement / demand planning and production planning). The one, unbeatable, benefit SAP (or similar monolithic ERP systems) offers is compliance. As every single process is connected to other processes the whole system is auditable and compliant to any tax or accounting legislation out there. Same goes for industry specific things like serial numbers (crucial in aerospace where I used to work). You will never get that by combining nieche products. Not if you aren't willing to create your own in-house developer department. And that will have to be on par with SAPs. Downside, then, is of course that you get zero benefit from improvements out of other companies. Something you will ultimately get using SAP for example. IMHO, SAP makes perfectly sense if you are a big company with an in-house production. Than you hugely beenfit from SAPs MRP-core, which you need anyway. On-top you get the other modules integrated in the same system. Without production? I would stay away from it. For my own company, managing logistics and service providers for clients, I opted for another software solution. There is no production to manage, and SAPs solutions for pure logistics, warehousing and transportation but also customs and such things, other providers are way better. Hybrids can make sense. Customs can be done outside SAP. Same goes for transportation and warehousing. But then interfaces become an issue. Doable, yes. But added complexity and failure modes. It's a trade off between functionality and complexity in these cases. For production management (classic MRP), I have yet to see something better then SAP. MS Dynamics doesn't look to bad, but I never actually worked with it.